Cornerville Posted November 27, 2006 Posted November 27, 2006 Just curious to see how this would turn out now that JP has won 2 in a row and Tin Man Jr. has lost a few in a row. Comments are always appreciated.
Gary M Posted November 27, 2006 Posted November 27, 2006 Just curious to see how this would turn out now that JP has won 2 in a row and Tin Man Jr. has lost a few in a row. Comments are always appreciated. 848819[/snapback] JP. Every body loves a winner.
bartshan-83 Posted November 27, 2006 Posted November 27, 2006 I'd cautiously pick JP right now, but really, what kind of results do you expect when you make this poll directly after JP's best two-game stretch as a pro v. Eli's possibly worst two-game stretch as a pro?
MartyBall4Buffalo Posted November 27, 2006 Posted November 27, 2006 Personally a year or 2 from now Im more interested in the question being "who would you rather have Phillip Rivers or Losman"
mcjeff215 Posted November 27, 2006 Posted November 27, 2006 giant fans would take JP 848882[/snapback] This week.
clownments22 Posted November 27, 2006 Posted November 27, 2006 no giants fan would take JP. living in a town full of primarily giants fan i hear a lot of jp trash talk. not even if we had the winning record rather than them. ->(next year we will if tiki sticks to his early retirement plans and they still would pick manning over jp)
RVJ Posted November 27, 2006 Posted November 27, 2006 I would be more curious to see the poll between J.P. and Vince Young. I bet it would be almost even.
Fan in Chicago Posted November 27, 2006 Posted November 27, 2006 I would be more curious to see the poll between J.P. and Vince Young. I bet it would be almost even. 849085[/snapback] I read into the original post that this was a comparison of QBs from the same draft class so Young won't count. I would pick JP over BenR also but not sure yet over Rivers. The question would be good if both JP and Rivers had comparable talent around them.
Recommended Posts