Poll: Would you trade Coleman for Worthy straight up?

[BillsFanForever19]

13 hours ago, Lost said:

In regards to the below thread @Roundybout started relating to Bills WR lack of separation.  I think an easy test of whether that actually matters or not could be decided if at this point in time, if people would rather have Xavier Worthy who is undeniably a better separator than Coleman.   According to next gen stats Worthy's avg separation is 3.6 to Keon's 2.2.   I suspect most people after half a season of play to evaluate would rather keep Coleman over Worthy but let's let the votes speak for themselves.  

 

 

 

Worthy has much better separation - but what the tape shows is if the man in front of him puts his hands on him at the line, he's done for.

 

I'll take the guy that can't separate as well but can out physical his man, is 4 inches taller, and 50 lbs heavier.

Edited 11 hours ago by BillsFanForever19

[DCofNC]

I would not, Keon has that dawg in him that we need on this team.  Having an enforcer that can just go take the ball has been missing for years.  
 

That said, I’d love to have a burner for Josh to take shots to, but I don’t necessarily think Worthy is the guy.  Call me nuts, but I don’t see a guy weighing less than the average 18 yr old high school senior, holding up in the NFL.  

[frostbitmic]

232-2 this is close

[HappyDays]

4 hours ago, Brandon said:

No, but in the weeks leading up to the draft,  Ladd McConkey was my highest rated WR outside the top 3 and I would've taken him over either Coleman or Worthy.  At the time,  I thought the Bills were so weak at WR that position within that group mattered significantly less than just finding someone who could play,  with the lack of speed and separation being another important factor.  

 

As it stands,  I don't necessarily feel bad about that at all.  McConkey is having an excellent rookie year.  Would I make an even trade of Coleman for McConkey today?  Probably not,  as Coleman has been playing well in his own right. 

 

McConkey is never going to be much better than he is right now IMO and he'll likely be relegated to the slot. High floor low ceiling type of player. I think you can find that skill set in the 3rd round or later. Big physical WRs with elite body control don't make it out of the top 40. I am all about drafting for the future, not for year one. And as we're seeing with Coleman sometimes that future comes faster than you think for the physically gifted players.

[Cursed]

I look forward to looking back at this particular year's WR class in a few years.

[ControllerOfPlanetX]

No straight up…I would have to be drunk.

[Billsatlastin2018]

Geez Louise!
Head Banging on Counter!

 

The Bills, because they play in an open air stadium which highlights the elements of wind,rain,sleet & snow in the back half of the Season never need an SEC Smurf WR!

 

They need EXACTLY what they got in Coleman!

 

A huge dude with an added 38 inch vertical who plays above the heads of his defenders and catches contested balls because of it!

 

A huge powerful QB who can throw it up high!

 

A match made in Lombardi heaven.

 

OBD has needed this for a generation!

 

FINALLY! ✔️👏🎉🏈👍

[NewEra]

@LostWhy make this poll anonymous?

[NewEra]

8 hours ago, machine gun kelly said:

Coleman is ranked at the top on yards after catch.  No thanks on the confusing supposition.  Coleman had his first 100+ game 2 games ago, and 73 yrs and a TD against Seattle.

 

we don’t need to do anything now that we have Cooper, Coleman, Shakir, and Kinkaid.

[billsfan89]

Is this a serious question? 

 

[AlCowlingsTaxiService]

After nearly half a season of evidence, it’s a hard no. However, I do believe that this offense would be even better with someone who could take the top off a defense at WR

[Since1981]

Cooper is a good substitute. 

[Prospector]

[zow2]

Nah.  and to be honest, Keon would probably work really well with Mahomes and Reid in their offense.  KC may wish to go back in time when both careers are sized up someday.