SouthernMan Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 Forget that the Bills have the # 8 pick and assume you could take any one player in the entire draft for your first round pick...who would it be? I'm not talking about trading a pick. I want to know who you'd take if you could have any draftee. I keep seeing a lot of posters getting geeked up about Bush, Leinhart, or Vince Young saying who great it would be if they could fall to the Bills. This amazes me. Aren't these kind of "sexy" picks exactly the reason the Bills are where they are today? Too many WRs, QBs, RBs, etc. wasted with the early picks. If it were my choice, I'd want the most dominant O-linemen who was the most intelligent, self-motivated, mature, and pro-ready of the bunch. If there were a D-linemen that was a gamebreaker, that would be tempting too. So you're on the clock with the first pick - who's your choice?
1gap2gap Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 Forget that the Bills have the # 8 pick and assume you could take any one player in the entire draft for your first round pick...who would it be? I'm not talking about trading a pick. I want to know who you'd take if you could have any draftee. I keep seeing a lot of posters getting geeked up about Bush, Leinhart, or Vince Young saying who great it would be if they could fall to the Bills. This amazes me. Aren't these kind of "sexy" picks exactly the reason the Bills are where they are today? Too many WRs, QBs, RBs, etc. wasted with the early picks. If it were my choice, I'd want the most dominant O-linemen who was the most intelligent, self-motivated, mature, and pro-ready of the bunch. If there were a D-linemen that was a gamebreaker, that would be tempting too. So you're on the clock with the first pick - who's your choice? 555063[/snapback] Mathias Kiwanuka DE Boston College
obie_wan Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 Although you don't want to hear it, the best move is to trade the pick for a package of picks/ players. The cost versus the risk of failure is too high for a player with zero NFL experience.
JStranger76 Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 Ferguson or Mario Williams. I'd probably flip a coin.
The Jokeman Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 So you're on the clock with the first pick - who's your choice? 555063[/snapback] To me it's easily D'Brickashaw Ferguson as in my eyes if you build a quality line (on either side of the ball) first and foremost. Hence my avatar and what's beneath it.
Mark VI Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 Although you don't want to hear it, the best move is to trade the pick for a package of picks/ players. The cost versus the risk of failure is too high for a player with zero NFL experience. 555085[/snapback] Spot on.
Adam Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 Forget that the Bills have the # 8 pick and assume you could take any one player in the entire draft for your first round pick...who would it be? I'm not talking about trading a pick. I want to know who you'd take if you could have any draftee. I keep seeing a lot of posters getting geeked up about Bush, Leinhart, or Vince Young saying who great it would be if they could fall to the Bills. This amazes me. Aren't these kind of "sexy" picks exactly the reason the Bills are where they are today? Too many WRs, QBs, RBs, etc. wasted with the early picks. If it were my choice, I'd want the most dominant O-linemen who was the most intelligent, self-motivated, mature, and pro-ready of the bunch. If there were a D-linemen that was a gamebreaker, that would be tempting too. So you're on the clock with the first pick - who's your choice? 555063[/snapback] I'd trade down and get the Brick
OnTheRocks Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 To me it's easily D'Brickashaw Ferguson as in my eyes if you build a quality line (on either side of the ball) first and foremost. Hence my avatar and what's beneath it. 555093[/snapback] this in my opinion is a no brainer. fortunately there doesn't seem to be a lot of brains working at One Bills Drive.
RuntheDamnBall Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 You know, it's half joking, but if Young comes out I probably would do anything in my power to get him. I'm talking Ditka, trade all my picks for this guy. Get your linemen in FA. And I'm a Losman guy. Young is a difference maker. Period. He showed it on the national stage, with a world of pressure -- and he was clutch against a team that could probably whup the crap out of a few NFL squads. Plus, handing the ball to the official and limited celebration before going for the two? Classy.
1gap2gap Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 Ferguson or Mario Williams. I'd probably flip a coin. 555089[/snapback] Mario Williams is talented but young and imature. He plays when he wants too. Mathias has almost as much talent but will handle the next level much better then Mario. (IMO) I also like The Brick but I believe there are a number of LT's and OT's in this draft that we can pick up later. We have four picks in the first day and if we get compensation for Pat Williams we just might have five picks in the first day. We should be able to get at least two studs for the O-line and a safety or CB.
Ramius Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 I dont think i can answer this question, as my judgement would be clouded by the Vince Young woodie i still have from the game last night.
Rico Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 IF Young is coming out, I'd trade the pick to Jerry Jones for a "reverse-Herschel Walker-like" stash of picks & players... unless I was Houston, then I'd take Young.
Adam Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 Although you don't want to hear it, the best move is to trade the pick for a package of picks/ players. The cost versus the risk of failure is too high for a player with zero NFL experience. 555085[/snapback] Thats only a good move when there are multiple guys rated very closely at the top of your board, and you are still guaranteed to get one of them
KOKBILLS Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 Although you don't want to hear it, the best move is to trade the pick for a package of picks/ players. The cost versus the risk of failure is too high for a player with zero NFL experience. 555085[/snapback] Agreed... But if I HAD to Pick one it would be Bush...He's a Gamebreaker/Playmaker...Can't have enough of those-type Players...
Sound_n_Fury Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 IF Young is coming out, I'd trade the pick to Jerry Jones for a "reverse-Herschel Walker-like" stash of picks & players... unless I was Houston, then I'd take Young. 555137[/snapback] That's the way you build a winner. Trade the pick and not bet the farm (or your salary cap) on a single "can't miss" guy.
mravenger Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 USC Offensive Line !!!!!!!!!!! Did You see the blocking for White? It was fantastic! Even though USC lost it wasto a very good Texas team, but the blocking was great!
Recommended Posts