OGTEleven Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 I didn't purposely spell his name wrong but don't care enough to look it up either. What do you all think of his life sentence? Did he win and prove that we are a weak willed nation? Did we win by proving we stick to our principles no matter the crime? Did we win by denying him his desire to be martyred? IMO, he didn't win, but we lost. I'm no big fan of the death penalty. I have mixed feelings about it. Also IMO, if there is a case where it should be used, this is it. Even if 9/11 had been thwarted, this merits death. For this and other reasons I think our court system has been shown as mamby pamby. What are our principles? To try to see gray everywhere? To make sure he gets to speak at his own sentencing? To make sure we hear "both sides" of a story, even when there is only one? Although I feel pretty strongly he should be put to death, that isn't even my own number one concern. Why did this trial take so long? It's 2006. The attacks were in 2001. Why are we compelled to hear every nuance of every angle any idiot can dream up? Why are his lawyers on C-Span claiming this is a victory for everyone? He wants them dead too. I don't like it. What do you think?
cromagnum Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 If he ever is around other inmates he's disposed of.....His life consist of 6x 11 windowless box for 23hrs. a day till he dies, thats a living death.
RuntheDamnBall Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 I didn't purposely spell his name wrong but don't care enough to look it up either. What do you all think of his life sentence? Did he win and prove that we are a weak willed nation? Did we win by proving we stick to our principles no matter the crime? Did we win by denying him his desire to be martyred? IMO, he didn't win, but we lost. I'm no big fan of the death penalty. I have mixed feelings about it. Also IMO, if there is a case where it should be used, this is it. Even if 9/11 had been thwarted, this merits death. For this and other reasons I think our court system has been shown as mamby pamby. What are our principles? To try to see gray everywhere? To make sure he gets to speak at his own sentencing? To make sure we hear "both sides" of a story, even when there is only one? Although I feel pretty strongly he should be put to death, that isn't even my own number one concern. Why did this trial take so long? It's 2006. The attacks were in 2001. Why are we compelled to hear every nuance of every angle any idiot can dream up? Why are his lawyers on C-Span claiming this is a victory for everyone? He wants them dead too. I don't like it. What do you think? 683424[/snapback] I think denying him the pleasure of martyrdom and not granting him his desired legacy is the better punishment. In so doing, we rightly cast ourselves as above these monsters, monsters though they may be. It's not weakness, it's not mercy.
Pine Barrens Mafia Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 I think denying him the pleasure of martyrdom and not granting him his desired legacy is the better punishment. In so doing, we rightly cast ourselves as above these monsters, monsters though they may be. It's not weakness, it's not mercy. 683439[/snapback] It's not? Likely he WON'T be in general population. He's being spared the torment he deserves. Rightfully, he ought to be sent to gitmo and made to disappear....only to have the rest of his life spent in the most horrible tortures imaginable in order that he'll never be able to publicly proclaim himself a hero to his fellow followers of the "religion of peace".
Ghost of BiB Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 I'm a death penalty advocate, but in this case I think they made the right call. Don't give him his martyrdom. If he wants it that bad, let him hang himself in his cell.
UConn James Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 About the only bright side I can make out of it, is he might live to see the Islamofascists soundly defeated and Bin Laden's head on a stick.
RuntheDamnBall Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 (edited) It's not? Likely he WON'T be in general population. He's being spared the torment he deserves. Rightfully, he ought to be sent to gitmo and made to disappear....only to have the rest of his life spent in the most horrible tortures imaginable in order that he'll never be able to publicly proclaim himself a hero to his fellow followers of the "religion of peace". 683442[/snapback] If we do that, either way the damage is done and he is a hero. Execution and his going suspiciously missing are no different in terms of what we project towards the Muslim world. You have to publicly take small steps like this to make those possibly sympathetic on the "other side" realize that the people in charge of them are the tyrants, not us, and that there's a third way outside of secular tyranny and religious tyranny. Any steps we take to the contrary (and we've taken many) only add to the Islamofascists' bulletin board, to use a football metaphor poorly. We're better; then let's prove it. I realize some might think we have nothing to prove, but 1) we've made plenty of mistakes and 2) in any case, being the best is something you have to prove daily. EDIT: And don't mistake me for a total dove here, either: I heard some of the transcripts and they make me want blood. If it were my wife on one of those planes, that feeling would surely be intensified exponentially. All the same, I know that to act on those emotions would be to simply engage in their game, and that's a complete downward spiral. Edited May 4, 2006 by RuntheDamnBall
The Avenger Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 I'm fine with not giving him the 10-15 years of death penalty appeals that would allow him to come into court time and time again and make a spectacle of himself and give him more quotes in the newspapers. He was begging for the death penalty in serious Br'er Rabbit style. Thirst for blood shouldn't cloud anyone's thought that he actually ended up with the worst possible pumishment for him - a life of solitude and anonymity in a supermax cell.
Ghost of BiB Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 France is discussing a deal to move him to a French prison...
Crap Throwing Monkey Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 France is discussing a deal to move him to a French prison... 683574[/snapback] Because...? That just stinks to high heaven of the stereotypical "We're French, so we're special" attitude...
KRC Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 Because...? 683660[/snapback] They are using the lahjik that he is a French citizen, so the French should control enforcement of his sentence. I am guessing that they think the U.S. sentence will be too tough on him.
Crap Throwing Monkey Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 They are using the lahjik that he is a French citizen, so the French should control enforcement of his sentence. I am guessing that they think the U.S. sentence will be too tough on him. 683669[/snapback] I remember years ago when that American !@#$ got hisself caned in Singapore, and how everyone was on the State Department to keep Singapore from carrying out Singapore justice on an American citizen. It was !@#$ing stupid logic back then, too. You do a crime in East Kjhjskristan, you pay the penalty in East Kjhjskristan, even if it's not a crime in your home country. Don't like it? Don't go to !@#$ing East Kjhjskristan.
Pine Barrens Mafia Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 If we do that, either way the damage is done and he is a hero. Execution and his going suspiciously missing are no different in terms of what we project towards the Muslim world. You have to publicly take small steps like this to make those possibly sympathetic on the "other side" realize that the people in charge of them are the tyrants, not us, and that there's a third way outside of secular tyranny and religious tyranny. Any steps we take to the contrary (and we've taken many) only add to the Islamofascists' bulletin board, to use a football metaphor poorly. We're better; then let's prove it. I realize some might think we have nothing to prove, but 1) we've made plenty of mistakes and 2) in any case, being the best is something you have to prove daily. EDIT: And don't mistake me for a total dove here, either: I heard some of the transcripts and they make me want blood. If it were my wife on one of those planes, that feeling would surely be intensified exponentially. All the same, I know that to act on those emotions would be to simply engage in their game, and that's a complete downward spiral. 683500[/snapback] Ah, I see. Well, at the very least he should be sent to leavenworth and put into general population. Let him take the shank.
OGTEleven Posted May 4, 2006 Author Posted May 4, 2006 They are using the lahjik that he is a French citizen, so the French should control enforcement of his sentence. I am guessing that they think the U.S. sentence will be too tough on him. 683669[/snapback] Is it possible that a sentce for this @#% could be too harsh? Even in the eyes of France?
KD in CA Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 Who? Much to his dismay, that little dirtbag is old news. Lock up up and forget him.
Lori Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 France is discussing a deal to move him to a French prison... 683574[/snapback] Fug 'em. They can't have him.
Ghost of BiB Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 Fug 'em. They can't have him. 683946[/snapback] I like you.
Taro T Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 I'm a death penalty advocate, but in this case I think they made the right call. Don't give him his martyrdom. If he wants it that bad, let him hang himself in his cell. 683451[/snapback] Dead on correct. Living is the last thing this PoS wants. I hope he lives to a ripe old age and then rots in Hades for eternity. I can wait a few years for him to get his richly deserved "reward".
Chilly Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 I like you. 683994[/snapback] I like you, but not in a homosexual way.
Recommended Posts