Jump to content

2 Number 1's for an elite pass rusher?  

126 members have voted

  1. 1. 2 Number 1's for an elite pass rusher?

    • Yes
      21
    • No
      105


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

I would do it in a heartbeat…Ed Oliver is not the answer, while Jones is a HOFer…👍

 

Plus, you kill 2 birds with one stone by weakening the Chiefs and making Mahomes life a living hell…

 

 

 

 

Edited by JaCrispy
  • Like (+1) 1
Posted
6 hours ago, Mr. WEO said:

yeah, otherwise identical

 

lol


Obviously Reid >> McDermott, but player wise, Chris Jones is the difference. 
 

It’s as easy to point out as he’s the reason why instead of being up 4 over KC at home with 2 minutes left, we had to trot out Bass for an ill-fated attempt to tie. 
 

He makes clutch plays like that over and over when it matters. 

Posted
46 minutes ago, JaCrispy said:

I would do it in a heartbeat…Ed Oliver is not the answer, while Jones is a HOFer…👍

 

Plus, you kill 2 birds with one stone by weakening the Chiefs and making Mahomes life a living hell…

 

 

 

 

I like Ed but I agree he's not the answer, we need more BEEF up the middle.  Players like Chris Jones don't grow on trees I get that but what's infuriating is a guy

like Travis Jones on the Ravens would have been perfect and he was a 3rd round pick.  I was really hoping that was a guy we were going to snag in that draft and it drives me crazy every time I watch a Ravens game especially when it was against us.

  • Like (+1) 2
Posted
9 hours ago, stlbills13 said:

Well I believe we would have beaten the Chiefs last year if Jones hadn't gotten to Allen on that late play. But I also believe we would have beaten the Chiefs in the 13 seconds game if we had better coaching. This year something else stupid will probably happen.


People tend to over exaggerate.

 

The Bills in 2 of the last 3 years were arguably 1 play away each year from beating the Chiefs and being the SuperBowl favorites.

 

The Chiefs were barely the better team.   
 

The difference for me is that in those critical moments either the coaching wasn’t up to par and play makers such as Chris Jones made an all world  play to disrupt an eventual TD whereas our players like Diggs doesn’t come up with a play and Bass misses a FG he should make.

 

We weren’t that far off and even in a mini rebuild year like this we are right there.

 

 

  • Agree 1
Posted

The bills don’t have a Chris jones so no argument there.  However the difference is more confidence that they can always win and  game management in tight situations.  The chiefs are cocky in close games and expect to make plays to win.  The bills all wait for someone else to step up and make a play. Allen has it but on defense it does not really exist.  I’m talking when you play the chiefs type situations.  Not the jets.  
 

And they have Butger.  The lumber if games this team has lost to 57 plus you’re fgs compared to how many they have snatched that way (zero) is a big difference. 

13 hours ago, frostbitmic said:

If we had Jones or someone like him he'd only be on the field about 60% of the plays anyways and then he'd get hurt.

It’s not injuries

Posted
11 hours ago, SCBills said:


Obviously Reid >> McDermott, but player wise, Chris Jones is the difference. 
 

It’s as easy to point out as he’s the reason why instead of being up 4 over KC at home with 2 minutes left, we had to trot out Bass for an ill-fated attempt to tie. 
 

He makes clutch plays like that over and over when it matters. 

 

well, their TE situation has been light years better than the Bills for years. 

Posted

So far I see ...

 

1.  Andy Reid > McD

2. Patrick Mahomes - Best QB / Offensive player

3. Chris Jones - Best Defensive player in the game

4. Travis Kelce - Best TE in the game

5. Reliable Kicker

 

We're very close at QB

Posted
21 hours ago, DabillsDaBillsDaBills said:

We need to draft a player like Chris Jones. Not trade multiple firsts or sign him as a 34 year old FA

 

Agreed that would be nice...but not too easy to find a Chris Jones when you draft late.  Sure it happens, but it is a lot harder to find them.

Posted
22 hours ago, Blackbeard said:

You swing for the fences when you have a team just one player away.  

 

Here i don't think just one player does it.  The Von year, yes.

 

We're rebuilding a tad.   I'd swing for the fences in a year we really think we can win a SB.

 

Well if we swing for Crosby or Garrett I am pretty sure it would be so whoever they got stayed a while too...so that swing for the fence move would be about more than just 1 season, it would be a big move moving forward too.

 

I would go get either of those guys myself, they are difference making players.  Rams won the SB because the D ended the game and Bengals were only it because their D shut down Mahomes the 2nd half of the AFCCG.  Chiefs won the SB last year because Jones blew a play up that Aiyuk was uncovered in the endzone, a game they were only in because Chris Jones blew up Dion against us on a would go ahead TD to Shakir.  

 

The fundamental lack of understanding on this board for just how important play makers are on Defense when you get into the playoffs and Super Bowl is wild.  If you could draft Crosby or Garrett with our first round pick next year, 100% of all teams would make that selection.  So all you are doing is paying an extra first to insure that the first round pick produces an elite player...considering 50% of first rounders bust anyways, that is an equal trade off.  2 firsts for a top of the league defensive difference maker. 

 

Its a no brainer if it can be done, especially considering our first are going to be almost 2nd's anyway.  

  • Agree 1
Posted
19 minutes ago, Alphadawg7 said:

 

Agreed that would be nice...but not too easy to find a Chris Jones when you draft late.  Sure it happens, but it is a lot harder to find them.


He was drafted in the 2nd round. Kelce in the 3rd. Mahomes was available when we drafted. Butker was signed off of Carolina’s ps. Identifying great talent is the issue not draft position. 

Posted (edited)

I don't think the Browns would trade Garrett . Sure he's worthless to their team this year but going forward I doubt they want to give up one of the best defensive players in the league .

 

On that note, i've always been curious if teams could make a trade where they agree to trade back. 

 

So for example :

 

Since Cleveland has no use for him this year, they agree to trade him to the Bills only for the remainder of the 2024 season, after which he goes back to Cleveland. Is that type of trade ever been made or even possible ? 

Edited by TrentEdwardsCheckDownOn4th
Posted

It for sure was in January.

 

Generally, I'd probably agree also - we have some nice pieces on defense, but no one who consistently disrupts the way Jones can.

 

Posted
17 hours ago, Billl said:

The best version of the modern era Bills was the 2022 squad prior to Von Miller’s injury.  They were the best team in the league with a gap between them and anyone else.  They had absolute studs in Allen, Von, Diggs, and White.  That team could just line up and kick your ass, not because they had no weaknesses but because their elite talent could simply take over games.

 

There were two conclusions that could have been drawn from that season.  One was that the team should try to load up on superstars.  The other was that the team shouldn’t have put so many eggs into so few baskets.  Beane chose the latter.  Now Josh is the only truly elite player on the roster, and they’re back to their old ways of beating lesser teams to a pulp while struggling against legit contenders.

 

Keon Coleman is a perfectly good player, and he’s going to have a 10 year NFL career.  If there’s some trait that he posseses that says he’s going to develop into a superstar, I’m missing it.  Xavier Worthy is a twig.  It is entirely possible that he won’t hold up physically in the league.  But unless and until that happens, he is absolutely electric, and every single Defensive Coordinator is forced to adjust his game plan to account for the possibility that he could score from anywhere on the field at any given time.  

 

Brandon Beane passed on Worthy for Coleman because he was more worried about recouping the third round pick he traded away mid-season for a 30 year old CB (despite drafting a CB in the first round in 2022) than he was with finding a superstar in the first round.  Now he’s traded a third round pick for a 30 year old WR (despite drafting a WR with his first pick in 2024).

 

There is an alternate universe in which people talk about the 2022 Bills championship season saying that Von was unblockble, Tre was lockdown, and the Allen to Diggs combination was unstoppable.  I simply can’t envision anyone ever looking back at the 2024 postseason saying that Keon Coleman and Amari Cooper were unguardable or that Rasul Douglas erased every elite WR he lined up against. This team is built to win the AFC East.  It’s not built to win four straight games against the Texans, Ravens, Chiefs, and 49ers.  The difference between the Bills and the Chiefs is Chris Jones…and Travis Kelce, and Trent McDuffie, and Rashee Rice and maybe Xavier Worthy.  The Amaris and Jujus and Rasul Douglases and Kareem Hunts are important, but you can’t give up big time draft assets to backfill your roster.

 

I doubt we were ever considering Worthy.  

 

By season's end (and with Cooper's addition), we'll get more out of Coleman than we would have w/ a speedster like Worthy.  And I think Worthy is better for the Chiefs.  But he will end up being more one-dimensional/gadgety, and we needed a guy who could potentially blossom into a true #1 or at worst 1b.  

 

With Cooper & the injuries to Rice and Brown, the Bills now have a significantly better WR room than the Chiefs.  They're built to handle the playoffs and all of the teams you mentioned.  I don't know how it will go this year, and Buffalo could certainly bow out by the divisional yet again, but I think it's a pretty middlin' year for the league in general and it's probably our best opportunity yet, if not our best team.

 

We have as much of a chance as the Chiefs this year, imo.  I get that KC is undefeated, but the optics haven't been quite as good as usual, and I don't think that WR corps is going to do it for them in January. They have the "aura" factor which is always an advantage, but the Ravens are a better team than both the Chiefs & Bills, who are relatively equal (and I'd say on the same level as Houston, also).  Most of the playoff games between those teams will probably come down to a play or 2.

 

This topic is OLD. A NEW topic should be started unless there is a very specific reason to revive this one.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...