slothrop Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 Yeah, I think Chicken Large will make the top 12 easily.....he's entertaining, so people will keep him around a while, but then when things get serious he'll get booted off. You gotta give that little geek credit for hitting the national stage like a champ, though. It's not his fault people dig him Can someone explain to me why Bucky is still in the competition??? He seems like a good guy and all, but there is no talent that I see. I don't get it. 616476[/snapback] I think Buckey did a great job with his song. HE is great for what he is - a country/Southern Rock guy. He just needs personality. BTW, how exactly is the nerd entertaining?
Movinon Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 I think Buckey did a great job with his song. HE is great for what he is - a country/Southern Rock guy. He just needs personality. BTW, how exactly is the nerd entertaining? 616487[/snapback] The nerd is entertaining in the same way you thought Buckey did great - nothing more, nothing less -
slothrop Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 The nerd is entertaining in the same way you thought Buckey did great - nothing more, nothing less - 616493[/snapback] However, the Nerd has negative amounts of personality - he is a personality blackhole that sucks joy and happiness into an unknown abyss. Buckey at least has some personality - he just needs more. Also, Buckey sounded good as opposed to the tone-deaf nerd who looks like he is singing with a gun to his head.
ajzepp Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 I think Buckey did a great job with his song. HE is great for what he is - a country/Southern Rock guy. He just needs personality. BTW, how exactly is the nerd entertaining? 616487[/snapback] Well I personally don't care for the nerds singing ability....and I don't think he's better than Bucky, but I don't see where Bucky has any talent either.....I thought he BUTCHERED that song last night. I dunno, I just don't see it.
Johnny Coli Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 I think the Sinatra kid (aka The Wedding Singer, as my wife calls him) goes. He looked pretty pi$$ed that they dared to criticize him, and my sources told me he took it out on a black jew with a glass eye back-stage. That "sway" kid is a goner as well. He should have stuck with the "pimp" hat, because although it was his song selection that ultimately buried him, it's his fat head that turns me off. Also, I'm pretty sure no one who is a Hawaiian-Latino mix has ever made it past three weeks. Adio-loha, Sway. (Feel free to use it, but know that I have it copywritten) Chicken Little stays for a few more weeks (probably a lot more than people would expect) because he's the Rudy of this competition, now. He's got a lisp. He's got no talent. There is no rational reason for him to even be on any stage what-so-ever. And yet, if I voted in these things (which I don't because that would be indirect support for the bloated corpse that is corporate rock), I'd vote to keep him around every damn week because I want to see what song he's going to butcher. I want to see this anti-hero, this anti-idol stick it to the man. This unremarkable, untalented, un-photogenic mess is the closest damn thing to punk rock you will ever see on that show. Yes, you read that correctly. He's so non-threatening he's down-right dangerous. "Sid" Covais will be a thorn in corporate rock n roll's side for at least another month. (He's got to ditch the bland parents, though. They make me uncomfortable.) If that Bucky kid doesn't go this week, beware of the wrath of the Country Music fans. He's all they've got. There's no NASCAR race this weekend, so if they sober up and get wind that one of their kin is on that thar tell-vishun shee-oh, they will vote en masse for him. Don't underestimate The Red State Factor, but don't overestimate how many own TVs or telephones.
slothrop Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 Chicken Little stays for a few more weeks (probably a lot more than people would expect) because he's the Rudy of this competition, now. He's got a lisp. He's got no talent. There is no rational reason for him to even be on any stage what-so-ever. And yet, if I voted in these things (which I don't because that would be indirect support for the bloated corpse that is corporate rock), I'd vote to keep him around every damn week because I want to see what song he's going to butcher. I want to see this anti-hero, this anti-idol stick it to the man. This unremarkable, untalented, un-photogenic mess is the closest damn thing to punk rock you will ever see on that show. Yes, you read that correctly. He's so non-threatening he's down-right dangerous. "Sid" Covais will be a thorn in corporate rock n roll's side for at least another month. (He's got to ditch the bland parents, though. They make me uncomfortable.) 616595[/snapback] Now that is the first good reason I have heard to keep him. This reminds me - is that web site still active that tries to recruit people to vote for the worst performer? OBviously the Nerd is it. Down with corporate power!
ajzepp Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 I think the Sinatra kid (aka The Wedding Singer, as my wife calls him) goes. He looked pretty pi$$ed that they dared to criticize him, and my sources told me he took it out on a black jew with a glass eye back-stage. That "sway" kid is a goner as well. He should have stuck with the "pimp" hat, because although it was his song selection that ultimately buried him, it's his fat head that turns me off. Also, I'm pretty sure no one who is a Hawaiian-Latino mix has ever made it past three weeks. Adio-loha, Sway. (Feel free to use it, but know that I have it copywritten) Chicken Little stays for a few more weeks (probably a lot more than people would expect) because he's the Rudy of this competition, now. He's got a lisp. He's got no talent. There is no rational reason for him to even be on any stage what-so-ever. And yet, if I voted in these things (which I don't because that would be indirect support for the bloated corpse that is corporate rock), I'd vote to keep him around every damn week because I want to see what song he's going to butcher. I want to see this anti-hero, this anti-idol stick it to the man. This unremarkable, untalented, un-photogenic mess is the closest damn thing to punk rock you will ever see on that show. Yes, you read that correctly. He's so non-threatening he's down-right dangerous. "Sid" Covais will be a thorn in corporate rock n roll's side for at least another month. (He's got to ditch the bland parents, though. They make me uncomfortable.) If that Bucky kid doesn't go this week, beware of the wrath of the Country Music fans. He's all they've got. There's no NASCAR race this weekend, so if they sober up and get wind that one of their kin is on that thar tell-vishun shee-oh, they will vote en masse for him. Don't underestimate The Red State Factor, but don't overestimate how many own TVs or telephones. 616595[/snapback] Bravo!
Rico Posted March 2, 2006 Author Posted March 2, 2006 Yeah, Nerd Boy isn't going anywhere, we've seen this all before... only thing he's missing is the trach hole in his neck.
ajzepp Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 Yeah, Nerd Boy isn't going anywhere, we've seen this all before...only thing he's missing is the trach hole in his neck. 616681[/snapback] LOL....well at least Fedorov could sing a little.....chicken large is not much better than the singin' cowboy
Rico Posted March 2, 2006 Author Posted March 2, 2006 I'm still undecided as to who I will be backing this year, & shall wait until the Final 12 has been decided... right now, I'm leaning towards Spazz Hicks, I think he learned some moves from Crazy Dave.
ajzepp Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 I'm still undecided as to who I will be backing this year, & shall wait until the Final 12 has been decided... right now, I'm leaning towards Spazz Hicks, I think he learned some moves from Crazy Dave. 616768[/snapback] LOL! CRAZY DAVE! They need to hook that dude up with an encore at some point during the season
LabattBlue Posted March 3, 2006 Posted March 3, 2006 The correct people got booted this week. Next week may be a little tougher... Mandisa, Kinnik, the Geek & Bucky??
ASCI Posted March 3, 2006 Posted March 3, 2006 The correct people got booted this week. Next week may be a little tougher... Mandisa, Kinnik, the Geek & Bucky?? 617484[/snapback] Mandingos the best singer there
The Dean Posted March 3, 2006 Posted March 3, 2006 While I don't watch the show, I did see the last guy voted off sing his farewell song and thought it was great, actually.
bobblehead Posted March 3, 2006 Posted March 3, 2006 Yeah, Nerd Boy isn't going anywhere, we've seen this all before...only thing he's missing is the trach hole in his neck. 616681[/snapback] I feel dirty when he pops up on my TV. Like I should be calling the Better Business Bureau to report them on abuse of child labor laws. Seriously, kids in sweatshops in Malaysia are not exploited as much as this sock puppet. I do have to quit watching this show, it's putting the freaking zap to my head. Now I find myself equating smashed potatoes with snaggleteeth. Thanks AI.
Mark Vader Posted March 4, 2006 Posted March 4, 2006 Here's my breakdown of who's left: Guys: Ace: He's very lucky to still be around. Both times he has been unimpressive. His good looks will carry him only so far. Bucky: Good at what he does which may limit him. Could make it to the final 12, but will be an early exit. Chris: One of the few guys who actually has talent. He will go far, maybe even to the last 2. Elliot: Middle of the pack contestant who has'nt stood out yet. Has a chance to go far, but must step up fast. Gedeon: Limited talent. Better off singing slow ballads then fast paced songs. Will not last much longer. Kevin: I think the kid is pretty good. Not the best, but not the worst either. Another middle of the pack guy. Taylor: In my opinion this is the dark horse contestant. Has talent, and could go far. If he stays consistent, he could sneak into the remaining 6 and get past a few of the projected favorites. Will: Has talent and could make some noise. Needs to show more emotion instead of just standing around. Ladies: Ayla: Probably the biggest surprise of the group. She has the voice, but could get overlooked due to her personality. Katherine: Co-favorite contestant, has the talent, personality, and likability. Should reach the final 4. Kelly: Another Co-favorite just like Katharine. Simon was right when he said she could get votes just by telling the calamari story. Should reach the final 4. Kinnik: Unimpressive in a very strong group. Unless she really stands out next week, she will be gone. Lisa: Has a lot of talent and should be able to get to the remaining 6, from there it'll be interesting. Mandisa: Another very talented contestant whose only drawback could be her age. If she makes a connection with the younger crowd, she will go far. Melissa: Deserves to be in the final 12, but could be phased out since she is'nt well known. Paris: Third Co-Favorite of the group. It's amazing how different her singing voice is compared to her speaking voice. Final 4 likely. Overall: The ladies group is much better than the guys. It's unfortunate that we have to have 6 and 6 of each. There are some of the women who should be allowed to go on, since there are only 3 or 4 guys who deserve to be here. I think Ace & Gedeon should be the next guys to go. Kinnik will be gone also, after that it's tough. Melissa seems like the obvious choice to leave, but that's only if one of the other ladies does terrible next week. I think in the long run we will have another female American Idol.
ajzepp Posted March 4, 2006 Posted March 4, 2006 Here's my breakdown of who's left:Guys: Ace: He's very lucky to still be around. Both times he has been unimpressive. His good looks will carry him only so far. Bucky: Good at what he does which may limit him. Could make it to the final 12, but will be an early exit. Chris: One of the few guys who actually has talent. He will go far, maybe even to the last 2. Elliot: Middle of the pack contestant who has'nt stood out yet. Has a chance to go far, but must step up fast. Gedeon: Limited talent. Better off singing slow ballads then fast paced songs. Will not last much longer. Kevin: I think the kid is pretty good. Not the best, but not the worst either. Another middle of the pack guy. Taylor: In my opinion this is the dark horse contestant. Has talent, and could go far. If he stays consistent, he could sneak into the remaining 6 and get past a few of the projected favorites. Will: Has talent and could make some noise. Needs to show more emotion instead of just standing around. Ladies: Ayla: Probably the biggest surprise of the group. She has the voice, but could get overlooked due to her personality. Katherine: Co-favorite contestant, has the talent, personality, and likability. Should reach the final 4. Kelly: Another Co-favorite just like Katharine. Simon was right when he said she could get votes just by telling the calamari story. Should reach the final 4. Kinnik: Unimpressive in a very strong group. Unless she really stands out next week, she will be gone. Lisa: Has a lot of talent and should be able to get to the remaining 6, from there it'll be interesting. Mandisa: Another very talented contestant whose only drawback could be her age. If she makes a connection with the younger crowd, she will go far. Melissa: Deserves to be in the final 12, but could be phased out since she is'nt well known. Paris: Third Co-Favorite of the group. It's amazing how different her singing voice is compared to her speaking voice. Final 4 likely. Overall: The ladies group is much better than the guys. It's unfortunate that we have to have 6 and 6 of each. There are some of the women who should be allowed to go on, since there are only 3 or 4 guys who deserve to be here. I think Ace & Gedeon should be the next guys to go. Kinnik will be gone also, after that it's tough. Melissa seems like the obvious choice to leave, but that's only if one of the other ladies does terrible next week. I think in the long run we will have another female American Idol. 617941[/snapback] I'd say I pretty much agree with everything you said. The one I'm honestly not sure about is Elliot. He's had some REALLY good feedback, from Simon in particular. Simon saying he's maybe the best male vocalist EVER? That's high praise indeed! I just don't know that America feels the same way about him.....he's an interesting one. I do agree about Ace, completely. He's getting by on charm and good looks at this point....I've been very disappointed with his performances. Kevin, I feel, is the novelty act.....nothing more, but nothing less than that either. Gedeon is nothing special, but I really think Will IS.....He just needs to learn to ENTERTAIN in addition to sing. I agree about the women.....they're just a more talented group overall. I think Lisa, Paris, Ayla, Katherine, Kelly and Mandisa are probably as talented or more talented than every guy. I think you can throw Taylor and Chris into that group along with them, but you're exactly right that it should not be a balanced six and six. Girls #7 and #8 will be more talented than guys #5 and #6 in all likelihood. I do think it will be the strongest final 12 overall in the 5 year history of the show, though. I think the person who wins it will be someone who really transforms and brings out their stage presence; someone who has more charisma than they realize, and does all they can to make us aware of it. I can't wait to watch it unfold
Rico Posted March 9, 2006 Author Posted March 9, 2006 Word is that there will be a shocker cut on Thursday from the girls... I hope it's Paris! Definitely won't be Mandisa after last night, can't see anyone else beating her, I think she takes it all.
Recommended Posts