Got_Wood Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 Yes, this is a crazy pipe dream. But there might be a GM out there that would pull this off... just not ours... because we don't have one. Adam Schefter believes that there will be a big problem in Philly this offseason when McNabb asks for an extension on his deal. http://www.rotoworld.com/content/playerpag...=NFL&id=704 Would this move make sense for us? Ego for ego. That would suck for Trent. McNabb would probably ask for his jersey number too Just a thought.
RayFinkle Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 Did Madden approve or reject this trade when you tried it?
Got_Wood Posted January 27, 2009 Author Posted January 27, 2009 I called Madden up myself. He liked it.
silvermike Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 Wow...that's the worst trade idea I've seen yet.
ajzepp Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 He's signed through 2013 and he wants an extension? Pfft...please.
lets_go_bills Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 This is almost as bad as that "Lynch for Boldin" thread.
TheLynchTrain Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 This is almost as bad as that "Lynch for Boldin" thread. worse
SKOOBY Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 We have a great / young QB now, so I like the Boldin thread more.
Jim in Anchorage Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 Bad enough we have the most famous missed kick in SB history. Now we can have the most famous throwing up GB in SB history.
Nightcrawler Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 We have a great / young QB now, so I like the Boldin thread more. This trade was plausible about 2 months ago with the McNabb benching, but Philadelphia's success coupled with McNabb's relationship with Andy Reid will never allow this to happen. Philadelphia currently is too smart of a franchise to even consider this as an option.
H2o Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 This is almost as bad as that "Lynch for Boldin" thread. worse Agreed. This thread is definitely worse.
Magox Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 Agreed. This thread is definitely worse. It's a toss up
muddy waters Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 Anybody who lives in the Philly area and sees too many Eagles games will tell you that McNabb can be a very good quarterback about 70 percent of the time, but that he is just horrible the remaining 30 percent. He has a lot of bad games. Absolutely, this trade would be a disaster for the Bills. Please please forget the idea of trading Peters. Sign him and keep him. He will mature as he gets older and be the keystone in the o-line.
Got_Wood Posted January 27, 2009 Author Posted January 27, 2009 Oh yes, definitely a disaster. I would HATE to bring in a QB who has been to the pro bowl 5 times, played in 5 NFC championships and 1 superbowl, one time offensive player of the year, and sure fire hall of famer. This might be a stupid thread (I know, I posted it), but it's hilarious that you WOULDN'T want him on this team. We would be allergic to success if we didn't take that trade.
lets_go_bills Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 Oh yes, definitely a disaster. I would HATE to bring in a QB who has been to the pro bowl 5 times, played in 5 NFC championships and 1 superbowl, one time offensive player of the year, and sure fire hall of famer. This might be a stupid thread (I know, I posted it), but it's hilarious that you WOULDN'T want him on this team. We would be allergic to success if we didn't take that trade. 1. He's not an HoFer. Not even close. 2. Of course we'd want him. But not for Peters. 3. We are allergic to success regardless.
PromoTheRobot Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 Yes, this is a crazy pipe dream. But there might be a GM out there that would pull this off... just not ours... because we don't have one. Adam Schefter believes that there will be a big problem in Philly this offseason when McNabb asks for an extension on his deal. http://www.rotoworld.com/content/playerpag...=NFL&id=704 Would this move make sense for us? Ego for ego. That would suck for Trent. McNabb would probably ask for his jersey number too Just a thought. When you say pipe dream do you mean you took a big hit off your hooka when you thought this one up? PTR
PromoTheRobot Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 Oh yes, definitely a disaster. I would HATE to bring in a QB who has been to the pro bowl 5 times, played in 5 NFC championships and 1 superbowl, one time offensive player of the year, and sure fire hall of famer. This might be a stupid thread (I know, I posted it), but it's hilarious that you WOULDN'T want him on this team. We would be allergic to success if we didn't take that trade. Your right...he WAS good. Call me weird but I like getting players who are still good. PTR
BillnutinHouston Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 The last time we brought in an over-the-hill player was when Donahoe acquired Drew Bledsoe on draft day. We all know how well that turned out. We ain't trading for any more over the hill players.
reddogblitz Posted January 27, 2009 Posted January 27, 2009 The last time we brought in an over-the-hill player was when Donahoe acquired Drew Bledsoe on draft day. We all know how well that turned out. We ain't trading for any more over the hill players. Got us our last winning season. 2004, that was fun season. Playing schmucks trying to learn on the job hasn't gotten us within 2 games of a winning season. 5-11, 7-9, 7-9, 7-9 If Philly will do that trade, do it in a heartbeat. Veteran leadership at QB is something this team desperately needs.
Recommended Posts