Bills sign a safety!!!! Mike Edwards a Bill

[gonzo1105]

Just now, nosejob said:

So we differ. He's not or never will be at any time, a starting quality safety in the NFL....so there

Did I say he was starting can you read? I said Edwards and Rapp will be the starters and Lewis and a draft pick will be the backup safeties. Now I know what it feels like to be a talk show host and have to listen to someone who has no clue

[NewEra]

2 hours ago, JakeFrommStateFarm said:

So we went from Poyer and Hyde to Edwards ?

 

What the f&*k is going on here ?

Salary cap

[Whkfc]

1 hour ago, Rico said:

If he keeps Cooper Dejean off this team, I approve.

What you don't like about Coop?

[90sBills]

58 minutes ago, loveorhatembillsfan4life said:

Well I can’t say I know too  much about Edwards but he does know Mahomes and maybe can  bring some insight into the Chiefs that we can exploit.. 

 

I guess Mahomes and Hollywood are already getting acquainted.. I really want to take this team down! 

 

Our franchise qb and the team’s newest wr signing aren’t even in the same state while theirs are already getting down to business.
Gotta respect that championship mentality. Sigh. 

[3rdand12]

1 hour ago, GunnerBill said:

 

We signed Rapp too though. That is what confuses me. I think Edwards is a slight upgrade but neither is a guy I want as my best safety.

You know it aint over yet . Rapp is likely a starter that plays downhill Bills need one who can run smartly with speedy WRs etc

They have a few safety's they can and should move on from

 

 

[Beast]

1 hour ago, GunnerBill said:

 

I had watched plenty of Hyde and some of Poyer. I have watched plenty of Edwards. I was confident about both the first two - I said on here Hyde was "great signing". I am less confident on Edwards. Not that he can't start..... but if he is your best safety you have a problem.

I don’t know, call me an idiot but I’ll take McDermott’s evaluation of those positions and give it a little more credibility than yours.

 

And to think, the off-season has a long ways to go and we also have a thing called the draft ahead of us.

Edited March 21 by Beast

[SoonerBillsFan]

 

 

3 hours ago, Big Blitz said:

 

Yea I'm not getting the hate over this at all.  
 

The FS for a top 3 D in the league.  
 

That's won 2 SBs.  That 

I like the signing, good solid Safety to start alongside Rapp.  I agree draft a guy in the 4th and let him get reps

[Putin]

 🤢 

[buffblue]

35 minutes ago, Beast said:

I don’t know, call me an idiot but I’ll take McDermott’s evaluation of those positions and give it a little more credibility than yours.

 

And to think, the off-season has a long ways to go and we also have a thing called the draft ahead of us.

I'd be lying if I said I felt great about the safety position at this juncture, but McD has earned the benefit of the doubt when it comes to coaching up a secondary. It's also why I don't agree with some prognosticators saying we need to draft a corner just because of cutting Tre. We still have some solid pieces in place to field a good pass defense.

Edited March 21 by buffblue

[Buffalo_Stampede]

1 hour ago, loveorhatembillsfan4life said:

Well I can’t say I know too  much about Edwards but he does know Mahomes and maybe can  bring some insight into the Chiefs that we can exploit.. 

 

I guess Mahomes and Hollywood are already getting acquainted.. I really want to take this team down! 

 

Why don’t I see our QB with Curtis Samuel yet?

[Big Blitz]

Chiefs fans replies says a lot about him 

 

 

[Success]

Just now, Big Blitz said:

Chiefs fans replies says a lot about him 

 

 

 

First thing I do when we sign someone is check his previous team's boards (as I'm sure many fans do).

 

They really liked this guy.  Nothing over the top, but it sounds like he's a gamer who will fit in well here.

 

[HappyDays]

7 hours ago, GunnerBill said:

Great. Now we have three backup safeties. When do we get a starter?

 

I think we'll be okay. It's just the safety position. I know we were spoiled for years by Hyde and Poyer but most defenses these days get by with mediocre safeties. Edwards was basically a starter for a championship defense last season.

 

I would rather have Edwards and Rapp at safety than say Simmons and Poyer for example. The latter pair is obviously much more talented but redistributing resources spent on the roster to more important positions is a still a more valuable outcome IMO.

 

Last year I was certain that we didn't have even a replacement level MLB on the roster and it turned out fine. This will turn out fine too, I think. As long as Beane doesn't use it as an excuse to reach for a safety in round 1 or 2.

 

Edited March 21 by HappyDays

[Warriorspikes51]

4 minutes ago, HappyDays said:

 

I think we'll be okay. It's just the safety position. I know we were spoiled for years by Hyde and Poyer but most defenses these days get by with mediocre safeties. Edwards was basically a starter for a championship defense last season.

 

I would rather have Edwards and Rapp at safety than say Simmons and Poyer for example. The latter pair is obviously much more talented but redistributing resources spent on the roster to more important positions is a still a more valuable outcome IMO.

 

Last year I was certain that we didn't have even a replacement level MLB on the roster and it turned out fine. This will turn out fine too, I think. As long as Beane doesn't use it as an excuse to reach for a safety in round 1 or 2.

 

Edwards is a solid all around player with a nose for the ball and the endzone.  Being on 2 different Championship teams should bring quality perspective to our defense as well.

 

Have you heard anything on Blackmon? 

[billsfan89]

1 minute ago, Success said:

 

First thing I do when we sign someone is check his previous team's boards (as I'm sure many fans do).

 

They really liked this guy.  Nothing over the top, but it sounds like he's a gamer who will fit in well here.

 

Sounds like he makes the plays he is “supposed” to make. The knock on him is that he’s just an average athlete so he doesn’t have dynamic range and he misses tackles a lot.

 

The positives are that he is very smart and almost always puts himself in a good position to make a play. He’s also not a bad athlete so he’s not bad range wise either.

 

I don’t think Po and Hyde were considered all that great athletes so I think the fit here makes sense. I am much higher on this signing than I was earlier in the day. 
 

I am still concerned with Rapp as a starter. Probably going to draft a safety to compete with Rapp but the Edwards signing is a nice one year “stop gap” solution 

[Florida Bills Fanatic]

6 hours ago, GunnerBill said:

 

I think Edwards is a starter based on our current roster. But he is a low end starter. I am worried about the safety position.

 

Thinking back, I felt the same way when Hyde and Poyer showed up.  Neither had really given an indication of how good they would become.  McD needs to work his magic. I do hope the Bills draft someone that can play sooner rather than later.  Having to play Lewis and Hamlin would be a nightmare scenario. 

[billsfan89]

6 minutes ago, HappyDays said:

 

I think we'll be okay. It's just the safety position. I know we were spoiled for years by Hyde and Poyer but most defenses these days get by with mediocre safeties. Edwards was basically a starter for a championship defense last season.

 

I would rather have Edwards and Rapp at safety than say Simmons and Poyer for example. The latter pair is obviously much more talented but redistributing resources spent on the roster to more important positions is a still a more valuable outcome IMO.

 

Last year I was certain that we didn't have even a replacement level MLB on the roster and it turned out fine. This will turn out fine too, I think. As long as Beane doesn't use it as an excuse to reach for a safety in round 1 or 2.

 

The Bills fielded a very good defense (for the most part when they were reasonably healthy) last season despite Hyde and Po being past their primes. 
 

Don’t get me wrong Hyde and Po were still effective starting caliber safeties but they weren’t as dominant as they were from 2017-2021 when they were a top tandem in the league. 
 

So it isn’t like the team is going from elite safety play to what may be an average to below average tandem. I still hope they can bring in a mid round safety to take a spot from Rapp who is better as a “Big Nickel” and a backup than as a day one starter.

[billsfan89]

1 minute ago, Florida Bills Fanatic said:

Thinking back, I felt the same way when Hyde and Poyer showed up.  Neither had really given an indication of how good they would become.  McD needs to work his magic. I do hope the Bills draft someone that can play sooner rather than later.  Having to play Lewis and Hamlin would be a nightmare scenario. 

I loved the Hyde signing. He was so highly regarded by Green Bay fans. He played all over the secondary and had 33 starts under his belt. He was a fairly big signing at 5 years 30 million with 14 million guaranteed. It was one of the highest safety contracts that off season. I think if you check the board many fans were very high on that signing. It wasn’t a stretch that Hyde would be a top 5-10 safety.

 

Po on the other hand was a complete unknown. The Bills seemingly gave a safety with 8 starts over 4 years and a player coming off an injury a 4 year deal with a modest guarantee. I didn’t understand that signing at all. It seemed like the Bills overpaid for a player that could have been had on a one year cheap deal.

 

No one or almost no one though Po would be an All Pro caliber safety 

[Desert Bills Fan]

I like these solid signings. Not superstars but solid.

it gives me hope the Bills will move up and draft Brian Thomas WR in round 1.

[Warriorspikes51]

 

going through the responses, overwhelming amount of KC fans upset to see him leave and sign here

Edited March 21 by Warriorspikes51