Poll: Would you trade Coleman for Worthy straight up?

[Since1981]

Beane obviously made the choice already. Speed vs body manipulation/ size. Beane saw that 17 better benefit for body manipulation/size over speed. No trade. 

[DCofNC]

On 10/30/2024 at 12:40 PM, BullBuchanan said:

The bills have been chasing a big-bodied redzone target for as long as I can remember. It seems they finally have one, and I don't see them having regrets about that. Sure, he may have Lee Smith speed, but he seems like he'll be a good one to have when other receivers can't get open. Reminds me of Dez Bryant. Hopefully he stays healthier.

It’s been a massive need for years, happy to have Coleman.  Speed like Worthy would be great as well, but there seems to be a lot more guys that can run fast vs guys than big guys who can play WR at a high level.   So overall, I’ll take the big guy.

[Buffalo Ballin]

Nah.

 

Big body capable WR are hard to get.

Speed is everywhere.

Remember, we have Shakir to take care of speed.

We're good.

[machine gun kelly]

I like Tee Higgins, but we may need the $ for extending other contracts.  It’s a lot cheaper to draft a 1st rd WR or at least a 2nd.

[Solomon Grundy]

39 minutes ago, oldmanfan said:

Coleman does things Worthy can’t do and Worthy does things Coleman can’t do

Coleman is just as dangerous with bubble screens as Worthy. Bills just don't give him the opportunity to present himself 

[MDH]

Coleman isn’t there yet and may never get there, but Worthy is a gadget guy at best and will never be worthy of a 1st. If given a do over I’d still prefer Leggett but between Coleman and Worthy I’ll take Coleman. 

[JerseyBills]

Not with this group of WRs, Worthy must be schemed up to be effective, gets bullied at the LOS, isn't good at all in the run game.

Coleman 1 v 1 seems to have Allens  complete confidence,  they should've had that 50 yard beauty called back by that bs penalty and the fade route vs Sauce which was on Allen. 

 

Worthy will have a role in this league for a while but I'm very content with Coleman, even if we took him at 28 , I think he'll be what Kelvin Benjamin was supposed to be- an elite big bodied WR , he just has to work on his hands , 2 drops, both difficult catches though but I believe he will work his butt off. 

[Eastport bills]

1 hour ago, Not at the table Karlos said:

His hands have been very inconsistent. Idk if I’d call them good yet. 

You’re absolutely right, his reputation at Fla. St. was he caught everything. He’s dropped some catchable balls but he’s showing flashes, with his length that he can dominate on 50/50 balls and he plays with an edge. I think he turns into a prime target once Josh develops trust. We have an embarrassment of riches with all the receivers that are talented.

[Don Otreply]

3 hours ago, Big Blitz said:

 

Looks like he gets separation to me…, 

[Nephilim17]

I'm not saying Worthy is great or will be but I think at this point, YES, I would trade him for Coleman. He turns those short swing passes and screens into consistent 8-yard gains. That's big. His outside speed is just too fast. I hope he doesn't turn into more but he may. Coleman is not consistently offering anything substantial. I suppose that could change next year but I fear KC is out-drafting us with WRs and D lineman.

I hope I'm wrong but tonight when it mattered — the 2025 AFCC — Worthy had a greater impact by a considerable margin.

[ghostwriter]

I wanted to trade up for BTJ. I wanted Worthy if we stayed put. I didn’t want Coleman but I gave him a chance.

[The Frankish Reich]

44 minutes ago, Nephilim17 said:

I'm not saying Worthy is great or will be but I think at this point, YES, I would trade him for Coleman

As would every GM, including Beane.

Coleman may turn out to be a very good WR. Worthy has already played a huge role in getting his team to another SB.

[Nephilim17]

7 minutes ago, ghostwriter said:

I wanted to trade up for BTJ. I wanted Worthy if we stayed put. I didn’t want Coleman but I gave him a chance.

Yes, many of us wanted BTJ. None of us are pro scouts but he had the size and speed and (in his 2023 year) the college production.

 

I bet the 2025 3rd rounder we used for Cooper would've gotten us close to where we needed to be for BTJ. Would anyone take Coleman and Cooper (given his age and salary) over 5 years of BTJ? 

Why are fans drinking beer making better picks than pro scouts and a GM?