(OT) Fantasy Football question about trades...

[FTW_BillsFan]

I sent this guy a trade of

 

Favre and McAllister (my players)

 

for

 

Peyton Manning. (His player)

 

I thought I was giving him a little too much, but aren't those 2 players worth Manning?

 

Comments please.

 

TIA.

[EZC-Boston]

I think that's pretty fair, but you're talking to quite possibly the worst fantasy football owner of all time...

[KD in CA]

No way. Very bad trade. Rescind it if you can.

 

The delta between Manning and Farve is not that much; nowhere near enough to throw in a Top 5 back like McAllister. Who else do you have at RB?

[FTW_BillsFan]

Here is my team. I actually got McAllister off the waiver wire when someone cut him. All the owners in this league are not the smartest ppl in the world fantasy wise.

 

Also, I don't have to rescind the offer cause the guy rejected the trade. Oh, his RBs are: Fred Taylor, Amos Zereoue and Wheatley.

 

QB B. Favre

WR M. Harrison

WR Ro. Williams

RB C. Portis

RB E. Smith

TE E. Johnson

WR/RB T. Jones

BN B. Westbrook (RB)

BN D. Mason (WR)

BN D. McAllister (RB)

BN J. Harrington (QB)

BN D. Patten (WR)

BN D. Levens (RB)

K M. Vanderjagt

DEF New York

[Guest Fantasy Novice]

Would anyone make this trade:

M. Faulk for T. Holt

 

Current RB's include: S. Alexander, R. Droughns (sup draft on monday), W. Green, K. Jones, J. wells, C. Perry, M. Faulk

WR's: L. Coles, D. Stallworth, R. Caldwell (inj), T. Calico (inj), J. Morton, T. Glenn (inj), A. Hakim (inj)

[KD in CA]

Would anyone make this trade:

M. Faulk for T. Holt

 

Current RB's include: S. Alexander, R. Droughns (sup draft on monday), W. Green, K. Jones, J. wells, C. Perry, M. Faulk

WR's: L. Coles, D. Stallworth, R. Caldwell (inj), T. Calico (inj), J. Morton, T. Glenn (inj), A. Hakim (inj)

91270[/snapback]

 

Only if I was the one getting Holt. That team has plenty of RBs, no top flight WRs (Coles is a bust this year).