Who would you rather have?

[Flbillsfan#1]

All the people who wanted Sheppard so bad, who would you rather have today........ Sheppard or McKelvin?

[Pirate Angel]

All the people who wanted Sheppard so bad, who would you rather have today........ Sheppard or McKelvin?

ILL let you know in three years

[bizell]

mckelvin

[nucci]

ILL let you know in three years

That's an easy way out. How about letting us know now? Teams can't look 3 years ahead to see how a player develops.

[Brandon]

McKelvin. He's several years younger and won't cost the Bills an enormous amount of money to sign.

[Buffaloed in Pa]

McKelvin hands down. Great cover corner and awsome return skills. Held Bigshot Calvin Johnson to 2 catches for 9 yards in his match-up against him.

[silvermike]

Presuming we could have traded down, it's really more of a McKelvin or Sheppard+Merling kind of thing.

[deep2evans]

McKelvin hands down. Great cover corner and awsome return skills. Held Bigshot Calvin Johnson to 2 catches for 9 yards in his match-up against him.

 

wow, didnt know that..

[Oneonta Buffalo Fan]

All the people who wanted Sheppard so bad, who would you rather have today........ Sheppard or McKelvin?

McLovin!

[The Senator]

McKelvin - faster, more versatile, great return guy, younger, no outrageous contract demands, more 'upside'.

 

(I think if McKelvin hadn't been there at #11, the Bills still might have tried to trade/swap picks with the Eagles in some sort of deal for Sheppard - when McKelvin was still there for the Bills, it made such a deal unnecessary.)

[colin]

i think this guy can be donte hall good.

 

plays rough and makes plays with a chip on his shoulder, but isn't such a jerk.

 

i was wanting drc, thinking no way does leodis get out of the top 10.