Mark Vader Posted January 3, 2006 Posted January 3, 2006 It's a shame that Terrence McGee is not going to the Pro Bowl as a KR, which he deserves to be. I know the main reason he did not get selected was because he did'nt have that many TD returns. I have only been following the Bills since Jim Kelly started playing, so I do'nt know the entire Bills history. So my question to all of you is this: Is Terrence McGee the best Kick Returner the Bills have ever had? I don't remember seeing a player on the Bills, even during the Super bowl years, who could return kicks as good as McGee has. Just want to get your reactions.
Hardy Pyle Posted January 3, 2006 Posted January 3, 2006 Chris Watson was pretty good. The infamous punt catcher.
WVUFootball29 Posted January 3, 2006 Posted January 3, 2006 It's a shame that Terrence McGee is not going to the Pro Bowl as a KR, which he deserves to be. I know the main reason he did not get selected was because he did'nt have that many TD returns. I have only been following the Bills since Jim Kelly started playing, so I do'nt know the entire Bills history. So my question to all of you is this: Is Terrence McGee the best Kick Returner the Bills have ever had? I don't remember seeing a player on the Bills, even during the Super bowl years, who could return kicks as good as McGee has. Just want to get your reactions. 549683[/snapback] Nope, Drew Haddad would be....least that was the general concensus this preseason. Moulds was a pretty darn good KR man his first 2 years in the league, but I checked back til about 1980's stats and found no one really better than McGee Bills stats
Kelly the Dog Posted January 3, 2006 Posted January 3, 2006 I have followed the Bills closely since the mid 1960s and McGee is by far the best KR the team has ever had. A combination of vision, speed, acceleration, cutting ability without losing speed, a knack for the big play and just plain being a football player makes him a really special player. He's probably the best in the NFL right now.
eSJayDee Posted January 3, 2006 Posted January 3, 2006 Levy made the comment that Moulds was the best he's ever seen. Statistically, I believe Wallace Francis is right up there. He only did it for a short period of time, so although I was following the Bills at the time, he didn't leave much of an impression on me. OJ did it the beginning of his career. I never saw him do that (a few years b4 my time), but based on seeing him in the open field on plays from scrimmage, I bet he was awesome (his stats bear that out).
/dev/null Posted January 3, 2006 Posted January 3, 2006 Nope, Drew Haddad would be....least that was the general concensus this preseason. 549696[/snapback] What about Antonio Brown
WVUFootball29 Posted January 3, 2006 Posted January 3, 2006 What about Antonio Brown 549752[/snapback] He stunk too...we was horrible as a returner/WR in college, always running sideline to sideline instead to endzone to endzone and could never catch anything but screens and even then he dropped his share. Soon as I heard buffalo signed I said, "Are you serious??? I had to deal with watching him in college, now I gotta see him on Sundays?"
Crap Throwing Monkey Posted January 3, 2006 Posted January 3, 2006 It's a shame that Terrence McGee is not going to the Pro Bowl as a KR, which he deserves to be. I know the main reason he did not get selected was because he did'nt have that many TD returns. I have only been following the Bills since Jim Kelly started playing, so I do'nt know the entire Bills history. So my question to all of you is this: Is Terrence McGee the best Kick Returner the Bills have ever had? I don't remember seeing a player on the Bills, even during the Super bowl years, who could return kicks as good as McGee has. Just want to get your reactions. 549683[/snapback] Best I've seen since I've watched the Bills (20-25 years). Next best in that time would be...Don Smith, I guess...?
Tcali Posted January 3, 2006 Posted January 3, 2006 It's a shame that Terrence McGee is not going to the Pro Bowl as a KR, which he deserves to be. I know the main reason he did not get selected was because he did'nt have that many TD returns. I have only been following the Bills since Jim Kelly started playing, so I do'nt know the entire Bills history. So my question to all of you is this: Is Terrence McGee the best Kick Returner the Bills have ever had? I don't remember seeing a player on the Bills, even during the Super bowl years, who could return kicks as good as McGee has. Just want to get your reactions. 549683[/snapback] I saw OJ......they were about equal. OJ was on the verge of breaking evry single one...but they kept a couple guys back as 'safeties';preventing the TD s.
ExWNYer Posted January 3, 2006 Posted January 3, 2006 I have followed the Bills closely since the mid 1960s and McGee is by far the best KR the team has ever had. A combination of vision, speed, acceleration, cutting ability without losing speed, a knack for the big play and just plain being a football player makes him a really special player. He's probably the best in the NFL right now. 549700[/snapback] Agreed. Levy made the comment that Moulds was the best he's ever seen.Statistically, I believe Wallace Francis is right up there. He only did it for a short period of time, so although I was following the Bills at the time, he didn't leave much of an impression on me. OJ did it the beginning of his career. I never saw him do that (a few years b4 my time), but based on seeing him in the open field on plays from scrimmage, I bet he was awesome (his stats bear that out). 549744[/snapback] I was going to mention Wallace Francis, also. Another would be Keith Moody, although Moody mainly returned punts.
Recommended Posts