daquixers_is_back Posted January 15, 2006 Posted January 15, 2006 Exactly. He's Kelly or Marino of this era. Good, but not good enough. 568672[/snapback] Yes, but his stats are better than Kellys ... and if he keeps on this pace, will be better than Marino's also.
BuffOrange Posted January 15, 2006 Posted January 15, 2006 But how many time did John LOSE the big one before he won it? (Actually the PROPER wayh to ask that question is, "How many time did the Broncos, with Elway at QB, lose the big ones before they won one?") 568403[/snapback] He got there 3 times with a worst team than what Peyton has. Worst analogy ever.
Pine Barrens Mafia Posted January 15, 2006 Posted January 15, 2006 Yes, but his stats are better than Kellys ... and if he keeps on this pace, will be better than Marino's also. 568680[/snapback] Only stat that matters: SB wins.
PromoTheRobot Posted January 16, 2006 Author Posted January 16, 2006 He gets my vote for HOF right now. 568642[/snapback] For what? His QB rating? Certainky isn't for his playoff performance. PTR
daquixers_is_back Posted January 16, 2006 Posted January 16, 2006 For what? His QB rating? Certainky isn't for his playoff performance. PTR 568913[/snapback] Well then why is Marino and Kelly in the HOF? The biggest (most remembered in my opinion) Bills playoff game ever was Quarterbacked by Frank Reich and Kelly never won a Super Bowl. And neither did Dan Marino. So why are they in the HOF? Their QB rating?
ATBNG Posted January 16, 2006 Posted January 16, 2006 Now how can you put this loss on the shoulders of Peyton Manning? He had 2 bad passes (that I have seen) thus far. One that should have been picked off (that was thrown to Wayne) and another one that kinda was picked off but was taken back. He had at least two 3rd down and long plays where he threw short of the marker and his receiver was wrapped up easily. He threw several passes way over receivers as well. Polamalu dropped three interceptions. Was he the reason they lost? No, but he's also the highest paid player in the game, and he played a so-so game at best. He can't walk away feeling like he played well enough where they deserved to win. That "protection" comment after the game was disgraceful.
Recommended Posts