Swift Sylvan Posted August 10, 2006 Posted August 10, 2006 Well what would our ratings be? Please don't kill me for spelling errors, I'm not an English Major. QB: Holcomb - 82 JP - 80 Nall - 76 Willis - 92 A-Train - 78 Shaud - 75 Lionel - 74 Shelton - 77 Burns - 70 Royal - 82 Everett - 78 Ciemajigger - 71 GeneralLee83 - 87 PriceisRight - 83 TheReedDeed - 82 Parrish - 80 Davis - 76 Aiken - 72 Nance - 101 Peters - 84 CV - 83 Fowler - 81 Reyes - 79 Gandy - 77 MaCargo - 78 Tripplett - 83 Anderson - 77 Williams - 75 (but if he keeps doing well I'll raise it) Schobel - 90 Kelsey - 80 Denney - 77 Posey - 82 (I KNOW I KNOW) Crowell - 85 Fletcher - 95 (!@#$ you Madden and whoever picks pro-bowlers) Spikes - 97 Haggan - 74 Stamer - 76 Clements - 94 McGee - 86 (and KR of 97 as oppose to 85) Greer - 76 King - 72 Youboty - 75 Vincent - 88 Bowen - 82 Whitner - 83 Simpson - 78 Baker - 75 Lindell - 82 Moorman - 98 Too High, Too Low?
MDH Posted August 11, 2006 Posted August 11, 2006 McGee - 86 (and KR of 97 as oppose to 85) 740330[/snapback] How on Earth can they give the best KO return man in the league a rating of 85? He's not even the highest rated returner on the Bills.
Swift Sylvan Posted August 11, 2006 Posted August 11, 2006 These ratings are BS... 740431[/snapback] Mine? Madden's? or both? I agree I might have made Nance a little low , but seriously other than Nance I did try to make them as to where I thought they stood. As subjective as that is
generaLee83 Posted August 11, 2006 Posted August 11, 2006 Every year I hope that at least Madden will recognize London Fletcher as a 95 level player (since no one else does) and every year I am dissapointed. This is going to be the first year that I will not purchase this game.
Chilly Posted August 11, 2006 Posted August 11, 2006 Why would it depress you? Billy and Bobby are preparing for life by playing Madden. Meanwhile, Achmed and Ayman are preparing for Billy and Bobby by playing with Nitro. 740188[/snapback] Because I'm planning on buying the game for my 360?
Fewell733 Posted August 11, 2006 Posted August 11, 2006 Pretty good rankings. Vincent is too high though- I think 84 or 85 is more accurate. Otherwise I would only maybe change a rating by 1 or 2 points here and there. Good job Well what would our ratings be? Please don't kill me for spelling errors, I'm not an English Major. QB: Holcomb - 82 JP - 80 Nall - 76 Willis - 92 A-Train - 78 Shaud - 75 Lionel - 74 Shelton - 77 Burns - 70 Royal - 82 Everett - 78 Ciemajigger - 71 GeneralLee83 - 87 PriceisRight - 83 TheReedDeed - 82 Parrish - 80 Davis - 76 Aiken - 72 Nance - 101 Peters - 84 CV - 83 Fowler - 81 Reyes - 79 Gandy - 77 MaCargo - 78 Tripplett - 83 Anderson - 77 Williams - 75 (but if he keeps doing well I'll raise it) Schobel - 90 Kelsey - 80 Denney - 77 Posey - 82 (I KNOW I KNOW) Crowell - 85 Fletcher - 95 (!@#$ you Madden and whoever picks pro-bowlers) Spikes - 97 Haggan - 74 Stamer - 76 Clements - 94 McGee - 86 (and KR of 97 as oppose to 85) Greer - 76 King - 72 Youboty - 75 Vincent - 88 Bowen - 82 Whitner - 83 Simpson - 78 Baker - 75 Lindell - 82 Moorman - 98 Too High, Too Low? 740330[/snapback]
Ranger Ranchod Posted August 11, 2006 Posted August 11, 2006 Andre Davis is our second-best receiver at 79. Interesting... When will McGee finally be 99 in Kick Return? 85 for the best at that job 2 years in a row, on the best ST in the league? Retarded.
Ranger Ranchod Posted August 11, 2006 Posted August 11, 2006 Ricard at FB is an 89 - that's a nice trade to make when you get the game!
Swift Sylvan Posted August 11, 2006 Posted August 11, 2006 Pretty good rankings. Vincent is too high though- I think 84 or 85 is more accurate. Otherwise I would only maybe change a rating by 1 or 2 points here and there. Good job 740598[/snapback] I guess this could be a good source when those of us who will buy the game want to alter the ratings.
BoondckCL Posted August 11, 2006 Posted August 11, 2006 The real question in judging how good the Madden ratings are is how good did they make Ron Mexico? If he is one of the best in the game, then they are lacking and are only buying into Donahoe-eske propaganda machines.
Ramius Posted August 11, 2006 Author Posted August 11, 2006 The real question in judging how good the Madden ratings are is how good did they make Ron Mexico? If he is one of the best in the game, then they are lacking and are only buying into Donahoe-eske propaganda machines. 741021[/snapback] Mexico is rated an overall of 91. The reaosn that is so high, is because his speed is a 93. His throw power is 96. both of those are right on. Also his throw accuracy is 79, probably a bit too high. So i'd say hes rated fairly. Other than that, i dont have too many problems with the ratings. you can get the roster update when madden comes out, and you can manually tweak some ratings, so its all good. Crowell is going up, MW and teague are going down.
Recommended Posts