I just got offered a crazy trade...

[Phlegm Alley]

Here is my roster:

 

QB: McNabb, Favre, Brees

RB: LT, Ronnie Brown, Gore, Chester Taylor

WR: Holt, Roy Williams, Donald Driver, Antonio Bryant, Lee Evans

 

I just got offered Plaxico Burress, Caddilac Williams, Marc Bulger, and Michael Turner (LT's handcuff)

 

FOR

 

Favre, Roy Williams, Frank Gore

 

 

 

After seeing Gore fumble the first 3 games and twice on the goaline, I think Michael Robinson might get GL carries. Roy Williams is injury prone, inconsistent, etc. Favre is off to a great start so far, but will he continue to be this good???

 

Would you guys pull the trigger on this trade?

[BuffOrange]

I think it's pretty marginal either way. I'd prefer Bulger over Favre. Roy Williams is a guy I like because he's put up 8 TD's each of the last two seasons with Joey Harrington at QB. I don't think you need Turner because handcuffs are for RB's who need handcuffs. Even if LT2 gets hurt, you're not going to see a Priest/LJ situation because the Chargers OL isn't that great.

[stinky finger]

I wouldn't. I prefer Favre/Gore to Bulger/Caddy. GB defense is so bad, Favre will whip it around more. TB situation is getting worse by the day.

[BILLS4LIFE]

I wouldnt. I would prefer to have Favre and Gore on my team.

[Buftex]

Why you could probably afford to trade Favre and Gore (who I still like a lot) with the depth you have, I don't really like what you are being offered in return...see if you can get more...everyone knows Favre throws a ton of picks, and may not be what he once was, but in terms of FF, he is still a pretty good starter to have, particularly if your trade partner is really weak at QB. As was mentioned, he will get his yardage, and a decent number of td's.

[ricojes]

Here is my roster:

 

QB: McNabb, Favre, Brees

RB: LT, Ronnie Brown, Gore, Chester Taylor

WR: Holt, Roy Williams, Donald Driver, Antonio Bryant, Lee Evans

 

I just got offered Plaxico Burress, Caddilac Williams, Marc Bulger, and Michael Turner (LT's handcuff)

 

FOR

 

Favre, Roy Williams, Frank Gore

After seeing Gore fumble the first 3 games and twice on the goaline, I think Michael Robinson might get GL carries.  Roy Williams is injury prone, inconsistent, etc. Favre is off to a great start so far, but will he continue to be this good???

 

Would you guys pull the trigger on this trade?

787601[/snapback]

While you have good depth, you will be making another team in your league a lot better. Williams is starting to gel with Kitna and will continue to produce. Favre is #3 on your depth chart so that doesn't matter. And Gore had a bad game, I don't think he'll get that many less goal line carries. Caddy is oft injured and teams playing TB are going to stack the line and let the rook beat them.