Does Dion Dawkins make the Wall of Fame

[AlCowlingsTaxiService]

No, for the  same reason that the HOF isn’t the Hall of Very Good. 

[BarleyNY]

The WoF is as much for the fans to show love to the players as it is for the Bills to acknowledge their contributions to the team. So IMO Dawkins is an obvious yes. Now get Kyle Williams on there. 

 

Edited Sunday at 03:01 PM by BarleyNY

[MJS]

5 hours ago, Doc Brown said:

There's a backlog in my opinion of guys who need to get in first.  Ruben Brown, Moulds, Butch Byrd, Kyle Williams, and Aaron Schobel.  If they let Hansen (no pro bowls) in then those guys should get in too.  Cornelius Bennett is more controversial and maybe we can just swap him with OJ when going to the new stadium and nobody will notice.

I totally agree on Byrd, Brown, and Williams. I could see Schobel as well. We'll see where Dawkins slots at the end of his career.

 

I'd also like to see Brian Moorman. He has the accolades. Yeah, he was a punter, but I don't care.

[Nelius]

He gets a ring and he leapfrogs everybody else mentioned

[T.E.]

5 hours ago, ChronicAndKnuckles said:

Dawkins is easily the most under respected player on the Bills by fans.

I would argue the opposite is true. Most Bills fans talk about him like he's Jonathan Ogden. This thread is a perfect example.

[First Round Bust]

he would have to finish the rest of his career as a Bill and make some pro bowl teams and win a ring or two...

 

moreover...

 

I wish he would win NFL Man Of The Year...as he is consistently the Bills candidate for very good reason, and he also lives in city and is often at Sabres games.

 

I know of no other Bill that lives in city...corect if I am wrong here...(Jerry Hughes used to live in the city as well back in the day - add past Bills that used to live in the city if you know- can)

[The Cincinnati Kid]

I think we all have to ask if a player is in our personal lore and tie to the team. For me, it’s Kelly, Thurman and Reed from when I was kid. Then it was Flutie, Bledsoe and Moulds paired with Price and Henry. I loved Freddie Jackson and Stevie Johnson with Fitz. And now Allen, Dawkins, Milano, Hyde, White, and Poyer. I don’t have any connection to Ferguson, Kemp, OJ or those guys. So they’re not really on my Wall of Fame for the Bills. As much as it’s an organizational honor, it’s pretty personal, I think.

[Mikie2times]

If we never reach a Super Bowl, I don't think it happens. Part of the reason those early 90's teams got so many in is the sustained deep playoff success. That group is considered more of a dynasty than say the current Allen led group. From the current Allen led group, Dion is probably the next closest to Josh, but that doesn't mean he's a lock. A lot of it will boil down to winning a title or not. If we do get one I would say it swings to him being closer to a lock.  

[ChronicAndKnuckles]

33 minutes ago, T.E. said:

I would argue the opposite is true. Most Bills fans talk about him like he's Jonathan Ogden. This thread is a perfect example.

Yes because he’s shut up most of the haters he had earlier in his career with consistent high level play. 

4 hours ago, Moulds_80 said:

This

User name checks out 👍

[Don Otreply]

Of players in the Allen era, absolutely YES, when was the last time anyone talked seriously about replacing him? Sure some loud mouths have blurted out some nonsense concerning Dion, but those folk are readily ignorable, you know, kinda like me, 😁🍸🚬

[Roundybout]

1 hour ago, MJS said:

I totally agree on Byrd, Brown, and Williams. I could see Schobel as well. We'll see where Dawkins slots at the end of his career.

 

I'd also like to see Brian Moorman. He has the accolades. Yeah, he was a punter, but I don't care.

 

I feel like Schobel would be a shoo-in if he didn't completely drop off the face of the planet after he retired. 

[JerseyBills]

Yes,  he has been elite the last 3 years or so and was always above average.  And he'll have 3 or more SBs as 17s LT 

[LABILLBACKER]

13 hours ago, GunnerBill said:

To me, yes he is. Obviously Kyle Williams first. Then Dion. I've argued before there is a case for Hyde and Poyer too... I'd put them on as a duo. 

I agree, Dion does deserve it but Kyle goes first.

[NewEra]

💯 

[Beast]

He’s on the wall or whatever it will be at the new stadium. No question about it.

Edited Sunday at 09:34 PM by Beast

[Kirby Jackson]

Yes!! Jim Ritcher and Phil Hansen are on the WOF. 

Edited Sunday at 10:45 PM by Kirby Jackson

[Matt_In_NH]

I want to say yes but the holding pro bowl guy does not seem to get consideration...Ruben Brown.