Rico Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 Kiper was just on NFL Live. IF VY comes out: Before yesterday, Bush & Leinart were 1-2, with Young going 6-10. After yesterday, Young shot up to top 3 & could end up #1, too early to tell, should be a wild race to draft day. Kiper also said that Bush shouldn't be hurt by the perception that he went into a funk after that awful lateral.
Buckeye Eric Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 Did anyone mention anything about Troy Smith's performance against ND? This kid is underated and will be coming out in all likelihood in 2007.
dave mcbride Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 Kiper was just on NFL Live. IF VY comes out:Before yesterday, Bush & Leinart were 1-3, with Young going 6-10. After yesterday, Young shot up to top 3 & could end up #1, too early to tell, should be a wild race to draft day. Kiper also said that Bush shouldn't be hurt by the perception that he went into a funk after that awful lateral. 555979[/snapback] you know, bush had 187 combined yards from scrimmage along with a spectacular td. thurman had 190 combined along with a spectacular td v. the giants in the sb. the point is that he played pretty well and put up some big numbers.
Rico Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 Did anyone mention anything about Troy Smith's performance against ND? This kid is underated and will be coming out in all likelihood in 2007. 555984[/snapback] He had a hell of a game... if Young comes back next year, OSU - Texas in Austin will be wild!
Alaska Darin Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 I seriously doubt Vince Young will be anything more than a mediocre pro QB. That was a terrific performance last night but he'd be headless in the NFL playing the same way.
The Jokeman Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 I seriously doubt Vince Young will be anything more than a mediocre pro QB. That was a terrific performance last night but he'd be headless in the NFL playing the same way. 556049[/snapback] That's why some team will draft him high and refine that skill package into another Donovan McNabb or Steve McNair.
Alaska Darin Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 That's why some team will draft him high and refine that skill package into another Donovan McNabb or Steve McNair. 556060[/snapback] The skill sets don't compare.
AKC Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 I seriously doubt Vince Young will be anything more than a mediocre pro QB. That was a terrific performance last night but he'd be headless in the NFL playing the same way. 556049[/snapback] You are correct Sir. Let me purchase your next pint of Porter.
BuffOrange Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 I seriously doubt Vince Young will be anything more than a mediocre pro QB. That was a terrific performance last night but he'd be headless in the NFL playing the same way. 556049[/snapback] I agree. Scouts who never sleep and watch a ridiculous number of games aren't going to drastically change their draft boards based on one game. As great as he played last night he still served up an easy int w/ his team down by 12 which if caught - would've ended the game.
Last Guy on the Bench Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 I seriously doubt Vince Young will be anything more than a mediocre pro QB. That was a terrific performance last night but he'd be headless in the NFL playing the same way. 556049[/snapback] I disagree. What impressed me most was his ability to stay calm and take in the way each play was unfolding. He made a LOT of good decisions last night (and of course a few bad ones, but not many). With a head like that plus a "comeback" temperament, I'd be surprised if he didn't figure out a way to adapt himself to the pro game. His style of play might change somewhat, of course, and he won't be racking up 500 yard games, but I bet he's gonna be a fine and interesting player to watch for a long time. Keep him out of the AFC East.
CosmicBills Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 I disagree. What impressed me most was his ability to stay calm and take in the way each play was unfolding. He made a LOT of good decisions last night (and of course a few bad ones, but not many). With a head like that plus a "comeback" temperament, I'd be surprised if he didn't figure out a way to adapt himself to the pro game. His style of play might change somewhat, of course, and he won't be racking up 500 yard games, but I bet he's gonna be a fine and interesting player to watch for a long time. Keep him out of the AFC East. 556197[/snapback] Um...but he can't throw. So what is he going to do in the NFL? Be a running QB? At least Vick and McNabb could throw the football when they came out. Of course, Vick can't throw it very well, but he is still head and shoulders above Young. Young is a player without a position in the pro game. Bush is a 2 down player who isn't big enough to last in the NFL. He's Warrick Dunn plus one Leinert doesn't have the zip in his arm to be anything more than a so-so pro.
dave mcbride Posted January 6, 2006 Posted January 6, 2006 Bush is a 2 down player who isn't big enough to last in the NFL. He's Warrick Dunn plus one 556207[/snapback] http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/DunnWa00.htm 2 or 3 more good seasons, and mr. dunn will be most likely be making a trip to the hall of fame.
CosmicBills Posted January 6, 2006 Posted January 6, 2006 http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/DunnWa00.htm 2 or 3 more good seasons, and mr. dunn will be most likely be making a trip to the hall of fame. 556342[/snapback] Only topped 1,000 yards in less than half the years he played in the league. Those are not HOF numbers. Dunn is good, not great. Bush will be good, not great -- certainly not "the best ever" and certainly not worth the money he will be paid as a No 1 or 2 pick.
BEAST MODE BABY! Posted January 6, 2006 Posted January 6, 2006 Bush is a 2 down player who isn't big enough to last in the NFL. He's Warrick Dunn plus one People say some stupid siht on this board. Tiki Barber sucks too. He'll never last.
Adam Posted January 6, 2006 Posted January 6, 2006 I hope he returns to Texas- and I am the furthest thing from a Longhorn fan
BEAST MODE BABY! Posted January 6, 2006 Posted January 6, 2006 Bush will be good, not great -- certainly not "the best ever" and certainly not worth the money he will be paid as a No 1 or 2 pick. I guess this makes you the most recent prophet since Muhammad.
CosmicBills Posted January 6, 2006 Posted January 6, 2006 People say some stupid siht on this board. Tiki Barber sucks too. He'll never last. 556376[/snapback] I never said Dunn or Barber suck. I never even said Bush sucked.
BEAST MODE BABY! Posted January 6, 2006 Posted January 6, 2006 I never said Dunn or Barber suck. I never even said Bush sucked. 556387[/snapback] Well saying Bush is Warrick Dunn + 1 certainly isn't waxing poetic about either guy. And I still think you're comment about Bush not lasting is silly. People like you drop words like "prototypical" and "physical specimen" all the time, as if that's some good predictor of a player's success and constitution. These are the same types who get all doe-eyed and light-headed when a Todd Marinovich takes his shirt off.
CosmicBills Posted January 6, 2006 Posted January 6, 2006 Well saying Bush is Warrick Dunn + 1 certainly isn't waxing poetic about either guy. And I still think you're comment about Bush not lasting is silly. People like you drop words like "prototypical" and "physical specimen" all the time, as if that's some good predictor of a player's success and constitution. These are the same types who get all doe-eyed and light-headed when a Todd Marinovich takes his shirt off. 556430[/snapback] Not true at all. I just said that Bush is not an everydown player...EVEN IN COLLEGE. How can he expect to be one in the pros? And if you think that's wrong, just look at the game last night. 4th and 2, the biggest play of the year and he isn't even on the field. I'm not even sure he is the best back on the USC squad. He is a dynamic player, but his style of play is not suited for the NFL where he won't have the luxery of playing against soft defenses every other game. So how do you justify paying a guy top money when he isn't an every down back?
The Dean Posted January 6, 2006 Posted January 6, 2006 I'm not even sure he is the best back on the USC squad. 556445[/snapback] What's that again?
Recommended Posts