BillsCelticsAngelsBama Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 Looking at depth chart, IMO the most glaring weaknesses are LT,LG,SS, and RDT... possibly even in that order. I would not be disappointed if we took two Offensive Linemen in rounds 1 and 2.. provided the quality is there, of course. The depth the Bills have behind Gandy and Anderson/Preston is scary Willis having holes to go through and the offensive having the ability to run for a first down (what a concept) will go along way to making our DEFENSE look a whole lot better. Thanks
Mark VI Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 I would not be disappointed if we took two Offensive Linemen in rounds 1 and 2.. provided the quality is there, of course. The depth the Bills have behind Gandy and Anderson/Preston is scary 648377[/snapback] Agreed. I'd like to draft 1 DT and a minumum 3 OL by the end of Round 4. I'm most worried about our 2 Starting Guard positions.
Beerball Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 I would not be disappointed if we took two Offensive Linemen in rounds 1 and 2.. provided the quality is there, of course. 648377[/snapback] Quality, that's the thing. We won't find an olineman of value at #8, so we either have to go another direction (d-line or db), or trade down, or trade up. I'm still hoping Marv trades down in Rd 1, but we'll see what happens.
Fixxxer Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 My list of needs would read: DT LG LDE RG SS LOT WR
BillsGuyInMalta Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 Davin Joseph out of Oklahoma is the solution to our LG spot. Every new thing I hear about this kid, the more I love him. He's strong, smart, versatile, a team player (played Guard his entire life but volunteered to take over LT when his teammate got hurt), and claims that the player he modeled his style over was former Bills guard, Ruben Brown. I say take him in the 2nd and put the LG spot out of your mind for the next 5 years because this kid has all the tools to dominate in the NFL. In fact, the only negative thing I've read about him is his height (only 6'3). But even thats not such a bad thing if he's playing Guard. As long as he's got the bulk, wingspan and strength (which he does) than his height shouldnt matter too much. To me, he's the best choice for us in the 2nd, regardless of what we do in the first. Here's some info on him, Draft Countdown rates him as the #1 Guard (although most sites have Giles ahead of him). http://www.nfldraftcountdown.com/scoutingr...avinjoseph.html http://www.footballsfuture.com/2006/prospe...vin_joseph.html http://2006.ontheclockdraft.com/profile.ph...721053091536786
stuckincincy Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 Davin Joseph out of Oklahoma is the solution to our LG spot. 648403[/snapback] How did he do against Ngata in the Holiday Bowl?
ans4e64 Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 My list: - DT (cant start tim anderson, just cant) - SS (Gandy is an adequate LT, Coy Wire is not an adequate SS) - LG (Would like to upgrade Bennie, if that means a LT and Gandy shift in thats fine too)
BillsGuyInMalta Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 How did he do against Ngata in the Holiday Bowl? 648454[/snapback] It looks like he handled Ngata pretty well actually. I didnt see the game but the stats in front of me are pretty stacked in Joseph's favor. Paved the way for 149 yards on the ground and Ngata only got two assisted tackles in the entire game...no sacks, no registered pressures.
drnykterstein Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 My guess is things go like this.. our first rounder = HUFF, a SS second rounder = DT 2 thirds = OL but if good value can't be found at DT and a decent OL is there then we'll take that in the second and get a DT in the third. Either way, those are our biggest needs at the moment.
ans4e64 Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 My guess is things go like this.. our first rounder = HUFF, a SS second rounder = DT 2 thirds = OL 648470[/snapback] i agree
drnykterstein Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 In fact, the only negative thing I've read about him is his height (only 6'3). 648403[/snapback] odd, doesn't it help you to get low on someone to get leverage? I'd think being short helps o-linemen as long as they don't sacrifice strength.
billsfaningeneseo Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 I agree with you rtconner, that is looking very plausible right now, and certainly would fill some glaring holes.
stuckincincy Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 It looks like he handled Ngata pretty well actually. I didnt see the game but the stats in front of me are pretty stacked in Joseph's favor. Paved the way for 149 yards on the ground and Ngata only got two assisted tackles in the entire game...no sacks, no registered pressures. 648465[/snapback] Thanks - I only watched 10 minutes or so of that game, to see Ngata. Looks like his stats are thin, but I liked seeing him tie up two linemen. Still, there those concerns about his previous injuries.
Bob in STL Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 My list: - DT (cant start tim anderson, just cant) - SS (Gandy is an adequate LT, Coy Wire is not an adequate SS) - LG (Would like to upgrade Bennie, if that means a LT and Gandy shift in thats fine too) 648459[/snapback] My prioity would be: round 1 - DT. Draft either Ngata or Bunkley. If we can slide down a few spots and still get Bunkley that would be great. The story about Ngata not fitting the scheme is crap. He could be an impact player. round 2 - Grab the best OT and hope that he can beat out Gandy this year. Then have Gandy compete with Fat Bennie for LG. at center have Preston compete with Fowler round 3 - draft a guard to push Villareal and draft a SS to push Wire/Bowen. Right OT - stick with Peters. stir it up and pray that a few of these rookies can play.
BUFFALOTONE Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 Davin Joseph out of Oklahoma is the solution to our LG spot. Every new thing I hear about this kid, the more I love him. He's strong, smart, versatile, a team player (played Guard his entire life but volunteered to take over LT when his teammate got hurt), and claims that the player he modeled his style over was former Bills guard, Ruben Brown. I say take him in the 2nd and put the LG spot out of your mind for the next 5 years because this kid has all the tools to dominate in the NFL. In fact, the only negative thing I've read about him is his height (only 6'3). But even thats not such a bad thing if he's playing Guard. As long as he's got the bulk, wingspan and strength (which he does) than his height shouldnt matter too much. To me, he's the best choice for us in the 2nd, regardless of what we do in the first. Here's some info on him, Draft Countdown rates him as the #1 Guard (although most sites have Giles ahead of him). http://www.nfldraftcountdown.com/scoutingr...avinjoseph.html http://www.footballsfuture.com/2006/prospe...vin_joseph.html http://2006.ontheclockdraft.com/profile.ph...721053091536786 648403[/snapback] I understand that Ruben Brown went to a bunch of pro bowls, but I thought he was quite possible the most overrated player I have ever seen. That clown had more penalties than the bills line combined.
Dan Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 I understand that Ruben Brown went to a bunch of pro bowls, but I thought he was quite possible the most overrated player I have ever seen. That clown had more penalties than the bills line combined. 648584[/snapback] I agree. Isn't that kinda like a QB saying I want to be just like Trent Dilfer.
apuszczalowski Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 round 1 - DT. Draft either Ngata or Bunkley. If we can slide down a few spots and still get Bunkley that would be great. The story about Ngata not fitting the scheme is crap. He could be an impact player. 648523[/snapback] I believe that Ngata might not be right for our schemes here in Buffalo. He will probably be a good DT in this league, but I don't think he will be good for Buffalo. The type of D they are going to play rely's on speed and a certain type of player to be successful. Ngata has been compared to Adams (from what I've heard a few times) which is the kind of players most think we need because of previous defensive schemes we have had in the past, but not the one they will use next year. And I really doubt we pick Bunkley at 8, if the bills want him I assume they trade down for him cause it would be a waste of the #8 pick getting him that early. I still think if there, they take VD or Huff, unless they can trade down.
Bob in STL Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 I believe that Ngata might not be right for our schemes here in Buffalo. He will probably be a good DT in this league, but I don't think he will be good for Buffalo. The type of D they are going to play rely's on speed and a certain type of player to be successful. Ngata has been compared to Adams (from what I've heard a few times) which is the kind of players most think we need because of previous defensive schemes we have had in the past, but not the one they will use next year. And I really doubt we pick Bunkley at 8, if the bills want him I assume they trade down for him cause it would be a waste of the #8 pick getting him that early. I still think if there, they take VD or Huff, unless they can trade down. 648632[/snapback] There is an inconsistency in evaluating Adams and what he did as a Bill. When Adams was a pro bowler he had Pat Williams as the two gap guy, tying up blockers so that Adams could go to the ball. Last year Adams could not, or would not, play the role of the 2 gap DT. He did not tie up blockers and was considered by the coaches to be ineffective against the run. In this new defense they say they want speed and people to go to the ball. Ngata has that. Adams had that. I don't get the agruement that Ngata does not fit? Scouts they say Ngata has speed, strength and size. That he can play 1 gap or 2. Bunkley - some say he does not represent ehough value at 8th. If he project as the best DT for our scheme, and is a better prospect than any of the OTs, then why not take him. Trading down is fine but it is always a gamble that you will lose your man. Huff- if he is there at 8 maybe we take him? Problem is I doubt we will find starters for both DT and OT in the 2nd and 3rd rounds. Recent draft history has not been kind to us on either of the lines. So it comes down to a trade-off of needs, value, and how hard it is to fill the many holes we have.
apuszczalowski Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 Actually this draft is supposedly very deep in line talent so Buffalo using a second or a third on someone could still get us someone good. I don't know, I think people are just overhyping Ngata cause he is supposedly the best DT in the draft so everyone thinks we need him.
obie_wan Posted March 31, 2006 Posted March 31, 2006 Davin Joseph out of Oklahoma is the solution to our LG spot. Every new thing I hear about this kid, the more I love him. He's strong, smart, versatile, a team player (played Guard his entire life but volunteered to take over LT when his teammate got hurt), and claims that the player he modeled his style over was former Bills guard, Ruben Brown. I say take him in the 2nd and put the LG spot out of your mind for the next 5 years because this kid has all the tools to dominate in the NFL. In fact, the only negative thing I've read about him is his height (only 6'3). But even thats not such a bad thing if he's playing Guard. As long as he's got the bulk, wingspan and strength (which he does) than his height shouldnt matter too much. To me, he's the best choice for us in the 2nd, regardless of what we do in the first. Here's some info on him, Draft Countdown rates him as the #1 Guard (although most sites have Giles ahead of him). http://www.nfldraftcountdown.com/scoutingr...avinjoseph.html http://www.footballsfuture.com/2006/prospe...vin_joseph.html http://2006.ontheclockdraft.com/profile.ph...721053091536786 648403[/snapback] Found this on another board regarding Joseph: "Just listening to Davin Joseph on NFL Sirius Radio and the kid is impressive. Pat Kirwin is asking him about the strengths and weaknesses on a variety of DTs and Joseph is speaking with the clarity and even handedness of a football coach. Considering the kid's measurables and his pedigree blocking at OU, I've got to believe he's going to be a 1st rounder, early 2nd rounder once teams have a chance to speak to him. For those interested, here's a paraphrased version of his thoughts on various DTs... Haloti Ngata, Oregon -- Quickest, most disruptive DT in this draft class. People underestimate his ability to get penetration Brodrick Bunkley, FSU -- Strongest DT he's ever seen, potential to be the very best of this class but for now isn't a complete football player yet Gabe Watson, Michigan -- Called him a "good" player with no discernible weaknesses but is also not "one of the best DTs in this draft." Rod Wright, Texas -- Joseph is friends with Wright and they've been training together, so take his comments with a grain of salt. But he did say that reports re: Wright lacking passion are completely erroneous and Rod has perfect technique to be an impact player at the next level" Based on this assessment of Ngata- all comments from the coaches are to deflect the Bills true intentions of taking Ngata at #8.
Recommended Posts