todd Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 Offensively..the call put everything on Losman and I don't think that should ever happen if the Bills wanted to win....Look on the bright side we are closer to being 6-10 than 9-7 and teasing us with "we are almost a playoff team".... So you don't think you should be able to trust a 5th year QB when the game is on the line? Do you smoke crack?
Golden Wheels Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 "It's not JP's fault. He's not getting good blocking." "It's not JP's fault. The coaches are calling bad plays." "It's not JP's fault. His receivers are dropping the ball." "It's not JP's fault. It's a leap year and there's a full moon tonight." "It's not JP's fault. The big car companies didn't get their bailout package." Have I forgotten any excuses?
kbuckley9091 Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 So you don't think you should be able to trust a 5th year QB when the game is on the line? Do you smoke crack? Not when the 5th year QB sucks and has never done anything to prove himself as a good QB! You give it to the guy who is running his heart out and having the game of his life....un-real..........
Fezmid Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 especially considering that there were only 2:00 left when the play began. There was 2:06. Which is why it was a good call -- incomplete pass, run, or pass all stop the clock at roughly 2 minutes. If we had just run the ball up the middle and not converted, everyone would say how we had no creativity and our coaches suck because of that.
Bmwolf21 Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 So you don't think you should be able to trust a 5th year QB when the game is on the line? Do you smoke crack? I don't think it has anything to do with trust. You have a player who is, by the most optimistic standard, a career backup and who has problems with a) trying to do to much, so he holds on to the ball too long and b) has issues with fumbles. Most coaches know their players' limitations and plan around them. That's what Dick and Turk needed to do here.
billnutinphoenix Posted December 14, 2008 Author Posted December 14, 2008 There was 2:06. Which is why it was a good call -- incomplete pass, run, or pass all stop the clock at roughly 2 minutes. But someone should have told him - IF YOU DON"T THE OPEN RECEIVER THEN GO!!!!
Bmwolf21 Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 There was 2:06. Which is why it was a good call -- incomplete pass, run, or pass all stop the clock at roughly 2 minutes. If we had just run the ball up the middle and not converted, everyone would say how we had no creativity and our coaches suck because of that. I see your point, but there is a time to be creative and aggressive and a time to be conservative and play ball-control offense. This was one of those times - pound the rock and take your chances with your franchise back, rather than trust your soon-to-be former backup QB.
bbills17 Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 with the bootleg he should have been instructed if you don't find the open man immediately, run for it...don't keep on looking.... Seriously would you shut up? Defending JP in this situation is sick. Nobody should have to TELL a 5th year QB anything, he should have a brain and know himself. I'm a high school football player and I was yelling from my couch to throw it away before the sack happened, THROW IT AWAY.
Brandon Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 So you don't think you should be able to trust a 5th year QB when the game is on the line? Do you smoke crack? If its a choice between your backup QB vs your RB who has 127 yards and is averaging 6 yards per carry, it doesn't seem like much of a decision to me. Realistically, the worst that would've been likely to happen is that Marshawn runs it twice, fails to pick up the first down, and the Bills punt back to the Jets with about 1:30 left and with the Jets having no timeouts left. JP deserves his share of the blame, mind you, but that was a horrid, awful, stupid playcall given the circumstances.
Fezmid Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 But someone should have told him - IF YOU DON"T THE OPEN RECEIVER THEN GO!!!! He needs to be told that? And how do you know he wasn't?
tbonehawaii Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 with the bootleg he should have been instructed if you don't find the open man immediately, run for it...don't keep on looking.... "should have been instructed"? he doesn't take instruction well. he would hav ebeen able to take this one: "hand the ball off to marshawn"
tbonehawaii Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 If its a choice between your backup QB vs your RB who has 127 yards and is averaging 6 yards per carry, it doesn't seem like much of a decision to me. Realistically, the worst that would've been likely to happen is that Marshawn runs it twice, fails to pick up the first down, and the Bills punt back to the Jets with about 1:30 left and with the Jets having no timeouts left. JP deserves his share of the blame, mind you, but that was a horrid, awful, stupid playcall given the circumstances. too true. i think that call sealed DJ and turk's fate
tbonehawaii Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 I see your point, but there is a time to be creative and aggressive and a time to be conservative and play ball-control offense. This was one of those times - pound the rock and take your chances with your franchise back, rather than trust your soon-to-be former backup QB. they rarely run outside even though it is usually successful
thebug Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 But someone should have told him - IF YOU DON"T THE OPEN RECEIVER THEN GO!!!! You seriously think he needs to be told that? what is he 10 years old? I wonder if they tell Lindell to put it through the uprights everytime he heads on the field?
billnutinphoenix Posted December 14, 2008 Author Posted December 14, 2008 Seriously would you shut up? Defending JP in this situation is sick. Nobody should have to TELL a 5th year QB anything, he should have a brain and know himself. I'm a high school football player and I was yelling from my couch to throw it away before the sack happened, THROW IT AWAY. He's a laughable QB okay...but this coaching staff is also about as lame as JP
Max997 Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 with the bootleg he should have been instructed if you don't find the open man immediately, run for it...don't keep on looking.... it was a horrible call and an extremely bad play by Losman
tbonehawaii Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 Seriously would you shut up? Defending JP in this situation is sick. Nobody should have to TELL a 5th year QB anything, he should have a brain and know himself. I'm a high school football player and I was yelling from my couch to throw it away before the sack happened, THROW IT AWAY. perfect storm of "all pro" peters wiffing helen keller at qb and play that never should have been called. i feel bad for jp but he is going to struggle to be a 3rd stringer somewhere next year
bisonbrigade Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 with the bootleg he should have been instructed if you don't find the open man immediately, run for it...don't keep on looking.... They probably did, but that was to many words for him to remember.
billnutinphoenix Posted December 14, 2008 Author Posted December 14, 2008 You seriously think he needs to be told that? what is he 10 years old? I wonder if they tell Lindell to put it through the uprights everytime he heads on the field? Anyone remember Donovan McNabb (who some people on this board want) didn't know about Overtime ending even if it's a tie...sometimes you have to tell some of these boneheads what to do... Has anyone ever looked at JP's Wonderlich score?
Bmwolf21 Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 they rarely run outside even though it is usually successful True. They've had some success on toss sweeps this year - it would seem that it might be a good time for that, or one of those fake-hand-off-quick-pitch plays. Or just something off tackle. Any running play would have been better than what they called. Heck, look at the unbalanced line the Jets rolled out and had Favre run the bootleg off on the first series. That would have been more than creative enough for me.
Recommended Posts