Who is Buffalo's most under rated player?

[klos63]

36 minutes ago, tomur67 said:

I think we have several ( many) underrated players,  but Mack Hollins has made several game changing plays along with Ty Johnson and Dawson Knox.

Could a player that gets a lot of attention and promotes himself like crazy be underrated? 

I think everyone recognizes his value. 

[FireChans]

Josh Allen tbh

[The Firebaugh Kid]

26.

[Goin Breakdown]

Josh of course. That poll was already taken. 

[QB Bills]

David Edwards. He's the key to the almost always guaranteed QB sneak conversion.

[Bookie Man]

Damar

[0017]

Ashton Youboty! Just kidding! 😂 For me it’s gotta be Spencer Brown, he is playing at a All-pro level and is only getting better, the entire O-line is absolutely balling this year and I think has to do with the approach and attitude he brings every game!! 

[BillsfaninSB]

1 hour ago, peterpan said:

The center or left guard. Can’t even think of their names right now 

Agreed on McGovern. 

[muppy]

 

 

Underrated this season?  Ray Davis. Until he blew up. Ty Johnson. Same. Who knew they would be as valuable as they are?

[Bills Fan in MD]

Ty Johnson.  The guy does so much.  We all know about the clutch catches but he's also great at pass protection.

[Buffalo Junction]

To the national media… everyone besides Allen, Dawkins, Von, and Milano. I’d throw Taron Johnson in there, but there are only a few pundits - mostly former players - that seem to understand his importance. 
 

Bills fans tend to underrate Knox. They often forget how good of a blocker he’s become, and neglect how he tends to show up at critical moments - especially scrambles. 

[GASabresIUFan]

Benford.  He is a top 5 corners in the NFL, but no in the media outside of Western NY even mentions him with Mr. I wasn't holding Surtain, Gardner or Winfield Jr etc... Pff grade for Benford is 82.6 which was 5th of 223 CBs in 2024.  

 

After Benford it's Spenser Brown.  Like Benford he is almost certainly in the top 5 players at his position and gets little to no love nationally. 

[Savage]

1 hour ago, HOUSE said:

A sure sign of being under rated 

Or under the influence.

 

[ChasBB]

Wow, 18 or 19 different players referenced in this thread so far.  That says a lot about this roster that so many players fit the description of underrated.

[Shortchaz]

1 hour ago, Buffalo_Stampede said:

Definitely Rousseau.

He’d qualify for an overrated thread. 

 

 

[GASabresIUFan]

10 hours ago, ChasBB said:

Wow, 18 or 19 different players referenced in this thread so far.  That says a lot about this roster that so many players fit the description of underrated.

This is definitely a "No-name" roster beside Josh and maybe Cook.  Taron Johnson and Dawkins get some love here and there but that's about it. 

 

Just looking at some Spencer Brown stats.  Only 1 sack and only 3 hits allowed all season.  Those are insanely low numbers for a NFL tackle. Dawkins numbers are 3 sacks and 4 hits.  Also insanely low numbers for a tackle.  

Edited Friday at 01:12 PM by GASabresIUFan

[Orlando Buffalo]

Apparently no one on the defense is any good, but of course most people only saw the LA and DET game so it is hard to argue with casual fans. On offense it is Shakir to me, no one knows who he is but he burns everyone. 

[Governor]

Cook.

 

Fans think he can be replaced with any 4th rounder and I don’t believe that. His unique skill set and ball security commands a premium that we should be willing to pay.

Edited Friday at 03:03 AM by Governor

[Don Otreply]

That Brit rugby guy…,

[KCNC]

Benford or Brown