Maybin holdout

[billnutinphoenix]

Maybin= Jax's DE Derrick Harvey....Lost 1st year due to late signing....

[BuffaloRebound]

He has a DORK for an agent and he is too stupid to see the disservice his agent is giving him. Looks like the Bills need to start looking at who the agent is as well as skills. This guy had ONE good season in college and is holding out thinking he is a Bruce Smith or something. The NFL needs a rookie cap !!!

 

Could not agree more. I don't condone Crabtree's holdout, but at least the guy dominated the college level for the 2 years he played. The problem lies in Maybin and his agent thinking their situation has anything to do with Crabtree's. If the 1st round was structured like free agency, Crabtree most likely would have commanded a lot more money than Maybin. Take a little more than Orakpo and what McKelvin got, be happy cause that's way more than a guy who is all about upside is worth, and start playing football.

[Thurman#1]

Read "Lords or the Realm." Its about the history of Baseball and labor. All it takes is one Al Davis/Haywood-Bey and it is off to the races. I would want all the money i could make given the circumstances as they are, and teams have little leverage when it comes to the draft picks. It is insane when rookies make more than proven vets. Insane! There needs to be a realistic system in place that makes these guys earn their dime.

 

 

 

Depends on the rookie and the proven vet.

 

Who do you want on your team, rookie Aaron Curry or proven vet Coy Wire?

 

Rookie Jason Smith or proven vet Dennis Roland (Bengals 2nd stringer)?

 

You know what I mean. The kids at the top of the college class deserve a lot of money. But yeah, there should be some kind of rookie cap to keep things from getting too ridiculous.

[Thoner7]

My sense is that the Bills might try to defend themselves by saying that you and they have difference in drafting philosophy. They might describe your approach as yes being a correct assessment of individual player skills, but the difference is they are not simply drafting talented individuals but they are drafting a team.

 

What this means may be two things that speak to picking a player like Byrd when he is available.

 

1. Particularly for the early rounds where players like Maybin and Byrd were taken team need trumps the issue of contract leverage for an individual, As far as safety goes the Bills likely saw themselves as relatively thin at this key position in the Cover 2. Sure they could pick Brown and get good leverage at DE, but this likely leaves them with starting a player like Scott who surprised with his play last year, but the face he was a surprise to do as well as he did shows we are lacking the game breaker in the longer run we need there,

 

2, Also as far as DL goes we actually probably have full house even with the use of a rotation and McCargo disappointing so far. We're still a year away from declaring him a bust. If he sticks this pre-season we likely are cutting two players who made the roster last year (Ellis and Bryan).

 

Add into this the heavy Bills emphasis on ST and having another safety capable player is more likely to provide ST help than Brown or a DL type player and the desire to build a team pushes the admitted greater contract leverage fpr a talented individual down on the priority list.

 

I think this is actually sound thinking the Bills problem has not been the strategy but actually the implementation and not picking the right team overall.

 

Your logic is flawed. As much as Dick trys, you just cant field a Defense of 11 DBs, it just wont work.

[seadog]

Can we trade him without signing him? I never liked the pick anyway. Seems like a better fit for a 3-4 OLB position to me.

[iinii]

Depends on the rookie and the proven vet.

 

Who do you want on your team, rookie Aaron Curry or proven vet Coy Wire?

 

Rookie Jason Smith or proven vet Dennis Roland (Bengals 2nd stringer)?

 

You know what I mean. The kids at the top of the college class deserve a lot of money. But yeah, there should be some kind of rookie cap to keep things from getting too ridiculous.

Coy Wire, a proven vet? Sanchez will make more than Brady under their latest contracts. You would call Tom Brady a proven vet, wouldn't you?

[jethro_tull]

Can we trade him without signing him? I never liked the pick anyway. Seems like a better fit for a 3-4 OLB position to me.

 

 

Aha! That's Dick's plan for next year! He's sick of going 0 for in the division against the 3-4 defense and might as well "join them".

 

PS Maybin is awesome off the line, the quickest burst in the draft. He's a keeper.

[atlbillsfan1975]

Depends on the rookie and the proven vet.

 

Who do you want on your team, rookie Aaron Curry or proven vet Coy Wire?

 

Rookie Jason Smith or proven vet Dennis Roland (Bengals 2nd stringer)?

 

You know what I mean. The kids at the top of the college class deserve a lot of money. But yeah, there should be some kind of rookie cap to keep things from getting too ridiculous.

wow, so you like to argue for arguements sake? I mean really.

It is crazy when Jake Long gets to be the highest paid offensive lineman before he has ever played a down. How someone played in college is relevant, but for each position i am sure we could give an example of a guy who was thought to be a 'lock' all pro, and busted out.

Haveing said all that i am not mad at Maybin, how many of us would go to work with out compensation, get injured and be unable to perform, and then get sent home. All with out getting a penny. The owners and players assoc. have to fix this problem once and for all.

[Buffaloed in Pa]

Can we trade him without signing him? I never liked the pick anyway. Seems like a better fit for a 3-4 OLB position to me.

My sons friend just walked in. He has seen maybin a few times ,last time was i n early june at the waffle house in State Colledge. Apparantly he had classes with his girlfriend. Anyway he swears this dude is small and is not even 6-3 . My sons friend is Almost 6-3 and he says Maybin is shorter than him. He says he has a decent size chect and arms no bigger than my sons. Although my son at 5-11 190 does lift alot.. He just cannot believe this guy is a 1st rd pick at De or LB with his size. Time will tell.

[Beerball]

20 first rounders unsigned, no problem

 

15 first rounders unsigned, no problem

 

10 first rounders unsigned, beginning to be a problem

 

5 first rounders unsigned, problem

 

3 first rounders unsigned, problem

 

 

Whether it's the FO, Maybin or Maybin's people the guy has missed a bunch of camp. I suppose if all he is going to be assigned to do is rush the passer then not really a big deal, but we're probably not going to get much more than that from him.

 

Has the team put thoughts of having him play in a 2 point stance (if they really planned that) been shelved for this year?

[Buffalo Mike1]

My sons friend just walked in. He has seen maybin a few times ,last time was i n early june at the waffle house in State Colledge. Apparantly he had classes with his girlfriend. Anyway he swears this dude is small and is not even 6-3 . My sons friend is Almost 6-3 and he says Maybin is shorter than him. He says he has a decent size chect and arms no bigger than my sons. Although my son at 5-11 190 does lift alot.. He just cannot believe this guy is a 1st rd pick at De or LB with his size. Time will tell.

Guess your son didn't watch Bruce Smith's Hall of Fame Speech.....

[Buffaloed in Pa]

Guess your son didn't watch Bruce Smith's Hall of Fame Speech.....

Yeah Time will tell if Money Maybin was watching also ....Duh.

[The Dean]

How many of these numb-nuts threads have their been?

 

1. Maybin is not holding out. He and the Bills have yet to agree on a contract. BIG difference.

 

2. Maybin won't be getting more money than his draft position deserves.

 

3. Maybin is likely to play in three preseason games (two at the least). Fairly typical for a player drafted toward the front end of the first round.

 

But I'm sure the sky MUST be falling.

[The Senator]

3. Maybin is likely to play in three preseason games (two at the least). Fairly typical for a player drafted toward the front end of the first round.

That's probably more preparation than Jason Peters will get.

[Flbillsfan#1]

Could not agree more. I don't condone Crabtree's holdout, but at least the guy dominated the college level for the 2 years he played. The problem lies in Maybin and his agent thinking their situation has anything to do with Crabtree's. If the 1st round was structured like free agency, Crabtree most likely would have commanded a lot more money than Maybin. Take a little more than Orakpo and what McKelvin got, be happy cause that's way more than a guy who is all about upside is worth, and start playing football.

He also suffered a foot injury which many players never fully recover from, especially receivers.

[Beerball]

How many of these numb-nuts threads have their been?

 

1. Maybin is not holding out. He and the Bills have yet to agree on a contract. BIG difference.

But I'm sure the sky MUST be falling.

The sky is most assuredly not falling, but to consider that the difference between a hold out and an unsigned rookie is BIG is silly.

 

He aint there however you define the circumstances.

[John from Riverside]

How many of these numb-nuts threads have their been?

 

1. Maybin is not holding out. He and the Bills have yet to agree on a contract. BIG difference.

 

2. Maybin won't be getting more money than his draft position deserves.

 

3. Maybin is likely to play in three preseason games (two at the least). Fairly typical for a player drafted toward the front end of the first round.

 

But I'm sure the sky MUST be falling.

 

Dean,

 

I am kinda getting frustrated as well at this point......if they have a figure that he is in the ball park with all of the signings around the 11 position except for Crabtree.......what is the hold up.

 

My mind wanders to either

 

- The bills are offering less then they should

or

- Maybins agent is being stupid

[The Dean]

The sky is most assuredly not falling, but to consider that the difference between a hold out and an unsigned rookie is BIG is silly.

 

He aint there however you define the circumstances.

 

 

Holding out means a player, under contract, is refusing to come to work (because he wants a bigger contract). In this case, the player is the one who is shirking his contractual obligation.

 

In the case of an unsigned draft pick, there can be no holdout because there is no job for the player to come to. We don't know which side is holding up the deal, or for what reasons.

 

If the major holdup is strictly monetary, the difference is somewhere around $500,000, maybe $1 Million. They will eventually just split the difference...no? But it could be about how the payments are structured.

 

According to a radio report I heard down here, the Jags were close to signing Monroe a week or so ago, with the guaranteed money at $19 Million. But somehow, because the way the contract and payments were structured, the guaranteed money was REALLY $16 million. That pissed off the agent, and the deal went sour. They finally signed Monroe to a deal at $19 guaranteed (actually a bit low for that spot). Now, I don't know if the report is true, but the source sounded pretty confident of the info.

 

Most reports are Maybin is very close to signing. I have yet to hear reports of animosity between the sides. I'm guessing Segal has been a little busy with Vick, and is probably getting down to the nuts-and-bolts of the Maybin deal now.

 

But hey, I could be wrong.

[Buffaloed in Pa]

Dean,

 

I am kinda getting frustrated as well at this point......if they have a figure that he is in the ball park with all of the signings around the 11 position except for Crabtree.......what is the hold up.

 

My mind wanders to either

 

- The bills are offering less then they should

or

- Maybins agent is being stupid

Exactly What is the hold up ???MONEY. Lots& Lots of MONEY>

[Stussy109]

Maybin needs extra bread to pay for Lavar Arrington's marketing skills