McAfee Defamation Allegations

[Since1981]

6 hours ago, DabillsDaBillsDaBills said:

He never used her name and tossed out some "allegedly's". The guy is allowed to reference a rumor on his show. 

That won’t protect against defamation in this case. By being cagey, he knew he was on thin ice 

[BillsPride12]

3 hours ago, BringMetheHeadofLeonLett said:

"What?" - well it made sense in someone's mind- glad I'm not the only one who saw that.  

 

On Pat McAfee, it's just mind-blowing how far down the pole of decency some of us allow ourselves to slide.  He's after the 'key demographic' of 18-34 year olds.  It's not an accident he did this, or kept pressing the topic- probably slipping ratings, but man no class to even dip into this. 
 

Jerry Springer, Giraldo Rivera, 'Married... With Children', political hack radio... it was all a bunch of trash which normalized this garbage- Don't get me wrong, MWC had a bunch of funny ish, but it was total trash entertainment.  Problem was, people didn't get that, and demanded more and more.  Welcome to the world of grown adult men talking scandalousness about teenage girls.  Barf

Where's Tipper Gore when we need her most

Dude Married with Children was not like the other things you just lumped it in with 

[Augie]

So, this is what I’m missing because I avoid ESPN? I can live without garbage like this. 

[BillsPride12]

1 hour ago, Augie said:

So, this is what I’m missing because I avoid ESPN? I can live without garbage like this. 

ESPN is nothing like it used to be.  The only thing on ESPN I like to watch are the 30 for 30s but they don't even seem to be doing those anymore

[DabillsDaBillsDaBills]

4 hours ago, Since1981 said:

That won’t protect against defamation in this case. By being cagey, he knew he was on thin ice 

 

Are you a lawyer? 

 

To me, as a layperson, it seems like there's enough grey area this would be a tough lawsuit to win. Especially when you consider McAfee has the resources to buy the best defense attorneys. 

 

This reminds me of when McAfee was sued by Brett Favre for defamation. Favre withdrew the lawsuit with no settlement after McAfee clarified a few things. I guess that case is a bit different since Favre is a public figure and this girl is not.  

 

For this case I could see McAfee throwing some settlement $$ her way, but I'd be surprised if he loses the lawsuit. 

[Pete]

38 minutes ago, BillsPride12 said:

ESPN is nothing like it used to be.  The only thing on ESPN I like to watch are the 30 for 30s but they don't even seem to be doing those anymore

FU Disney for destroying ESPN

[Mango]

14 hours ago, cgang said:

Exactly.  I have two daughters in college and I feel the same way.  That guy is a POS and him being a shock jock doesn’t count as an excuse.  But I guess I’m giving him what he wants by starting this thread.  What a disgrace. 

 

The tough part is that he's not a shock jock. He's a new aged sports commentator. I think there is a line there especially because this starts to color way outside the lines of sports.

 

If 2002 Howard Stern did this it would be another wild and crazy thing he said/did it would burn bright for a moment and fizzle until he did that next absurd thing. He also openly doesn't follow sports and it would disappear much quicker.

 

Point being, PM isn't a shock jock. 

[appoo]

it's not even difficult. You're a sports guy. Stop talking about sex and you'll be good

[uticaclub]

19 hours ago, appoo said:

He and the other barstool bros ruined that young ladies life for absolutely no reason other than clout 

He has not been associated with Barstool for several years.

[Since1981]

7 hours ago, DabillsDaBillsDaBills said:

seems like there's enough grey area this would be a tough lawsuit to win

Either the person being sued (the defendant) or the one doing the suing (the plaintiff) can ask for a jury trial—and if one of them does, it usually happens. But keep in mind, once you’re in front of a jury, all bets are off. I’d expect a young college girl who didn’t do anything wrong to come across as a pretty sympathetic plaintiff.

[appoo]

48 minutes ago, uticaclub said:

He has not been associated with Barstool for several years.

no but a couple of Barstool guys (or perhaps ex barstool guys) jumped on this crap, and I think one of them even pushed a memecoin with her name

[cgang]

There is something about this story that really struck a nerve.  I’ve been a member of this Board since 2005 (I think even before that in the earliest versions of this board) and I think this is only the second topic that I started (sorry all- I first posted this to the Stadium Wall and not this one so thanks Mods!). 
 

The thing that gets me is how callous McAfee and his bros were and how it wasn’t at all a sports topic.  I am a lawyer and I don’t know how this will all play out, but I’m glad the young woman and her family are fighting back.  I don’t think they are opportunistic btw.  They want accountability and I fully support that.  Can’t imagine how I would feel if I was her father.  Hell McAfee is a father now to a baby girl- maybe he’ll grow up and want to be more responsible but I doubt it. His $85M gig is a lot. 

[BillsPride12]

It was irresponsible of McAfee to bring this up on his show but this story was already all over Twitter before he mentioned it.  The way social media is used today especially amongst the younger kids is just a big cesspool and further declining modern society as we know it.  

[djp14150]

On 4/2/2025 at 8:55 PM, Coach Tuesday said:

When you talk for a living - this stuff is basically inevitable.

What am I missing?  This student incident doesn’t appear to involve Dart or some other ole miss athlete….so why do sports shows even talk about this?

[Snappysnackcakes]

I’ve read the article again and still found no Buffalo Bills-related information. McAfee didn’t play for Buffalo and I think this needs to be in a different forum. I mean, when I posted about needing at-game assistance for some Tuck’s wipes and it was promptly removed. I was at the Titans game in OP back in, I believe, 2009. The weather was beautiful (warm) and I’d overindulged some wings the night before. 

[Simon]

23 hours ago, Snappysnackcakes said:

I’ve read the article again and still found no Buffalo Bills-related information. McAfee didn’t play for Buffalo and I think this needs to be in a different forum.

 

You do realize you're already in the non-Bills Off the Wall section, right?

[Pete]

Pat shouldn’t have talked about it.  But I posted a picture of her and the father which looked like a couple in the picture.  But the picture was removed.  This was not made up from thin air.  Things are often not what they seem.  But rumors usually start from some smidgen of truth 

[Mark Vader]

On 4/3/2025 at 7:03 AM, BillsPride12 said:

ESPN is nothing like it used to be.  The only thing on ESPN I like to watch are the 30 for 30s but they don't even seem to be doing those anymore

They still have great coverage of college football & college basketball.

 

That's about it.

[BillsPride12]

14 hours ago, Mark Vader said:

They still have great coverage of college football & college basketball.

 

That's about it.

I don't really follow college sports too much except for following some draft coverage around this time of the year

[Mark Vader]

15 hours ago, BillsPride12 said:

I don't really follow college sports too much except for following some draft coverage around this time of the year

I can't help you.