TSW 1.0 Poll - Who should the Bills select at #30 (Poll Closed)

[Virgil]

For this poll, I focused on all positions that weren't QB/FB/TE with a ESPN draft grade of 87 or higher.  

 

Poll will close at 8am on 4/3/25.  

 

The eligible players are based upon those who were not already selected in the TSW 1.0 Mock draft linked below:

 

 

 

Edited 5 hours ago by Virgil

[BillsFanMike]

Not much to pick from talent wise. I hope Beane has an Ace up his sleeve.

 

[Virgil]

Just now, BillsFanMike said:

Not much to pick from talent wise. I hope Beane has an Ace up his sleeve.

 

 

Yeah, there were a few players that went right before us that I would have been excited about.  Most of these players have 2nd round grades, which is to be expected when picking at 30.  

[TBBills Fan]

Any of the CBs.  I think amos may be the best for us 

Edited 22 hours ago by TBBills Fan

[No_Matter_What]

If we are including unlikely positions, then TE Loveland should be in based on his consensus ranking, which is top 20. Also DT Williams was mentioned couple times as potential 1st round pick. But none of them will be chosen eventually so who cares

 

Looks like a solid pool to choose from. 

 

I say BPA between WR/DL/CB. Nolen?

 

 

[Virgil]

Just now, No_Matter_What said:

If we are including unlikely positions, then TE Loveland should be in based on his consensus ranking, which is top 20. Also DT Williams was mentioned couple times as potential 1st round pick. But none of them will be chosen eventually so who cares

 

Looks like a solid pool to choose from. 

 

I say BPA between WR/DL/CB. Nolen?

 

 

 

I didn't even look at TE's.  I feel like this board would explode 😜

[GunnerBill]

I voted Amos (I just think he is perfect for our scheme) but if Scourton was on the list..... I'd have gone for him.

 

My view on Green is if he is there at #30, you should stay away. Because he only makes it that far is the off field stuff is bad (and I have spoken to one beat reporter this week, not Bills different market who said what we know at this point is tip of the iceberg).

[HappyDays]

If Mike Green falls this far in the real draft it's probably because of his old sexual assault allegations... He sticks out as the clear BPA to me and he fits a need. His pass rush skill set also happens to complement Rousseau perfectly. So I voted for him. But I don't know if Beane would overlook the allegations.

[scuba guy]

2 minutes ago, Virgil said:

 

Yeah, there were a few players that went right before us that I would have been excited about.  Most of these players have 2nd round grades, which is to be expected when picking at 30.  

Yup in the real world I think we trade back with Tennessee and grap,a 3rd rounder and give them one of our 5th rounderz

[Virgil]

1 minute ago, HappyDays said:

If Mike Green falls this far in the real draft it's probably because of his old sexual assault allegations... He sticks out as the clear BPA to me and he fits a need. His pass rush skill set also happens to complement Rousseau perfectly. So I voted for him. But I don't know if Beane would overlook the allegations.

 

Are the allegations resolved, or is there possibility for future suspensions?

Just now, scuba guy said:

Yup in the real world I think we trade back with Tennessee and grap,a 3rd rounder and give them one of our 5th rounderz

 

If there's a player we are confident will pan out at DT or DB, I could see them wanting to stay put for that 5th year contract option. 

 

Overall, I think we are trying to either utilize less picks this year and trade up, or gain picks for next year.  

 

10 draft picks aren't going to make the team this year.  

[HappyDays]

5 minutes ago, No_Matter_What said:

If we are including unlikely positions, then TE Loveland should be in based on his consensus ranking, which is top 20.

 

There is a legitimate case that he's BPA right now. If Beane stuck to the board and picked him I imagine his next move would be trading Kincaid. That would be a real tough pill to swallow though.

[scuba guy]

6 minutes ago, HappyDays said:

 

There is a legitimate case that he's BPA right now. If Beane stuck to the board and picked him I imagine his next move would be trading Kincaid. That would be a real tough pill to swallow though.

Yeah put if kc does n ot trade up for the 3 best ot in the class I can see them taking a te

[Logic]

6 minutes ago, HappyDays said:

 

There is a legitimate case that he's BPA right now. If Beane stuck to the board and picked him I imagine his next move would be trading Kincaid. That would be a real tough pill to swallow though.

This is where Beane's "BPA at a position of need" comes into play.

If they draft Colston Loveland and give up on Dalton Kincaid after an injury filled sophomore year (after he showed real promise is a rookie), I'd be truly shocked.

I won't argue that he may be BPA based on what's sitting there right now, but I just can't realistically see it. We all know Beane doesn't REALLY draft BPA anyway, even if he gives lip service to it.

[LABILLBACKER]

Nolen or Amos, unless Grant falls.

[GunnerBill]

13 minutes ago, HappyDays said:

If Mike Green falls this far in the real draft it's probably because of his old sexual assault allegations... He sticks out as the clear BPA to me and he fits a need. His pass rush skill set also happens to complement Rousseau perfectly. So I voted for him. But I don't know if Beane would overlook the allegations.

 

I think it is probably because the known about sexual assault allegations are not all there is on him. And based on the rumour mill that is the way it is trending. 

[nosejob]

I wouldn't be mad at Nolan. He may be the BPA  DT at 30. On a side note I think Burch will be really good....not at 30 of course.

[GunnerBill]

I have 6 guys remaining graded higher than Loveland (one isn't on the poll though).

[MJS]

13 minutes ago, LABILLBACKER said:

Nolen or Amos, unless Grant falls.

There have been a few mocking Grant to the Bills, like Daniel Jeremiah.

[LEBills]

Amos is a good player but Nolen is the better player

13 minutes ago, GunnerBill said:

I have 6 guys remaining graded higher than Loveland (one isn't on the poll though).

princely?

[TOboy]

I think Nolan is the BPA, but not a great fit beside Ed. 
 

I voted Amos as he’s a better fit.