Rank your Top 10 Bills QBs

[2003Contenders]

4 minutes ago, JP51 said:

Dude Clod Collins gotta be in this mix someplace... 

And let's not forget Billy Joe "I never read my playbook" Tolbert.

Edited 6 hours ago by 2003Contenders

[Jamie Nails]

4 minutes ago, JP51 said:

Dude Clod Collins gotta be in this mix someplace... 

People dont remember how good Lamonica was before we traded him away... bad move... bring on Dennis Shaw.... 

 

Had him on there, but it would have been 11 all time greats! 

[transient]

28 minutes ago, Jamie Nails said:

Nathan Peterman

Gibran Hamden 

Billy Joe Hobert

Vince Young 
Matt Leinert 

Cardale Jones 

Thad Lewis 

Matt Simms

Jeff Tuel 

Alex Van Pelt  

He's definitely #1 on the list of Chroisiest QBs ever to play for the Bills.

[Kirby Jackson]

2 hours ago, JP51 said:

I am sure we are going to get the same players pretty much... I am interested in where they end up in your rankings...  I am also interested in where Kelly and Allen show up in your picks...  here are mine

 

Allen

Kelly

Kemp

Ferguson

Flutie

Bledsoe

Fitz

Lamonica

Tyrod

Frank Reich

 

 

Allen and Kelly isn’t a debate at this point. Allen is 1 and Kelly is 2. It honestly isn’t that close. Please, please, please don’t use the Super Bowl argument. If Allen had Kelly’s roster he would have won 3+.
 

Also, Bledsoe sucks. If you remove the first 8 games and look at the rest of the time, it’s Losman or EJish. He is far too high and his success was just 8 games. He was atrocious after that. I’ve pulled the numbers here before but couldn’t search it (assuming it’s from the ever switch). At any rate he had as many turnovers as TDs, led the league in sacks and a horrible completion percentage. 
 

Allen

Kelly

Kemp

Flutie

Lamonica

Fitz

Tyrod

Ferguson

Bledsoe

Orton

 

*I am only considering starters.

Edited 6 hours ago by Kirby Jackson

[GerstAusGosheim]

I swear to god if someone seriously puts Rob Johnson on this list.

[ControllerOfPlanetX]

Trying making this list for the Jets…

[GerstAusGosheim]

4 minutes ago, ControllerOfPlanetX said:

Trying making this list for the Jets…

1: Richard Todd

[Dan Darragh]

45 minutes ago, Jamie Nails said:

Nathan Peterman

Gibran Hamden 

Billy Joe Hobert

Vince Young 
Matt Leinert 

Cardale Jones 

Thad Lewis 

Matt Simms

Jeff Tuel 

Alex Van Pelt  

How did Brian Brohm not make this list?

[Jay_Fixit]

Since I became a fan in 1989 at the age of 9…

 

Kelly

Allen

Bledsoe

Fitzpatrick

Johnson

Flutie (gritting my teeth as I hate this guy)

Reich

Taylor

Orton

Edwards before injury

 

 

 

[JP51]

1 hour ago, ControllerOfPlanetX said:

Trying making this list for the Jets…

I would defo have a bourbon or 2 before attempting 

[Fleezoid]

How come nobody's got this guy on their list......

 

 

 

 

Edited 5 hours ago by Fleezoid

[SoTier]

3 hours ago, JP51 said:

I am sure we are going to get the same players pretty much... I am interested in where they end up in your rankings...  I am also interested in where Kelly and Allen show up in your picks...  here are mine

 

Allen

Kelly

Kemp

Ferguson

Flutie

Bledsoe

Fitz

Lamonica

Tyrod

Frank Reich

 

 

 

I can't disagree with your list.  The bottom of that list is pretty sad.  FTR, Lamonica and Reich weren't even starters for the Bills.

[ControllerOfPlanetX]

49 minutes ago, JP51 said:

I would defo have a bourbon or 2 before attempting 

Their #1 guy has more career interceptions than TD passes….almost 50 of them!!
 

 

[dwight in philly]

4 hours ago, JP51 said:

I am sure we are going to get the same players pretty much... I am interested in where they end up in your rankings...  I am also interested in where Kelly and Allen show up in your picks...  here are mine

 

Allen

Kelly

Kemp

Ferguson

Flutie

Bledsoe

Fitz

Lamonica

Tyrod

Frank Reich

 

 

Pretty much nailed it , may substitute Dennis Shaw for Tyrod though 

[BontitaBills]

3 hours ago, Jamie Nails said:

Nathan Peterman

Gibran Hamden 

Billy Joe Hobert

Vince Young 
Matt Leinert 

Cardale Jones 

Thad Lewis 

Matt Simms

Jeff Tuel 

Alex Van Pelt  

No Joe Dufek?

[The Frankish Reich]

3 hours ago, JP51 said:

Dude Clod Collins gotta be in this mix someplace... 

People dont remember how good Lamonica was before we traded him away... bad move... bring on Dennis Shaw.... 

Hey, watch it. Dennis Shaw was my first sports hero (o.k., I was 6)

[MJS]

5 hours ago, DrDawkinstein said:

I get what youre saying. I'd also argue that if Allen had Kelly's defenses he would have WON 4 Super Bowls already.

If Allen had the 90's defense they wouldn't make the postseason because every defensive player would be suspended under the current rules.

1 hour ago, ControllerOfPlanetX said:

Their #1 guy has more career interceptions than TD passes….almost 50 of them!!

And more losses than wins. That's the real tell.

[The Frankish Reich]

3 hours ago, ControllerOfPlanetX said:

Trying making this list for the Jets…

I'll bite.

1. Namath (yeah, I know, didn't really deserve the HOF, but still ... first AFL/C Super Bowl)

2. Testaverde

3. Todd

4. O'Brien

5. Pennington

6. Favre

7. Fitz

8. Sanchez

9. Boomer

10. O'Donnell

 

You could argue that other than the Top 2 (Kelly/Allen vs. Namath/Vinny), the Jets 3-10 are actually better than the Bills 3-10. Of course that doesn't matter, does it.

 

[DrDawkinstein]

46 minutes ago, MJS said:

If Allen had the 90's defense they wouldn't make the postseason because every defensive player would be suspended under the current rules.

 

 

Maybe the drug and rape rules. But their on-field play was just fine. Maybe Leonard Smith...

[boyst]

 

Mitch Trubisky

Matt Lienert 

Vince Young

Matt Barkley

Kevin Kolb

 

Edited 2 hours ago by boyst