marioc Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 I just had a bad thought that if Trent somehow played very poorly the first couple of games would the fans and media start calling for him to be benched? How long of a leash do you think he should get? I would hate to see him benched too soon with no *good* alternatives waiting in the wings but I would also hate to see the Bills miss the playoffs again. By *good*, I mean consistently good, not does one good thing followed up by one or more extremely costly bone-headed things. Not naming any names or anything.....
Dan Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 I just had a bad thought that if Trent somehow played very poorly the first couple of games would the fans and media start calling for him to be benched? How long of a leash do you think he should get? I would hate to see him benched too soon with no *good* alternatives waiting in the wings but I would also hate to see the Bills miss the playoffs again. By *good*, I mean consistently good, not does one good thing followed up by one or more extremely costly bone-headed things. Not naming any names or anything..... Helllloooo..... Hamdan? The Chroise shall set us free.
MartyBall4Buffalo Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 If Edwards isn't good the bills aren't making the playoffs regardless, so it's a null argument. With that said. You give him the season. What If Edwards lights it up his first couple of games? And by *Lights it up* I mean the scoreboard. Same answer. You give him the season and judge the broad context of games, not the moment.
marioc Posted August 7, 2008 Author Posted August 7, 2008 Helllloooo..... Hamdan? The Chroise shall set us free. Have you ever seen Hamdan do anything, let alone anything good? But yes, that very well might be the rallying call come week 4. God, I hope not....
Heels20X6 Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 If Edwards isn't good the bills aren't making the playoffs regardless, so it's a null argument. With that said. You give him the season. What If Edwards lights it up his first couple of games? And by *Lights it up* I mean the scoreboard. Same answer. You give him the season and judge the broad context of games, not the moment. Agreed...for the love of all things holy, let him start every game he is physically capable of. The Bills decided the JP Experiment was over so now it is Trent's turn to rise and fall on his talent alone. The only acceptable way for JP to enter a game is injury and regardless of play, when Trent is ready, he gets his job back. No MORE QB CAROUSEL. If he fails, then the Bills are right back at where we started and we trade a first rounder for Colt Brennan based on his preseason play (JOKING!)
BillsFan-4-Ever Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 I just had a bad thought that if Trent somehow played very poorly the first couple of games would the fans and media start calling for him to be benched? How long of a leash do you think he should get? I would hate to see him benched too soon with no *good* alternatives waiting in the wings but I would also hate to see the Bills miss the playoffs again. By *good*, I mean consistently good, not does one good thing followed up by one or more extremely costly bone-headed things. Not naming any names or anything..... How is that any different from Losman losing 4 and 5 straight games in his 2nd season? Let's not panic and see what happens. Seattle and Jacksonville is the hard part of the schedule. Followed by Raiders, Rams and Cards. If the Bills are not at least 3-2 then we should start to worry and look at what the real reason is.
ricojes Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 What if Trent completely chokes the first couple games?, Quarterback controversy pt. 2? let's flash back to 2007, where the topic was: What if JP completely chokes the first couple games? Quarterback controversy? Sound familiar? Any team with a young unproven QB will be asking the what if questions? If the Bills believe TE is the QB of the future, they stick with him. Since they didn't bring a veteran QB into camp, I have to believe they are confident in his abilities. He will not get pulled for poor play this year...
bowery4 Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 I guess that the JP homers will call him on it. I vote to keep him in through thick and thin, he isn't JP in his 4th year. I hope for the best and will wait and see all season, if he can stay healthy.
Captain Hindsight Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 I want to see trent play the whole year. He better improve his game tho or it could be a long season
IDBillzFan Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 I guess that the JP homers will call him on it. I vote to keep him in through thick and thin, he isn't JP in his 4th year. I hope for the best and will wait and see all season, if he can stay healthy. You'd be guessing wrong for most of us so-called JP homers because for most of us, our problem was never about Trent, it was about how JP was managed. If Trent starts sucking, and Jauron starts dicking around with "We'll let you know who's starting by Wednesday" crap, the JP homers will likely be pissing and moaning about the way Trent is managed.
Hazed and Amuzed Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 You can't sit him if he stinks it up in the first couple of games, especially since it's his second year. He is expected to struggle this year, teams have film on him now and know how to prepare better for him. Hell, Peyton Mannings worst year was his 2nd. He had a rating of 71 and threw more Ints. then TD's. If Trent is at the very least as good as he was in his first few games of his career then we should be alright, IMO, if he is then it will mean that he has adjusted to others teams adjusting to him, this I believe is one of the most important attributes a QB can have. I think Trent has it and it will show by the end of this season.
Adam Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 I just had a bad thought that if Trent somehow played very poorly the first couple of games would the fans and media start calling for him to be benched? How long of a leash do you think he should get? I would hate to see him benched too soon with no *good* alternatives waiting in the wings but I would also hate to see the Bills miss the playoffs again. By *good*, I mean consistently good, not does one good thing followed up by one or more extremely costly bone-headed things. Not naming any names or anything..... What if the team chokes? Do we bench everybody?
The Rev.Mattb74 ESQ. Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 I know the answer to this I read about it on a resteraunt wall.
bladiebla Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 Have you ever seen Hamdan do anything, let alone anything good? But yes, that very well might be the rallying call come week 4. God, I hope not.... Plenty and then some... See my sig for vid. Read the OTA/TC reports, very positive on Hamdan. Watch the OTA/TC highlight vids; watch for #10, lots of good stuff.
PromoTheRobot Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 What if Trent Edwards and the Bills are good? What will we whine about? PTR
IDBillzFan Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 What if Trent Edwards and the Bills are good? What will we whine about? PTR Rest assured, someone will find something.
Dr. Trooth Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 You must not have much familiarity with Buffalo, the Bills, or fans to ask such a question. Bills fans are patient to a point. But, we live in a world of 'what have you done for me lately'? Any Bill who chokes or doesn't play up to, or close to, expectations will incur the wrath of the fans. That's guaranteed. Edwards or other. Two games in a row? Completly choke? Edwards? Dude... I've got $500 that says that won't happen... game on?
MattyT Posted August 7, 2008 Posted August 7, 2008 You'd be guessing wrong for most of us so-called JP homers because for most of us, our problem was never about Trent, it was about how JP was managed. If Trent starts sucking, and Jauron starts dicking around with "We'll let you know who's starting by Wednesday" crap, the JP homers will likely be pissing and moaning about the way Trent is managed. Good post.
Recommended Posts