5 Wide Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 Josh Reed had a nice game. He made some good catches and ran hard after the catch. On his one grab he proceeded to drag the db 5 yards after contact. Damien Shelton, you on the other hand, you need to actually make contact with someone to receive a grade. I'm not sure why that at 265 pounds you need to put your head down and lunge at a blitzing LB on a blitz pickup as opposed to squaring up and just taking the man, but you wiffed hard a couple times yesterday. I've been neutral as far as what Shelton means to the team, but that was horrible.
Toledo Bill Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 I really question his value on the kick-off return team. I understand the concept of him being out there as a blocker but all he did yesterday was slow down returns. Was he part of the kick-return game last year? I didn't think he was and I sure don't think he contributed yesterday.
Rubes Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 Shelton sucked yesterday. I saw two plays I can recall where he either whiffed completely or just stood around not blocking the guy in front of him.
buffaloboyinATL Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 I really question his value on the kick-off return team. I understand the concept of him being out there as a blocker but all he did yesterday was slow down returns. Was he part of the kick-return game last year? I didn't think he was and I sure don't think he contributed yesterday. 769382[/snapback] I agree, there was one return where McGee tried to break it outside, there was one guy between him and at least 20 yards of green and Shelton blocked the one guy right into McGee. If Shelton could have held that block for a second or two there would have been a great return, instead we got the ball on our own 10. I believe that was the series that lead to the safety.
LabattBlue Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 That weakass attempt at blitz pickup by Shelton is nothing but a continuation of his poor play at FB from last year. They had all offseason to address it and yet he's still here. Maybe next year.
MDH Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 This might sound idiotic to some but if Reed had amazing hands he'd be a clone of Hines Ward. Both are fantastic blockers in the run game, both know how to find a weakness in the D and get open on a regular basis but only one actually makes the catch on a consistent basis when the ball is thrown his way. If Reed could get his head out of his as$ and focus for an entire game the guy would be a player.
MDH Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 That weakass attempt at blitz pickup by Shelton is nothing but a continuation of his poor play at FB from last year. They had all offseason to address it and yet he's still here. Maybe next year. 769402[/snapback] Yeah, as impressed as I was with Shelton's play two years ago the guy just continues his backslide. I'd like to see the Bills go with more 3WR sets and get Shelton off the field. It's not like he's doing anything in the backfield anyway.
stuckincincy Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 Bills should drop a dime and take a look at Vanderbilt's 2004 FB Matt Tant. Or maybe this guy, Naufahu Tahi. http://www.nfl.com/draft/profiles/2006/tahi_naufahu
HurlyBurly51 Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 Josh Reed had a nice game. He made some good catches and ran hard after the catch. On his one grab he proceeded to drag the db 5 yards after contact. Damien Shelton, you on the other hand, you need to actually make contact with someone to receive a grade. I'm not sure why that at 265 pounds you need to put your head down and lunge at a blitzing LB on a blitz pickup as opposed to squaring up and just taking the man, but you wiffed hard a couple times yesterday. I've been neutral as far as what Shelton means to the team, but that was horrible. 769365[/snapback] I read some posts defending Shelton's performance because it was "only preseason." Never understood why individual performances should be excused when you're battling for jobs just because the outcome of the game doesn't count. But now that he's sucking in regular games I think this can be added to the list of issues that need to be addressed. Granted, not at the top of the list, but an upgrade would be in order.
Dan Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 I, too, must admit Reed had a good game. I've thought for several years he should be gone. But, he did make some nice catches. The first catch of his on the sideline was something I thought he was incapable of. To harp on a different player: I did notice Wire chasing, in vain, the Patriot ball carrier on several plays. (Notice I said chasing not tackling.)
5 Wide Posted September 11, 2006 Author Posted September 11, 2006 I, too, must admit Reed had a good game. I've thought for several years he should be gone. But, he did make some nice catches. The first catch of his on the sideline was something I thought he was incapable of. To harp on a different player: I did notice Wire chasing, in vain, the Patriot ball carrier on several plays. (Notice I said chasing not tackling.) 769666[/snapback] I noticed Wire filling the holes and then flat out missing the tackle....but the coaches took him out of the game because we have Whitner. Shelton on the other hand, there is no plan B
Kelly the Dog Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 The thing about Reed is that he usually and repeatedly makes the tough grabs, so his hands are not the problem. He drops the easiest ones and catches the often hardest ones. So it's a concentration/confidence problem not a talent/hands problem.
scribo Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 Shelton making the team over Ricard puzzled me then, and it is boggling my little mind now. Is it too late to fix that error?
The Dean Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 That weakass attempt at blitz pickup by Shelton is nothing but a continuation of his poor play at FB from last year. They had all offseason to address it and yet he's still here. Maybe next year. 769402[/snapback] You are 100% correct. I can't understand why he's still on this team.
The Dean Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 The thing about Reed is that he usually and repeatedly makes the tough grabs, so his hands are not the problem. He drops the easiest ones and catches the often hardest ones. So it's a concentration/confidence problem not a talent/hands problem. 769674[/snapback] Exactly. Reed has great hands. I continue to think he may get stoned too often. What about Peerless catching the ball over the middle while taking a lick? Where did THAT come from?
Gavin in Va Beach Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 Shelton smokes the peep that's for sure. He and Wire may get one more chance, but if they both suck as bad as they did yesterday then if Jauron has any stones those two should be cleaning out lockers very soon. As for Reed, maybe re-signing him wasn't so bad after all...
Bflojohn Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 I'll be satisfied IF they stop throwing the ball to this loser! Shelton can't block, catch or run.... perfect combination in my book!
Rico Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 I noticed Wire filling the holes and then flat out missing the tackle....but the coaches took him out of the game because we have Whitner. Shelton on the other hand, there is no plan B 769673[/snapback] No, but there is a plan A: 3 WR-sets, with Shelton on the bench.
Recommended Posts