Swift Sylvan Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 A couple years ago, someone made a thread where it was all-time Bill's survivor which included players such as Marv, Ralph, Jimbo, Thurman, Bruce, etc..... and everyday we would vote off someone. Was it Bill from NYC who made the thread? Anyways, my suggestion is in light of our repeating/uneventful threads that we start a new survivor except that it should it consist of scapegoats for the Bills in perhaps the last five years. My nominees would be: JP Kelly Holcomb Willis McGahee Travis Henry EMO Josh Reed Robert Royal Duke Preston Mike Williams Mike Gandy Chris Kelsay Tim Anderson Jeff Posey Troy Vincent Coy Wire Mike Mularkey Dick Jauron Ralph Any thoughts?
Swift Sylvan Posted May 15, 2008 Author Posted May 15, 2008 The reason I won't start the thread is because I won't be able to access the internet for a couple days in the near future and the person should be able to update the thread each day.
Huuuge Bills Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 You want a scapegoat, yet you left off the most obvious one? How about the guy who brought in almost all of those players on the list... Tommy Donahoe.
/dev/null Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 I would add: QB Drew Bledsoe C Trey Teague and Hamden
justnzane Posted May 16, 2008 Posted May 16, 2008 How about Eddie "I got juked by Chad Pennington" Robinson Buffalo Billdo Larry Tripplett Nate Clements Melvin Fowler any Bills TE (minus Everett) and Tom Clements
Wilson from Gamehendge Posted May 16, 2008 Posted May 16, 2008 Greg Jerman, Bennie Anderson, Tutan Reyes, "Fast Freddie" Smith, Shaud Williams, Rashad Baker, Justin Bannan, Brad Cieslak, Tim Euhus, Ron Edwards, Eric King, Dylan McFarland, Chris Villarrial, Lauvale Sape, Jon Dorenbos, Mike Schneck, Joe Burns, Mark Campbell, Shane Matthews, Izell Reese, Pierson Prioleau, Bobby Shaw, Marcus Price, Lawrence Smith, Kevin Thomas, Matt Bowen, Andre Davis, Terrance Pennington, Aaron Merz, Ross Tucker, Marques Sullivan, Ben Sobieski...and there are so many more I could think of, including... ...my favorites, Drew Haddad and Liam Ezekiel.
justnzane Posted May 16, 2008 Posted May 16, 2008 Greg Jerman, Bennie Anderson, Tutan Reyes, "Fast Freddie" Smith, Shaud Williams, Rashad Baker, Justin Bannan, Brad Cieslak, Tim Euhus, Ron Edwards, Eric King, Dylan McFarland, Chris Villarrial, Lauvale Sape, Jon Dorenbos, Mike Schneck, Joe Burns, Mark Campbell, Shane Matthews, Izell Reese, Pierson Prioleau, Bobby Shaw, Marcus Price, Lawrence Smith, Kevin Thomas, Matt Bowen, Andre Davis, Terrance Pennington, Aaron Merz, Ross Tucker, Marques Sullivan, Ben Sobieski...and there are so many more I could think of, including... ...my favorites, Drew Haddad and Liam Ezekiel. Boy, you really missed the point here. The point was to list people that were goats in the Bills fans minds recently. the only ones on that list that qualify are bennie anderson (good example by the way), Shaud Williams, and maybe Villarial.
Wilson from Gamehendge Posted May 16, 2008 Posted May 16, 2008 Boy, you really missed the point here. The point was to list people that were goats in the Bills fans minds recently. the only ones on that list that qualify are bennie anderson (good example by the way), Shaud Williams, and maybe Villarial. Yeah, sorry...I didn't really understand it, haha. I thought it was just horrible players who got run out of town. How about Lawyer Milloy? I would say Matt Bowen, Izell Reese and Mark Campbell...they were all signings that were supposed to be good starters, and they sucked!
justnzane Posted May 16, 2008 Posted May 16, 2008 Yeah, sorry...I didn't really understand it, haha. I thought it was just horrible players who got run out of town. How about Lawyer Milloy? It is more about scapegoats, and while Milloy wasn't the Pro Bowl caliber player that he was for NE*, he wasn't completely torn apart here, either. My interpretation is basically players that flat out sucked (Bennie Anderson, Tim Anderson) failed to live to their own hype (Nate Clements), set the franchise back (Tom Donahoe, Ralphy), talked major sh-- about Buffalo (Willis MacGahee), or had sex with minors (Travis Henry)
2020 Our Year For Sure Posted May 16, 2008 Posted May 16, 2008 So...would we vote off the players we like, or the players we don't like?
justnzane Posted May 16, 2008 Posted May 16, 2008 So...would we vote off the players we like, or the players we don't like? We would probably vote off the players we like, and keep voting to keep jagoffs like Willis on the island
Swift Sylvan Posted May 16, 2008 Author Posted May 16, 2008 We would probably vote off the players we like, and keep voting to keep jagoffs like Willis on the island See who is the most hated scapegoat?
justnzane Posted May 16, 2008 Posted May 16, 2008 See who is the most hated scapegoat? Sure I like the idea of that. Mods/Admins, can we do some kind of contest like that where we have a poll and we eliminate the one that is least hated. Or could we do some kind of brackets where we have 32 or 64 players square off round by round?
Recommended Posts