VABills Posted June 26, 2005 Posted June 26, 2005 I was watching Peter Jacobson and friends on TV early this morning on Golf Channel. That had some "famous" guitar maker on there. Well the format is they talk a little about golf, as well as the professions of each of the guests. He said something to the effect that what we as "civilians" see in guitar player is wrong. We have no clue what makes a great guitar player. He said the ones that everyone lists in the top 100 are terrible and could not compare with the real greats. He pretty much implied that most people would not appreciate it and the bands would not be able to handle good players. Did anyone see this? I really think he was taking a mjor jab at the Van Halens, Eric Claptons, etc... of the world.
Ghost of BiB Posted June 26, 2005 Posted June 26, 2005 I was watching Peter Jacobson and friends on TV early this morning on Golf Channel. That had some "famous" guitar maker on there. Well the format is they talk a little about golf, as well as the professions of each of the guests. He said something to the effect that what we as "civilians" see in guitar player is wrong. We have no clue what makes a great guitar player. He said the ones that everyone lists in the top 100 are terrible and could not compare with the real greats. He pretty much implied that most people would not appreciate it and the bands would not be able to handle good players. Did anyone see this? I really think he was taking a mjor jab at the Van Halens, Eric Claptons, etc... of the world. 368210[/snapback] You get up on a Sunday morning and tune in the guitar conversation on the golf channel? And here, I thought MY life was boring.
Fixxxer Posted June 26, 2005 Posted June 26, 2005 i had a guitar and i still can not play it 368213[/snapback] Did you ever try to learn? I say this because I have a guitar but I never tried to take my hobby further. I'm not good but I think if I learned a bit I could be average.
VABills Posted June 26, 2005 Author Posted June 26, 2005 You get up on a Sunday morning and tune in the guitar conversation on the golf channel? And here, I thought MY life was boring. 368216[/snapback] It was on when I flipped the TV on. I like the Kelly Thigeman (sp??) that is on there. I am thinking shower scene with her.
Ghost of BiB Posted June 26, 2005 Posted June 26, 2005 It was on when I flipped the TV on. I like the Kelly Thigeman (sp??) that is on there. I am thinking shower scene with her. 368224[/snapback] Did you check out my Italian golfer photo? Sophie is kinda cute.
VABills Posted June 26, 2005 Author Posted June 26, 2005 Did you check out my Italian golfer photo? Sophie is kinda cute. 368229[/snapback] No, where is it. And why are you shitting on my thread.
Ghost of BiB Posted June 26, 2005 Posted June 26, 2005 No, where is it. And why are you shitting on my thread. 368233[/snapback] In the Wie thread. And... 1. Because I can. 2. Chances are, you were the only one watching anyway.
VABills Posted June 26, 2005 Author Posted June 26, 2005 In the Wie thread. And... 1. Because I can. 2. Chances are, you were the only one watching anyway. 368234[/snapback] Well people don't know good TV either. I guess if it isn't American Idol, Lost, etc... then it doesn't matter.
Ghost of BiB Posted June 26, 2005 Posted June 26, 2005 Well people don't know good TV either. I guess if it isn't American Idol, Lost, etc... then it doesn't matter. 368235[/snapback] And you went to bed watching the golf channel. You DO know you're talking to someone who has never seen a single episode of either of them.
coltrane34 Posted June 26, 2005 Posted June 26, 2005 I was watching Peter Jacobson and friends on TV early this morning on Golf Channel. That had some "famous" guitar maker on there. Well the format is they talk a little about golf, as well as the professions of each of the guests. He said something to the effect that what we as "civilians" see in guitar player is wrong. We have no clue what makes a great guitar player. He said the ones that everyone lists in the top 100 are terrible and could not compare with the real greats. He pretty much implied that most people would not appreciate it and the bands would not be able to handle good players. Did anyone see this? I really think he was taking a mjor jab at the Van Halens, Eric Claptons, etc... of the world. 368210[/snapback] Ok here is another topic that I guess you need to be better informed on. The mainstreem guitar players especially rock guitarists cannot hold a candle to the true masters of the instrument. Eddie, Slash, and the glam rockers cannot play music outside of ther genres because they are not very talented. Look into real muscisians like emmit ray, paco deluccia, al demiola, john scofield, and there are about 500 more. These guys can play anything and would embarass any mainstreem rocker.
VABills Posted June 26, 2005 Author Posted June 26, 2005 Ok here is another topic that I guess you need to be better informed on. The mainstreem guitar players especially rock guitarists cannot hold a candle to the true masters of the instrument. Eddie, Slash, and the glam rockers cannot play music outside of ther genres because they are not very talented. Look into real muscisians like emmit ray, paco deluccia, al demiola, john scofield, and there are about 500 more. These guys can play anything and would embarass any mainstreem rocker. 368240[/snapback] Guess you didn't read, that is what this guy implied. I have no clue, because I don't have a musical bone in my body.
Alaska Darin Posted June 26, 2005 Posted June 26, 2005 Ok here is another topic that I guess you need to be better informed on. The mainstreem guitar players especially rock guitarists cannot hold a candle to the true masters of the instrument. Eddie, Slash, and the glam rockers cannot play music outside of ther genres because they are not very talented. Look into real muscisians like emmit ray, paco deluccia, al demiola, john scofield, and there are about 500 more. These guys can play anything and would embarass any mainstreem rocker. 368240[/snapback] There's a pretty big hole in your argument considering Eddie Van Halen was trained as a classical pianist and comes from a family well versed in same. I saw him jamming at a NADY show with Holdsworth and he held his own just fine and they were basically playing fusion. Randy Rhoads was pretty much the same way.
coltrane34 Posted June 26, 2005 Posted June 26, 2005 There's a pretty big hole in your argument considering Eddie Van Halen was trained as a classical pianist and comes from a family well versed in same. I saw him jamming at a NADY show with Holdsworth and he held his own just fine and they were basically playing fusion. Randy Rhoads was pretty much the same way. 368253[/snapback] That still is not on the same level as these virtouso's. My apologies if that is what the thread implied.
Campy Posted June 26, 2005 Posted June 26, 2005 Eddie, Slash, and the glam rockers cannot play music outside of ther genres because they are not very talented. 368240[/snapback] I totally agree with the gist of your post, but I think it'd be a mistake to lump EVH into that category. FWIW, I play.
Ghost of BiB Posted June 27, 2005 Posted June 27, 2005 I totally agree with the gist of your post, but I think it'd be a mistake to lump EVH into that category. FWIW, I play. 368264[/snapback] I do as well. For almost 40 years. So does the CTM, believe it or not. Not everyone can be an Andres Segovia. For that matter, some of the best true musicians, technique-wise, play bluegrass or jazz/blues. Many of them are classically trained - have won competitions, but you've probably never heard of them. Where's Azalin when you need him? Most commercial players ARE one trick ponies, but because of genre, I would caution against the stereotypes.
mead107 Posted June 27, 2005 Posted June 27, 2005 Did you ever try to learn? I say this because I have a guitar but I never tried to take my hobby further. I'm not good but I think if I learned a bit I could be average. 368221[/snapback] took lessons for a year teacher said I try something else .
Zac Posted June 27, 2005 Posted June 27, 2005 It is so much harder to play guitar in a jazz ensemble then a band.
Ghost of BiB Posted June 27, 2005 Posted June 27, 2005 It is so much harder to play guitar in a jazz ensemble then a band. 368309[/snapback] You mean there is something besides C-D-E? cool.
Zac Posted June 27, 2005 Posted June 27, 2005 You mean there is something besides C-D-E? cool. 368318[/snapback] Nahhh...
Recommended Posts