Another one - Trey Hendrickson asks for a trade from Cincy

[Bleeding Bills Blue]

On 3/17/2025 at 7:01 PM, FireChans said:

Yup.

 

The Diggs v Jefferson conversation is funny to me because I think the biggest thing Josh needed was a PROVEN offensive superstar in his corner as opposed to a great rookie. 
 

Now, do I think Josh becomes the superstar elite QB he is with JJ instead of Diggs? Probably, yeah. But I will never ever hold that trade against Beane. Diggs had the gravitas to help Josh grow. It was 100% the right move and even in hindsight, I still think I make it. 

Asking above, if you could go back and draft JJ, knowing how Josh turned out with Diggs, would you do it?

 

I always think like... if we get the power of hindsight - don't the raiders?  or the eagles? or any of the other teams in front of the bills pick?  They would all take jefferson too.  

 

1 minute ago, The Firebaugh Kid said:

Id give em a 2nd all day. The problem is his salary I’d assume.

Insanely underpaid and he has no guarantees beyond this year.  He's already on his 2nd team and has made around 60 million dollars so... i don't see a scenario where he plays under that contract.  He's a 31 year old all-pro averaging 14 sacks per year the last 5, who just watched Hunter and Garrett get big paydays at similar ages. 

 

He either gets traded and extended, or extended in cincy, but there's really no reason to cave and risk injury in a walk year.  Especially when you have already made a lot of money, and you watched your team give 0 time pro-bowl/all-pro WR Higgins almost 29M AAV.  

[Warriorspikes51]

18 minutes ago, The Firebaugh Kid said:

Id give em a 2nd all day. The problem is his salary I’d assume.

 

30 - Grant

56 - Hendrickson

62 - Porter 
109 - Caldwell

SEND IT 

[Mark Vader]

3 hours ago, Warriorspikes51 said:

 

30 - Grant

56 - Hendrickson

62 - Porter 
109 - Caldwell

SEND IT 

We should get at least a draft pick from the Bengals as well.

[KingBoots8]

On 3/17/2025 at 7:01 PM, FireChans said:

Yup.

 

The Diggs v Jefferson conversation is funny to me because I think the biggest thing Josh needed was a PROVEN offensive superstar in his corner as opposed to a great rookie. 
 

Now, do I think Josh becomes the superstar elite QB he is with JJ instead of Diggs? Probably, yeah. But I will never ever hold that trade against Beane. Diggs had the gravitas to help Josh grow. It was 100% the right move and even in hindsight, I still think I make it. 

Asking above, if you could go back and draft JJ, knowing how Josh turned out with Diggs, would you do it?

100% agree - we wanted someone with experience to help give Josh a trusted receiver. With a rookie you have no real idea if the game is too big for them.

 

The other thing I see all the time is people act like it was Diggs for Jefferson - it wasn’t. It was Diggs for pick # 22, and a few day 3 picks. Had the Eagles drafted JJ instead of Reagor we would have been begging to go get a guy like Diggs. Eagles screwed up (a rarity in the draft lately) and JJ fell to the Vikings. (The thought of JJ being on that team is terrifying lol).
 

We got an experienced starter to help Josh grow, Vikes got a rookie who could rely on Kirk Cousins to get the ball to him. Both teams technically won and got what they needed, but yeah the a Vikings just happened to have a generational talent fall to 22. If Diggs could keep his ego/attitude/mouth from getting locker rooms to hate him we wouldn’t even be having this conversation.

 

 

 

Edited to add: As for Hendrickson, he is worth a day 2 pick but I don’t know how we could afford him. I think we explored the option, got his price tag, and decided to extend our own players instead.

Edited Thursday at 06:16 PM by KingBoots8

[nosejob]

47 minutes ago, KingBoots8 said:

100% agree - we wanted someone with experience to help give Josh a trusted receiver. With a rookie you have no real idea if the game is too big for them.

 

The other thing I see all the time is people act like it was Diggs for Jefferson - it wasn’t. It was Diggs for pick # 22, and a few day 3 picks. Had the Eagles drafted JJ instead of Reagor we would have been begging to go get a guy like Diggs. Eagles screwed up (a rarity in the draft lately) and JJ fell to the Vikings. (The thought of JJ being on that team is terrifying lol).
 

We got an experienced starter to help Josh grow, Vikes got a rookie who could rely on Kirk Cousins to get the ball to him. Both teams technically won and got what they needed, but yeah the a Vikings just happened to have a generational talent fall to 22. If Diggs could keep his ego/attitude/mouth from getting locker rooms to hate him we wouldn’t even be having this conversation.

 

 

 

Edited to add: As for Hendrickson, he is worth a day 2 pick but I don’t know how we could afford him. I think we explored the option, got his price tag, and decided to extend our own players instead.

I don't see how we could make this happen either.  I think it's time for BB and McD to establish a young core and PLAY them. Screw the bottom of the barrel vets and bottle feeding rookies. ie. Draft the hell out of the Dline and make it a strength and not like it took so long to make an Oline.

 

BTW just as a prediction, I think Ty Robinson from Nebraska will be a Bill. Kyle Williams 3.0

Edited Thursday at 07:03 PM by nosejob