RayFinkle Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 So Brandon Flowers had to wait until the Killers became a legitmate success/their 2nd album was released before he could attack Green Day? Note to Flowers: American Idiot was released almost two years ago and Bullet in a Bible was released one year ago. You've been holding this in for two years?? 816403[/snapback] Nobody knew who the f-ck he was 2 years ago. I love these Johnny come lately guys.
Cugalabanza Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 No one in either of these bands is fit to carry Handsome Dick Manitoba's sweaty jock strap.
loadofmularkey Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 Nobody knew who the f-ck he was 2 years ago. I love these Johnny come lately guys. 816426[/snapback] Exactly. He had to wait until his band "made it".
SilverNRed Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 Green Day > The Killers. 816095[/snapback] The Killers are about 100x better than Green Day, and that's a conservative estimate. The lyrics to every Green Day song sound like they were written by a 14 year old ("here comes the rain again, falling from the stars"?? That's friggin embarassing.) Meanwhile, "Mr. Brightside" and "When You Were Young" are two of the best songs of the past few years. And he didn't wait until they'd "made it" to say this. They "made it" with their first album. He waited until their second album was out.
RayFinkle Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 The Killers are about 100x better than Green Day, and that's a conservative estimate. If people even remember who The Killers are in a decade, you might have an arguement. What do they have, one album out?
SilverNRed Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 If people even remember who The Killers are in a decade, you might have an arguement. What do they have, one album out? 816499[/snapback] Yes, God forbid we judge bands based on quality instead of popularity. By that standard, NSync may be the greatest musical act of all time. Green Day was a bunch of has-beens about 5 years ago before they decided crank up the anti-American crap (which is something a lot of desperate celebrities do). They even released a greatest hits CD, which is not something bands in their prime generally do. And I'll take both Killers albums over everything Green Day has ever done.
RayFinkle Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 Yes, God forbid we judge bands based on quality instead of popularity. By that standard, NSync may be the greatest musical act of all time. Green Day was a bunch of has-beens about 5 years ago before they decided crank up the anti-American crap (which is something a lot of desperate celebrities do). They even released a greatest hits CD, which is not something bands in their prime generally do. And I'll take both Killers albums over everything Green Day has ever done. 816509[/snapback] The Killers = Jessica Simpson Greenday = Madonna
daquixers_is_back Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 If people even remember who The Killers are in a decade, you might have an arguement. What do they have, one album out? 816499[/snapback] Not to take sides or anything, because Greenday really is a legend for the genre but The Killers first album was extremely successful. Probably much more than American Idiot.
SilverNRed Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 The Killers = Jessica SimpsonGreenday = Madonna 816511[/snapback] That's a funny way to put it. But (and this is another topic) I still don't think Jessica Simpson has ever had a hit song. I think her record company just annointed her "music star" one day without consulting the entire rest of the world.
buffaloboyinATL Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 Exactly. He had to wait until his band "made it". 816447[/snapback] Maybe he has been saying it for 2 years but no one bothered to print it until he "made it". It doesn't mean his opinion is new, just more interesting now.
I 90 Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 No one in either of these bands is fit to carry Handsome Dick Manitoba's sweaty jock strap. 816429[/snapback] True 'dat.
Chef Jim Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 Not to take sides or anything, because Greenday really is a legend for the genre but The Killers first album was extremely successful. Probably much more than American Idiot. 816515[/snapback] Whoa nelly............
IBTG81 Posted October 25, 2006 Author Posted October 25, 2006 The Killers are about 100x better than Green Day, and that's a conservative estimate. The lyrics to every Green Day song sound like they were written by a 14 year old ("here comes the rain again, falling from the stars"?? That's friggin embarassing.) Meanwhile, "Mr. Brightside" and "When You Were Young" are two of the best songs of the past few years. And he didn't wait until they'd "made it" to say this. They "made it" with their first album. He waited until their second album was out. 816493[/snapback] Exactly!
IBTG81 Posted October 25, 2006 Author Posted October 25, 2006 Whoa nelly............ 816652[/snapback] I have to agree with Jim here. Legends?! Are you friggan kidding me?! GreenDay is Pop/Rock. They aren't punk in the slightest. "I walk a lonely road The only one that I have ever known Don't know where it goes But it's home to me and I walk alone"
buffalomike Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 I LOVE Green Day and I like the Killers. With that being said when the Killers have shown that they have anywhere near the staying power of Green Day, then they can talk. Green Day's American Idiot album is a masterpiece and I believe I am right in assuming that it was more popular sales wise than the Killers Hot Fuss album. But popularity doesnt mean sh-- in music so I really dont know what point I am trying to make.
Chef Jim Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 I LOVE Green Day and I like the Killers. With that being said when the Killers have shown that they have anywhere near the staying power of Green Day, then they can talk. Green Day's American Idiot album is a masterpiece and I believe I am right in assuming that it was more popular sales wise than the Killers Hot Fuss album. But popularity doesnt mean sh-- in music so I really dont know what point I am trying to make. 816812[/snapback] The point that you're making, along with most of the others here, is they know nothing of the genre...........Johnny?
daquixers_is_back Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 I have to agree with Jim here. Legends?! Are you friggan kidding me?!GreenDay is Pop/Rock. They aren't punk in the slightest. "I walk a lonely road The only one that I have ever known Don't know where it goes But it's home to me and I walk alone" 816809[/snapback] Im starting to get the feeling that the people on this board only listen to the top 40 and not underground or scene music. Greenday was an extremely popular underground/punk/scene band for years before they got popular and changed to pop/rock ... they still have legendary status for their early work even though people have said they "sold out." Their popular song "time of your life" is actually them saying a "goodbye" or more like a "f you" to the underground scene they are leaving behind. Its amazing what people dont know about punk emo and scene music on this board.
Chef Jim Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 Im starting to get the feeling that the people on this board only listen to the top 40 and not underground or scene music. Greenday was an extremely popular underground/punk/scene band for years before they got popular and changed to pop/rock ... they still have legendary status for their early work even though people have said they "sold out." Their popular song "time of your life" is actually them saying a "goodbye" or more like a "f you" to the underground scene they are leaving behind. 816831[/snapback] No some of a realize that punk has been around for probably 20 years longer than most of you've been alive. Those are the legends.
daquixers_is_back Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 No some of a realize that punk has been around for probably 20 years longer than most of you've been alive. Those are the legends. 816834[/snapback] Just as a 'gun' has changed from a simple rifle to a bazooka, so has music. The term "punk rock" 30 or so years ago is different than what it is now. Im sorry to break this to you guys. I would love to go to some scene concerts with you though ... you would really learn something about the genre.
IBTG81 Posted October 25, 2006 Author Posted October 25, 2006 Im starting to get the feeling that the people on this board only listen to the top 40 and not underground or scene music. Greenday was an extremely popular underground/punk/scene band for years before they got popular and changed to pop/rock ... they still have legendary status for their early work even though people have said they "sold out." Their popular song "time of your life" is actually them saying a "goodbye" or more like a "f you" to the underground scene they are leaving behind. 816831[/snapback] Greenday is about as punk as 'NSync are. Johnny Ramone would be rolling in his grave if he heard that GreenDay were being called punk.
Recommended Posts