Frez Posted October 9, 2004 Share Posted October 9, 2004 Let's do something fun. Why not make a list of the 32 starting QB's in the NFL and rate them in your order from Best to worst. Let's see how everyone's list compares. I was kinda surprised where I had to put Bledsoe. 1. Peyton Manning 2. D.McNabb 3. Tom Brady 4. Daunte Culpepper 5. Michael Vick 6. Chad Pennington 7. Brett Favre 8. Steve McNair 9. Trent Green 10. Joey Harrington 11. Ben Roethlisberger 12. Matt Hasselbeck 13. Byron Leftwich 14. David Carr 15. Jeff Garcia 16. Jake Delhomme 17. Aaron Brooks 18. Kerry Collins 19. Brad Johnson 20. Kurt Warner 21. Marc Bulger 22. Jake Plummer 23. Carson Palmer 24. Vinny Interceptaverdie 25. Drew Bledsoe 26. Drew Brees 27. Mark Brunell 28. Jay Fiedler 29. Josh McCown 30 Kyle Boller 31 Ken Dorsey 32. J. Quinn (Bears) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Thurman's Helmet Posted October 9, 2004 Share Posted October 9, 2004 #1 begins and ends with Tom Brady. End of story Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rico Posted October 9, 2004 Share Posted October 9, 2004 #1 begins and ends with Tom Brady. End of story 62750[/snapback] Agree 100%. That is one ugly list. Sure are a lot of sucky QBs starting. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lori Posted October 9, 2004 Share Posted October 9, 2004 #1 begins and ends with Tom Brady. End of story 62750[/snapback] Dammit, I was going to beat you to the punch... "#1 Tom Brady, #2 who cares? Sincerely, Patriots fans" Just pickin'. To be deadly serious, though - he's gotten the job done, and the two guys Frez listed ahead of him haven't. Much as with Elway, I'm never going to like the guy, but have to (grudgingly) respect what he's done. And Rico? You're right, there's some real AFL2 talent on that list. Remember back when most every team had a decent QB? I miss that era. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Chalkie Gerzowski Posted October 9, 2004 Share Posted October 9, 2004 AFC 1. Manning 2. Brady 3. Pennington 4. Green 5. Leftwich 6. McNair 7. Rothliesberger 8. Carr 9. Plummer 10. Garcia 11. Brees 12. Bledsoe 13. Boller 14. Collins 15. Palmer 16. Feeley NFC 1. McNabb 2. Culpepper 3. Hasselbeck 4. Bulger 5. Favre 6. Vick 7. Harrington 8. Brooks 9. Delhomme 10. Warner 11. Testaverde 12. Brunell 13. McCown 14. Rattay 15. Simms 16. Quinn Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rico Posted October 9, 2004 Share Posted October 9, 2004 And Rico? You're right, there's some real AFL2 talent on that list. Remember back when most every team had a decent QB? I miss that era. 62762[/snapback] I miss them too, Lori. As much as I don't like Manning or Favre, I really enjoyed the Colts-Packers game the other week ago. That was fun to watch. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JStranger76 Posted October 9, 2004 Share Posted October 9, 2004 Damn you Class of 83!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mead107 Posted October 9, 2004 Share Posted October 9, 2004 hate to say it . .brady beat manning, ,mcnabb runner up , and favre on the down side , drew just get us a win please Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
stevestojan Posted October 9, 2004 Share Posted October 9, 2004 1. Tom Brady If you say Peyton, all that means is you have seen highlights from his 2 5TD games. He sucks in the playoffs (2 4INT games). Sure, he won 2 playoff games in 2003, but threw 4 picks (again) and handed NE a trip to the SB). Remember, for every 5 TD game, he has several above average ones. Oh, and Brady has two of the last three super bowl rings issued. Bledsoe? For starting QBs? Bottom 5 easily. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Steven in MD Posted October 10, 2004 Share Posted October 10, 2004 Are you asking which QB you would want to have in a SB game? Are you talking about the best QB for a season? Brady is not even in the top 10 QBs in the league. He cannot, and therefore does not throw a deep ball. You never see him audible out of play. I would take Manning, Favre, Vick, McNabb and Culpepper over Brady ANY day except for Super Bowl Sunday. The only credit I give him, is that he is cool under pressure. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hollywood Donahoe Posted October 10, 2004 Share Posted October 10, 2004 [brady] cannot, and therefore does not throw a deep ball. Some Bills fan you are. You didn't even watch the game last week. 1-35-NE24 (12:34) T.Brady pass to D.Givens to BUF 32 for 44 yards (C.Wire). Caught over middle at BUF 35. 1-10-BUF49 (7:10) T.Brady pass to D.Patten to BUF 6 for 43 yards (T.McGee). Caught over middle at BUF 12. I suppose those were outlet passes? And that's just last week. There's no excuse for such a moronic statement from someone who claims to follow the NFL. You never see him audible out of play. Either you're joking around, or you're the biggest idiot to ever post on this board. You must think that Peyton Manning is the only QB to audible, since he's the only one that feels the need to put on a show when he does it. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ATBNG Posted October 10, 2004 Share Posted October 10, 2004 You must think that Peyton Manning is the only QB to audible, since he's the only one that feels the need to put on a show when he does it. I still can't get over that egomaniacal demonstration AT HOME against Green Bay with 2:40 left where he did the whole "talk to all 10 players" routine after he publicly had a conversation with Hochuli right before the play about which clock would run out first. He also steps forward all the time, but somehow this isn't a false start. He also is about as interesting as a piece of sand. I just don't get it. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BuffOrange Posted October 10, 2004 Share Posted October 10, 2004 For all the picks Manning threw in that title game, what did the Pats offense do? Score 1 TD and throw a pick in the endzone when a score would've put the game away? When you factor in the fact that the Pats defense is about 10 times better than the Colts, I don't know how anybody thinks the the result wouldn't have been the same had the QB's switched teams. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MartyBall4Buffalo Posted October 10, 2004 Share Posted October 10, 2004 AFC 1. BRADY 2. PENNINGTON 3. MANNING 4. MCNAIR 5. GREEN 6. CARR 7. Leftwhich 8. PLUMMER 9. BREES 10. ROTHLISBERGER 11. BLEDSOE 12. PALMER 13. GARCIA 14. COLLINS 15. FIEDLER 16. MR. KYLE BOLLER- Can throw 50 yards on one knee from mid field through the goal posts. Can't hit the broad side of a barn in a game situation. NFC- 1. Hasselbeck 2. Mcnabb 3. Aaron brooks 4. Mike Vick 5. Kurt Warner 6. Jake Delhomme 7. Marc Bulger 8. Joey Harrington 9. Daunte Culpepper 10. Brett Favre 11. Vinny Interceptaverde 12. Brunell 13. Mccown 14. Rattay 15. Quinn 16. Simms I have reasons for most of these but it would've took too long to type. But before I get flamed for culpepper and favre being so low. I wouldn't rank them that low if 1. Brett favre finishes a game healthy this season 2. Culpepper gets breathed on and doesnt turn the ball over. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hollywood Donahoe Posted October 10, 2004 Share Posted October 10, 2004 For all the picks Manning threw in that title game, what did the Pats offense do? Score 1 TD and throw a pick in the endzone when a score would've put the game away? When you factor in the fact that the Pats defense is about 10 times better than the Colts, I don't know how anybody thinks the the result wouldn't have been the same had the QB's switched teams. 63159[/snapback] Your post is misleading because: - you forgot to mention that Christian Fauria dropped not one, but TWO TD passes from Brady in the end zone. and: - you ignore the fact that Manning has Harrison, Wayne, James, Pollard, and a great OL at his disposal, while Brady has a bunch short recivers with physical limitations and a OL full of of rejects and castoffs. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
RuntheDamnBall Posted October 10, 2004 Share Posted October 10, 2004 Better question is, where would Losman fit in in this list? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Astrobot Posted October 10, 2004 Share Posted October 10, 2004 Chalkie got it nearly right. (Chalkie's #'s still listed) AFC 1. Manning 2. Brady 6. McNair 3. Pennington 7. Rothlesberger 4. Green 8. Carr 5. Leftwich 9. Plummer 11. Brees 14. Collins 10. Garcia 12. Bledsoe 13. Boller 15. Palmer 16. Feeley NFC 1. McNabb 2. Culpepper 3. Hasselbeck 5. Favre 6. Vick 4. Bulger 7. Harrington 10. Warner 8. Brooks 9. Delhomme 11. Testaverde 12. Brunell 13. McCown 14. Rattay 15. Simms 16. Quinn Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BuffOrange Posted October 10, 2004 Share Posted October 10, 2004 Your post is misleading because: - you forgot to mention that Christian Fauria dropped not one, but TWO TD passes from Brady in the end zone. and: - you ignore the fact that Manning has Harrison, Wayne, James, Pollard, and a great OL at his disposal, while Brady has a bunch short recivers with physical limitations and a OL full of of rejects and castoffs. 63259[/snapback] Ahh, nothing like good old Dolphins/Marino fan syndrome.... "Our team is the greatest; except when we're arguing about QB's, in which case the QB is the whole team and the rest of the team sucks".... Marcus Pollard? He's an average TE on any other team. Reggie Wayne was a nobody prior to last year, and Manning was pretty good before that. Not that I'm disputing that the Colts have more weapons, but I picked the Pats to win that game last year because regardless of QB's - good defense, great coach, good special teams, decent offense, referees, and home field beats a great offense, bad defense, choke coach, and mediocre special teams. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JohninMinn. Posted October 10, 2004 Share Posted October 10, 2004 Better question is, where would Losman fit in in this list? 63294[/snapback] A college kid who has 3 years of mistakes to make yet Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Satan Posted October 10, 2004 Share Posted October 10, 2004 Let's do something fun. Why not make a list of the 32 starting QB's in the NFL and rate them in your order from Best to worst. Let's see how everyone's list compares. I was kinda surprised where I had to put Bledsoe. 1. Peyton Manning 2. D.McNabb 3. Tom Brady 4. Daunte Culpepper 5. Michael Vick 6. Chad Pennington 7. Brett Favre 8. Steve McNair 9. Trent Green 10. Joey Harrington 11. Ben Roethlisberger 12. Matt Hasselbeck 13. Byron Leftwich 14. David Carr 15. Jeff Garcia 16. Jake Delhomme 17. Aaron Brooks 18. Kerry Collins 19. Brad Johnson 20. Kurt Warner 21. Marc Bulger 22. Jake Plummer 23. Carson Palmer 24. Vinny Interceptaverdie 25. Drew Bledsoe 26. Drew Brees 27. Mark Brunell 28. Jay Fiedler 29. Josh McCown 30 Kyle Boller 31 Ken Dorsey 32. J. Quinn (Bears) 62709[/snapback] Hasselbeck at 11? Behind Rothenslingbergergenson and his two career starts??? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
(2).thumb.jpeg.6e78fe3142ec9e6bfedbf027610db26f.jpeg)
Recommended Posts