Bills All Pro 1st team

[oldmanfan]

3 hours ago, Danger Mouse said:

Sorry - I'm sure you've done this so many time before

 

But I'm really interested in your views. 

 

The game here is, obviously, the best Bills of all time per position. But  one player per position.

 

Not the established best. The one YOU think is best. in YOUR opinion:

 

 

Quote reply answers and educate me:

 

QB

RB:

WR:

TE:

OT:

G:

C :

 

DE:

OLB:

MLB:

CB:

FS/SS: 

 

P:

K - actually, no. 

 

KR: 

 

Head Coach:

QB:  Allen

RB:  OJ

FB:  Cookie

WR:  Reed, Jerry Butler tie

TE:  Warlick

OT:  Barber

G:  Joe D and Shaw tie

Center:  Hull

 

DE:  Bruce

DT:  Sestak

NT:  P Williams

OLB:  Bennett and Stratton tie

ILB:  Fletcher

CB:  Robert James

FS:  Saimes

SS:  Hyde/Poyer

K:  Christie

P:  Moorman

KR:  McGee

ST: Tasker

 

Coach:  Marv

 

 

[BucketList]

14 hours ago, Danger Mouse said:

Sorry - I'm sure you've done this so many time before

 

But I'm really interested in your views. 

 

The game here is, obviously, the best Bills of all time per position. But  one player per position.

 

Not the established best. The one YOU think is best. in YOUR opinion:

 

 

Quote reply answers and educate me:

 

QB: Allen

RB: OJ

WR: Lofton

WR: Moulds

TE: Metzelaars

OT: Peters, Dawkins

G: DeLamielleure, Shaw

C : Hull

DT: K Williams, T Washington 

DE: Smith, Mario Williams

OLB: Paup, Bennett

MLB: Fletcher

CB: Winfield, R James

FS/SS: Byrd, Hyde

 

P: McGuire

K: Christie

 

ST: Tasker

 

Head Coach: Saban

 

[JP51]

14 hours ago, buffblue said:

QB - Billy Joe Tolliver

RB - Christian Wade

WR - Kelvin Benjamin

TE - Lonnie Johnson

T - Mike Williams

G - Vlad Ducasse

C - Duke Preston

 

DE - Ryan Denney

DT - John McCargo

OLB - Jeff Posey 

MLB - John DiGiorgio

CB - Chris Watson/Justin Rogers

S - Pierson Prioleau

 

K - Nick Mike-Mayer

P - Matt Haack

KR - Chris Ivory

 

Head Coach - Hank Bullough

Awesome... I would make a case for Erik Flowers at DE, and Ed Wang at tackle he was a beast! LOL 

[frostbitmic]

 

QB - Jim Kelly ... Took us to 4 Super Bowls ... Josh will move to #1 with a SB victory

RB: OJ ... Yeah he had off field issues but on field he was the best

WR: Andre Reed ... Not even close really and James Lofton

TE: Dalton Kincaid ... Not yet but he'll own all TE records for this team by the time he's done.

OT: Dion Dawkins and House Ballard would be imposing bookends

G: Jim Ritcher and Erik Wood

C : Kent Hull

 

DE: Bruuuuuuuuce and Phil Hanson

DT - Pat Williams and Ted Washington ... They didn't run on them

OLB: Darryl Talley, Personal favorite and Milano

MLB: Chris Spielman

CB: Antoine Winfield and Nate Odomes

FS/SS: Hyde and Poyer together in their primes

 

P: Brian Moorman

K - Steve Christie

ST - Steve Tasker ... Honorable to Mark Pike

KR: Nyheim Hines ... Two TDs in one game locks this up.

 

Head Coach: Marv Levy ... 4 AFC Championships

 

 

 

Edited 2 hours ago by frostbitmic

[MJS]

11 hours ago, Mango said:

Jason Peters is a first ballot HOF LT. No idea how he isn’t on anybodies list. 

 

Andre and Moulds were both better receivers than Stef. Shocked he’s on here twice. 
 

No hate on Smerlas or Kyle, but Ted Washington deserves some love here.

 

Peters is a HOF player for another team. He barely played for the Bills, so I don't even consider him a former Bills great. You can if you want, though.

[JaCrispy]

15 hours ago, Sojourner said:

There’s some we haven’t had any AP1 player at but with AP2 team, they all can be filled except Tight End. 
 

QB: Allen

RB: Thurman

WR: Diggs

TE*: Metzelaars

OT: Wilford

G: Joe D

C : Hull

 

DE: Bruce

DT: Smerlas

OLB: Paup/Biscuit

MLB: Spikes

CB: Odomes 

FS/SS: Byrd

 

P: Moorman

K: Norwood, actually yes. 

 

KR: McGee

 

Head Coach: Marv

I know you didn’t specify that they had to be an All-Pro selection but I did it anyway lol

Norwood= No

 

I would take Christie over him

[Kelly to Allen]

12 hours ago, oldmanfan said:

QB:  Allen

RB:  OJ

FB:  Cookie

WR:  Reed, Jerry Butler tie

TE:  Warlick

OT:  Barber

G:  Joe D and Shaw tie

Center:  Hull

 

DE:  Bruce

DT:  Sestak

NT:  P Williams

OLB:  Bennett and Stratton tie

ILB:  Fletcher

CB:  Robert James

FS:  Saimes

SS:  Hyde/Poyer

K:  Christie

P:  Moorman

KR:  McGee

ST: Tasker

 

Coach:  Marv

 

 

 

Jim Kelly / J. Allen 

Oj

Thurman / J. Cook

Butler 

Moulds

Reed/ Shakir

Kincaid / Knox 

Dawkins 

R. Brown 

Hull

Joe D/ Torrence 

S. Brown 

 

Bruce

Rousseau 

Oliver 

V. Miller 

Cowart

Milano / T. Bernard 

Bennett 

C. Benford 

Winfield / T. Johnson 

Jones 

Hyde

 

Christie 

Mohr

Tasker

Parrish 

 

I'm extremely bias towards the current bills team because I think they'll win a couple super bowls. 

 

Also Allen needs to at least get to a super bowl for me to 100% put him over Kelly. Kelly going to 4 Straight is insane and elite. 

 

Kelly is number 1, Allen number 2 right now 

Edited 2 hours ago by Kelly to Allen

[Flip Johnson]

29 minutes ago, frostbitmic said:

 

QB - Jim Kelly ... Took us to 4 Super Bowls ... Josh will move to #1 with a SB victory

RB: OJ ... Yeah he had off field issues but on field he was the best

WR: Andre Reed ... Not even close really

TE: Dalton Kincaid ... Not yet but he'll own all TE records for this team by the time he's done.

OT: Dion Dawkins and House Ballard would be imposing bookends

G: Jim Ritcher and Erik Wood

C : Kent Hull

 

DE: Bruuuuuuuuce

DT - Pat Williams and Ted Washington ... They didn't run on them

OLB: Darryl Talley ... Personal favorite

MLB: Chris Spielman

CB: Antoine Winfield

FS/SS: Hyde and Poyer together in their primes

 

P: Brian Moorman

K - Steve Christie

 

KR: Nyheim Hines ... Two TDs in one game locks this up.

 

Head Coach: Marv Levy ... 4 AFC Championships

OJ had "off field issues"?

 

 

[The Jokeman]

16 hours ago, WotAGuy said:

Maybe Allen. That’s it. 

Allen, OJ and Bruce are the only realistic options. Joe D is an honorable mention.

[frostbitmic]

3 minutes ago, Flip Johnson said:

OJ had "off field issues"?

 

 

Just a couple, not worth mentioning really

 

[Kelly to Allen]

1 minute ago, The Jokeman said:

Allen, OJ and Bruce are the only realistic options. Joe D is an honorable mention.

Was joe d better than Ruben Brown? I wasn't old enough to watch the electric company oline

[Sojourner]

20 minutes ago, JaCrispy said:

Norwood= No

 

I would take Christie over him

oh definitley, but that was more a joke to his “actually, no” hence the actually yes lol

[Kelly to Allen]

6 minutes ago, Flip Johnson said:

OJ had "off field issues"?

 

 

 

 

Nope. If the glove doesn't fit, you must acquit!!!...

 

😂

Edited 2 hours ago by Kelly to Allen

[The Jokeman]

1 minute ago, Kelly to Allen said:

Was joe d better than Ruben Brown? I wasn't old enough to watch the electric company oline

I didn't see Joe D either as been watching since the mid 80s lol

[Kelly to Allen]

Just now, The Jokeman said:

I didn't see Joe D either as been watching since the mid 80s lol

 

My father said Reggie McKenzie was awesome too. So idk. 

 

 

[The Jokeman]

16 minutes ago, Kelly to Allen said:

 

Jim Kelly / J. Allen 

Oj

Thurman / J. Cook

Butler 

Moulds

Reed/ Shakir

Kincaid / Knox 

Dawkins 

R. Brown 

Hull

Joe D/ Torrence 

S. Brown 

 

Bruce

Rousseau 

Oliver 

V. Miller 

Cowart

Milano / T. Bernard 

Bennett 

C. Benford 

Winfield / T. Johnson 

Jones 

Hyde

 

Christie 

Mohr

Tasker

Parrish 

 

I'm extremely bias towards the current bills team because I think they'll win a couple super bowls. 

 

Also Allen needs to at least get to a super bowl for me to 100% put him over Kelly. Kelly going to 4 Straight is insane and elite. 

 

Kelly is number 1, Allen number 2 right now 

Give Josh Thurman, Reed, Lofton and Bruce and would imagine we would have won one as he doesn't seem to fold under pressure like Jimbo did.

[Kelly to Allen]

Yup. Reggie McKenzie made 3 all pro teams. That's awesome. I didn't know that 

3 minutes ago, The Jokeman said:

Give Josh Thurman, Reed, Lofton and Bruce and would imagine we would have won one as he doesn't seem to fold under pressure like Jimbo did.

 

 

Kelly was fine in SB 25

 

Kelly had Hof performance in the 90 playoff and 93 playoff. Beat Montana in 93, Marino in 90, 92. Elway in 91 but that was obviously the defense. 

 

I can't remember the numbers but Kelly vs the raiders in 93 had almost 300 yds, 3 tds, zero int and it was like -30 wind chill with wind and ice. It's one of the greatest bad weather playoff performances in NFL playoff history 

Edited 2 hours ago by Kelly to Allen

[oldmanfan]

22 minutes ago, Kelly to Allen said:

 

Jim Kelly / J. Allen 

Oj

Thurman / J. Cook

Butler 

Moulds

Reed/ Shakir

Kincaid / Knox 

Dawkins 

R. Brown 

Hull

Joe D/ Torrence 

S. Brown 

 

Bruce

Rousseau 

Oliver 

V. Miller 

Cowart

Milano / T. Bernard 

Bennett 

C. Benford 

Winfield / T. Johnson 

Jones 

Hyde

 

Christie 

Mohr

Tasker

Parrish 

 

I'm extremely bias towards the current bills team because I think they'll win a couple super bowls. 

 

Also Allen needs to at least get to a super bowl for me to 100% put him over Kelly. Kelly going to 4 Straight is insane and elite. 

 

Kelly is number 1, Allen number 2 right now 

I’m biased to the AFL teams because I watched them and because they won two championships.

[Kelly to Allen]

 

[GASabresIUFan]

QB: Josh Allen

RB: OJ Simpson

RB2: Thurmon Thomas

WR: Andre Reed

WR2: Jerry Butler

WR3: Diggs

TE: Pete Metzelaars

OT: Wolford, Dawkins

G: Joe DeLamielleure, Billy Shaw

C : Kent Hull

 

DE: Bruce Smith

DE2: Aaron Schobel

DT:  Fred Smerlas, Kyle Williams

OLB: Biscuit

MLB: Talley

CB: Nate Odomes

FS/SS: Hyde & Poyer

 

P: Marv Bateman

K - Steve Christie

Special Teams: Tasker

KR: McGee

 

Head Coach: McDermott