wnyguy Posted Tuesday at 08:05 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:05 PM I gotta give shout out to Derrick Burroughs who was great until that damn injury cut his career short. I remember him getting torched his first couple of seasons but he became fantastic for us afterwards. Quote
Robert James Posted Tuesday at 08:06 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:06 PM 28 minutes ago, JÂy RÛßeÒ said: Bob James. If only medical technology was 40 years further along when he tore a knee ligament cause in the 70's it was almost a sure career-ender I agree completely! 1 Quote
Augie Posted Tuesday at 08:06 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:06 PM (edited) 28 minutes ago, Motorin' said: He wasn't half the CB that Vontae Davis was. ….but he was a fine “punt catcher”, that Chris Watson was….. Edited Tuesday at 08:33 PM by Augie Quote
Sierra Foothills Posted Tuesday at 08:06 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:06 PM 24 minutes ago, njbuff said: Chris Watson 2 minutes ago, Motorin' said: He wasn't half the CB that Vontae Davis was. True but Watson was inarguably the best punt catcher in Buffalo Bills history. Quote
Neo Posted Tuesday at 08:11 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:11 PM 31 minutes ago, oldmanfan said: I’ve seen them all. I’d say Robert James. Here’s my top 5: Robert James Tre White Nate Clements Nate Odoms Booker Egerson Bingo across the board and in order! Quote
billsbackto81 Posted Tuesday at 08:12 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:12 PM Antoine Winfield Tre White Nate Odomes Nate Clements At least during my time actively watching since the late 80s 2 1 Quote
wnyguy Posted Tuesday at 08:13 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:13 PM 1 minute ago, Drey said: Leodis McKelvin That damned fumble though. 1 1 Quote
GunnerBill Posted Tuesday at 08:15 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:15 PM It is Gilmore or White in my era (since 2002). Quote
Sierra Foothills Posted Tuesday at 08:16 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:16 PM 2 minutes ago, Drey said: Leodis McKelvin 1 minute ago, wnyguy said: That damned fumble though. He couldn’t carry Chris Watson’s jar of Stickum. 1 Quote
oldmanfan Posted Tuesday at 08:18 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:18 PM 6 minutes ago, Neo said: Bingo across the board and in order! Butch Byrd was 5b to Booker at 5a. Both excellent coverage guys. Quote
D. L. Hot-Flamethrower Posted Tuesday at 08:20 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:20 PM Sure looks like its Butch Byrd when you look at the facts like AP,PB, championships etc. 2 Quote
MJS Posted Tuesday at 08:26 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:26 PM (edited) 1) Butch Byrd (and it isn't close) 2) Charles Romes 3) Terrence McGee 4) Nate Odomes 5) Robert James Honorable mentions: Tre White, Mario Clark, Nate Clements, Booker Edgerson Edited Tuesday at 08:28 PM by MJS 2 Quote
Rigotz Posted Tuesday at 08:28 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:28 PM (edited) 36 minutes ago, Billl said: Stephon Gilmore This is the correct answer. 2019 Defensive Player of the Year. 7 Cornerbacks have ever won that award. Ever. Total. He might not have had all his best years on the Bills, but he's the best corner. -- Edit: LOL at all of the lists that don't have him in the top 5. Cmon. Edited Tuesday at 08:29 PM by Rigotz Quote
MJS Posted Tuesday at 08:35 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:35 PM 5 minutes ago, Rigotz said: This is the correct answer. 2019 Defensive Player of the Year. 7 Cornerbacks have ever won that award. Ever. Total. He might not have had all his best years on the Bills, but he's the best corner. -- Edit: LOL at all of the lists that don't have him in the top 5. Cmon. He isn't even close to the top 5 in Bills history. He simply did not have much of an impact here. He went to other teams and had his impact. He is not a top 5 Bills corner, plain and simple. Quote
Augie Posted Tuesday at 08:35 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:35 PM 22 minutes ago, wnyguy said: That damned fumble though. He’d do it again! 😂 Quote
Buffalo716 Posted Tuesday at 08:38 PM Posted Tuesday at 08:38 PM (edited) 3 minutes ago, MJS said: He isn't even close to the top 5 in Bills history. He simply did not have much of an impact here. He went to other teams and had his impact. He is not a top 5 Bills corner, plain and simple. He was massively underrated here though People called him a bum consistently throughout his career but I always was clamoring that Gilmore was a All-Pro on a bad team One great corner doesn't make or break a team but he wasn't the reason we were bad.. I certainly did think he was a top corner even with the bills who got a bad rep Like I'm not putting a rank on him one through five but he was a stud here.. he played with a club.. people used to question his toughness and he played with a broken hand lol Edited Tuesday at 08:38 PM by Buffalo716 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.