Sound_n_Fury Posted September 26, 2005 Posted September 26, 2005 AMEN. They aren't even in the same ballpark in their first 3 starts. 455441[/snapback] Palmer's first three starts: Game 1....18/27 for 248 yards___2 TD___1 int___105.2 QB rating___31-24 Loss to NYJ Game 2....21/38 for 147 yards___0 TD___1 int___53.3 QB rating___16-13 Win over MIA Game 3....25/52 for 316 yards___0 TD___3 int___43.4 QB rating___23-9 Loss to BALT Looks pretty similar to JP to me, especially the 1-2 record and QB ratings in games 2 and 3.
LabattBlue Posted September 26, 2005 Posted September 26, 2005 Did you think that JP would give us a better chance to win than Bledsoe THIS season? Tell the truth. 455440[/snapback] The truth...DB would have given us a chance to go 9-7 or 10-6. If the Bills had made the playoffs, they would have been clobbered. I stand by my opinion that DB could not take the Bills to the SB. Therefore, I was in favor of the decision to let DB go and take our lumps with JP in 2005.
Ramius Posted September 26, 2005 Posted September 26, 2005 So to disprove your point, if you theoritically gave all 30 NFL coaches the choice of having either JPL or CP straight from college, do you know how many would pick JPL? ZERO! 455511[/snapback] ok, maybe i was wrong to compare you to b.harami...at least he knew the league has 32 teams...
Sound_n_Fury Posted September 26, 2005 Posted September 26, 2005 ok, maybe i was wrong to compare you to b.harami...at least he knew the league has 32 teams... 455705[/snapback] I think he was skipping Capers and Tice!
PTS Posted September 26, 2005 Posted September 26, 2005 ok, maybe i was wrong to compare you to b.harami...at least he knew the league has 32 teams... 455705[/snapback] Damnit. Just ruined my point. I can't keep track of teams anymore.
MDH Posted September 26, 2005 Posted September 26, 2005 JP Losman is no Carson Palmer. I wish people would stop comparing the two. 455437[/snapback] Carson Palmer wasn't "Carson Palmer" last year after 3 games either. Hell, very few QBs come out of the gate looking good; it doesn't mean they won't eventually be quality players. If every coach gave up on QBs as quickly as the people on this board there would be very few QBs who started more than 3 games in their entire career.
JOHNNYFAIRPLAY Posted September 26, 2005 Posted September 26, 2005 JP Losman is no Carson Palmer. I wish people would stop comparing the two. 455437[/snapback] He's also no Rob Johnson too. Have to see both sides
PTS Posted September 27, 2005 Posted September 27, 2005 He's also no Rob Johnson too. Have to see both sides 455989[/snapback] My God I'm actually going to say this... Rob Johnson would have won that game yesterday. I'm going to go put a pistol to my head now.
MDH Posted September 27, 2005 Posted September 27, 2005 My God I'm actually going to say this... Rob Johnson would have won that game yesterday. I'm going to go put a pistol to my head now. 456203[/snapback] Damn, I didn't know RJ could be used on D to shore up our run D. That guy was a talent!
ofiba Posted September 27, 2005 Posted September 27, 2005 Rob Johnson would have won that game yesterday. 456203[/snapback]
Oneida Lake Posted September 27, 2005 Posted September 27, 2005 I agree. Losman has to be given a couple of years. He would have to play ridiculously bad for him not to get all of this year and next to show his abilities. 455307[/snapback] Sounds like fun.
LabattBlue Posted September 27, 2005 Posted September 27, 2005 Sounds like fun. 456230[/snapback] More fun than watching a 10+ year vet in the twilight of his career needing an alarm clock in order for him to know when to throw the ball. http://www.dallascowboys.com
shoveldog Posted September 27, 2005 Posted September 27, 2005 This is silly. Yes, our D was the worst performer on Sunday, in terms of the 3 groups. But Losman was the worst INDIVIDUAL performer. Some of you are already starting to back off and say, well, it's going to take a while...we'll suck until he's ready. Don't forget: This team was supposed to win NOW, the same way the steelers did it with BRoethlisberger. The team referenced their situation many times. THey said they're winning NOW. They said it in a variety of ways. After game 1 it looked like they were demonstrating that vision. But the reality is we were just lucky to play such a horrid team to make us look better than we are. Losman is NOT seeing the field. He's not seeing wide open receivers. He's hesitating. He has addressed his failure to pull the trigger and yet it continues. I give him credit for his ownership but this glitch in his game is the worst glitch you can have. And it could haunt him his entire career. Which would make his career short. Hopefully he'll get over it. I Like the kid. But again, it's a coach's game. And mularkey has not impressed me yet. Like him, but I'm not impressed. If I could trade him right now for Saban, I would. Too negative for ya? Well, whatever. I'm sick of the same old story with minor edits. 455349[/snapback] I'm not sure where to pass blame, there is way to much of it to pass at the moment. But, I'll agree 100% with your assessment of JP. So many on this board want to justify... Will the kid be good, time will tell... But, right now, this minute, he is B-A-D, BAD. Rookie mistakes, maybe, but he's not even playing like a potential NFL quarterback at the moment. If he threw like this at a combine, he wouldn't have even been drafted, let alone in the 1st round. ` I'll also agree 100% that MM and TC need to set the kid up for success. If he is not throwing with any accuracy, stop giving him those throws to make. Give him more quick slants, quick outs, and screens to take the pressure off and get him some confidence in his throws.
CoachChuckDickerson Posted September 27, 2005 Posted September 27, 2005 Palmer's first three starts: Game 1....18/27 for 248 yards___2 TD___1 int___105.2 QB rating___31-24 Loss to NYJ Game 2....21/38 for 147 yards___0 TD___1 int___53.3 QB rating___16-13 Win over MIA Game 3....25/52 for 316 yards___0 TD___3 int___43.4 QB rating___23-9 Loss to BALT Looks pretty similar to JP to me, especially the 1-2 record and QB ratings in games 2 and 3. 455648[/snapback] Really? Twice as many passing yards through 3 games is close to you? Not to mention the 55% completion pertentage compared to 48% for JP. Okey Dokey.
boutwillis Posted September 27, 2005 Posted September 27, 2005 One thing that cant be helped are injuries. We have to swallow it and let JP do what he has to do learn.
djfarr00 Posted September 27, 2005 Posted September 27, 2005 WTF...Did you expect Losman to be an All-Pro right out of the gate. Go back and take a look at Eli Manning when he came in for Warner last year. 3 games and you are ready to write off his career. Did I expect that Losman through 3 games would show more signs than he has? Sure I did, but I'm not ready to write him off, because he hasn't. 455394[/snapback] Eli Manning (and i'm not a fan) was a true rookie last year. JPL saw time in the preseason last year / a few games last year / the entire offseason to study the playbook / preseason this year. Its not even close to compare a 1st season rookie w/ ultra high expectations to a second year qb w/ no experience. They're from different worlds and clearly moving in different directions.
PTS Posted September 27, 2005 Posted September 27, 2005 Damn, I didn't know RJ could be used on D to shore up our run D. That guy was a talent! 456214[/snapback] It didn't matter how bad everyone else played because that game was winable if you had a QB with any awareness on the field. JP lost that game. Yes, the defense didn't play great but we should have won that game without a doubt.
NJ_BillsFan Posted September 27, 2005 Posted September 27, 2005 JP is not awful. He has many strengths and weaknesses. His weakness is inexperience. Hopefully he will gain enough experience that he will be our qb of the future.
pkwwjd Posted September 27, 2005 Posted September 27, 2005 Really? Twice as many passing yards through 3 games is close to you? Not to mention the 55% completion pertentage compared to 48% for JP. Okey Dokey. 456366[/snapback] the "end all and be all" of statistics, the QB rating has Carson's first 3 games at 60.88 JP's first three 59.99 actually their stats are comparable other things not taken into account in QB rating: sacks yielded -- JP 7 for 57, CP 10 for 68 rushing yards -- JP 15 for 64, CP 3 for 12 fumbles lost -- each 1 sounding better and better all the time ... take into account, CP's one win was against a Miami squad that won how many games last year? ...
mead107 Posted September 27, 2005 Posted September 27, 2005 It didn't matter how bad everyone else played because that game was winable if you had a QB with any awareness on the field. JP lost that game. Yes, the defense didn't play great but we should have won that game without a doubt. 456489[/snapback] you can say the same about the defense. JP played well enough to win the game led us to 16 points . yes JP did not play great . but he is not the one who gave up 200 plus yards on the ground .
Recommended Posts