Bills need a hardnosed, blunt QB coach

[CincyBillsFan]

11 hours ago, Lieutenant Aldo Raine said:

 

Haters gonna hate; do you ever see any positive posts from these same people or ever see them show up after a win?  Yeah, me either. 

They usually vanish for a couple of days before starting back up.

 

2 hours ago, Back2Buff said:

 

We don't even play the playoff games if the defense doesn't get this team into the playoffs.

 

We have the number one seed and week 18 "bye" if Allen doesn't throw 3 picks vs Jets, 2 vs Den, and doesn't throw a pick on first play of game vs NE.  How healthy would we have been if guys didn't have to play for 2 weeks?

We are also likely the 1st seed if the defense can hold the lead that Allen gave them in 3 games with under 2 minutes to play.

 

 

[Mister Defense]

On 1/29/2024 at 7:47 AM, Back2Buff said:

With the Bills not learning and just giving Josh what he wants in the OC coach again, they need to find a QB coach that is going to get into Josh's brain.  A guy that has been around for a while, and isn't looking to baby Allen.

 

One guy I'm wondering if he will do it as a "favor", is Frank Reich.  He obviously doesn't need a job, but wondering if he would come back here to try and get us over the hump.

 

These last two hires at QB coach, Dorsey and Brady, have been young guys that were looking to eventually be head coaches.  We don't need to go in that direction again.

 

Even with his very good first half of year, and likely even better year next year, I doubt Brady would be ready to be a head coach after next season.

 

Maybe after a few superb years, but for now he is the best guy for the job.

 

Dorsey as a head coach!! Almost surreal that he would think this, but almost no chance of that now, unless it is a middle school or pee wee team in desperate need. I think he would be a great Gatorade boy, however, the kind of non thinking, menial task he could excel at.  With a lot of practice and significant monitoring and assistance.

 

 

 

Edited January 30 by Mister Defense

[MrEpsYtown]

On 1/29/2024 at 8:35 AM, MrEpsYtown said:

Just hire Pete Carmichael Jr. He was really good for the Saints for many years and he's a super experienced sounding board for Joe Brady who has extensive knowledge of the system. He would be a great extra pair of eyes for Brady and Carmichael was with Drew Brees for a long time back to their San Diego days, so I have to give him some credit for what Brees did in NO.  I think an experienced coach is what he needs. He's been coached by kids ever since Daboll left. 

 

Sean Ryan was the QB coach in Carolina and worked for Bill O'Brien, Tom Coughlin etc. I don't know about his style, but he is also an experienced name out there. 

 

Former Eagles OC, Brian Johnson would be a nice get if he doesn't get a job as an OC somewhere. 

 

Outside the box thinking, Todd Haley is known to be pretty abrasive, is an E-P coach, and could do good things for Josh, or he could ruin him. 

 

I could also see Thad Lewis coming over if the Bucs bypass him for the OC position. He is a young guy, so I am not sure that is ideal. 

 

 

So Carmichael to the Broncos. I still think Sean Ryan makes a lot of sense. He is freely available working for a college I believe. 

[90sBills]

On 1/29/2024 at 9:11 AM, Bob Jones said:

Sounds like you're saying that JA has no room for improvement. I totally disagree with the latter. 

 

He definitely could use help with how to read what defenses are doing, and also with his decision-making (regarding where to throw the ball). Plenty of All-22 film from plenty of games this past season make the latter fairly obvious.

This part of the game is what’s holding him back. He has all the physical tools. It’s the processing part that separates the best of the best. I hope he devotes time to improve this aspect in the offseason. 

[90sBills]

On 1/29/2024 at 9:17 AM, BullBuchanan said:

How many more weapons does he need? He had Diggs, Shakir, Kincaid, Cook, and even Knox. Who did Mahomes have besides Kelce?

There aren't many teams that have more passing weapons than us.

It’s funny that most people on here believes that Allen is better than Mahomes. Then turn around and demand that Allen needs all pro pass catchers everywhere to help him win. 
 

All the while Mahomes is leading his team to yet another Superbowl with a rag tag receiving group. I get being homers but sometimes it’s just too much. 

[Back2Buff]

6 hours ago, Bruffalo said:

 

We have the 1 seed if McDermott didn't let the Eagles, NE, and Denver walk down and score after Josh gives the go ahead TD.

 

Blaming the QB when he's consistently the best player on the field is convenient and lazy.

 

 

How did we take the lead in NE, maybe a Poyer fumble?!?!  The offense got the ball first in OT and what happened?  The Bills offense had EIGHT possessions where they got ZERO points vs Den.  Ya, lets blame the defense.

 

 

Edited January 30 by Back2Buff

[Bruffalo]

7 minutes ago, Back2Buff said:

 

How did we take the lead in NE, maybe a Poyer fumble?!?!  The offense got the ball first in OT and what happened?  The Bills offense had EIGHT possessions where they got ZERO points vs Den.  Ya, lets blame the defense.

 

 

3 times the defense had less than 2 minutes on the clock left with the lead and they blew it.  Yes, let's blame the defense.

I'm not willing to put anymore of the team on Allen then what's already on his shoulders.  The guy is the Bills, and jabronis like this want to run him out of town because he was just SUPER ALLEN and not SUPER SUPER ALLEN that last possession.

 

I wish I could live in a world so black and white. If the most scoring TD QB in the damn league isn't "doing enough" then maybe we should look around at the other 21 guys on the field.

 

It must be easy to have such a binary vision of sports. 

[Rocky Landing]

Yes, I've been thinking that the quarterback is the problem on this team...

[oldmanfan]

If Brady wanted to be coached hard it ‘s OK

for Josh to have the same.

[CincyBillsFan]

3 hours ago, 90sBills said:

It’s funny that most people on here believes that Allen is better than Mahomes. Then turn around and demand that Allen needs all pro pass catchers everywhere to help him win. 
 

All the while Mahomes is leading his team to yet another Superbowl with a rag tag receiving group. I get being homers but sometimes it’s just too much. 

You misrepresent what is being said.  First off this is the first season in which it could be said that Allen's package of skill players was on par with the Chiefs.  Over the previous 5 seasons there was no comparison as Mahomes enjoyed a huge advantage in the complimentary talent surrounding him.

 

But even this year Mahomes had a great defense that has actually played better in the playoffs then the regular season.  Allen has never enjoyed the luxury of having a defense that wasn't anything but terrible in the playoffs.

 

Mahomes has Reid.

 

And the difference between the Chiefs and Bills this season was a FG.  They finished with the same record and Buffalo gave KC it's toughest game in the AFC playoffs.

 

I think that Mahomes is the number one QB in the NFL because he is the most accomplished QB playing today.  I think it's fair to say that Allen, because of his unique physical gifts, may be as good or better then Mahomes but until he can win a couple of Super Bowl titles Mahomes will always be considered the "better" QB.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[90sBills]

25 minutes ago, CincyBillsFan said:

You misrepresent what is being said.  First off this is the first season in which it could be said that Allen's package of skill players was on par with the Chiefs.  Over the previous 5 seasons there was no comparison as Mahomes enjoyed a huge advantage in the complimentary talent surrounding him.

 

But even this year Mahomes had a great defense that has actually played better in the playoffs then the regular season.  Allen has never enjoyed the luxury of having a defense that wasn't anything but terrible in the playoffs.

 

Mahomes has Reid.

 

And the difference between the Chiefs and Bills this season was a FG.  They finished with the same record and Buffalo gave KC it's toughest game in the AFC playoffs.

 

I think that Mahomes is the number one QB in the NFL because he is the most accomplished QB playing today.  I think it's fair to say that Allen, because of his unique physical gifts, may be as good or better then Mahomes but until he can win a couple of Super Bowl titles Mahomes will always be considered the "better" QB.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

KC’s receivers were not great last year either and they won it all. I disagree that the difference between Buffalo and KC this year is a fg. The difference between the two is one team playing in the Superbowl and the other team that cannot win when it really counts. It isn’t limited to just this year either. 
 

As for Allen. He has all the physical tools. Even though Mahomes can make all the throws I think Allen has the bigger arm. Where he trails Mahomes is the mental side of the game. This is something that Allen can and should improve if he wants to continue to be in the conversation as one of the top QBs in the league.

 

 

[CincyBillsFan]

27 minutes ago, 90sBills said:

KC’s receivers were not great last year either and they won it all. I disagree that the difference between Buffalo and KC this year is a fg. The difference between the two is one team playing in the Superbowl and the other team that cannot win when it really counts. It isn’t limited to just this year either. 
 

As for Allen. He has all the physical tools. Even though Mahomes can make all the throws I think Allen has the bigger arm. Where he trails Mahomes is the mental side of the game. This is something that Allen can and should improve if he wants to continue to be in the conversation as one of the top QBs in the league.

 

 

KC had much better skill players in 2019, 2020 & 2021.  They had a much better offensive line in 2022. 

 

As for Mahomes being ahead of Allen in the "mental" aspects of football I agree and would point a finger at Reid as the reason.  On his best day DaBoll was only a fraction as smart an offensive guy as Reid.

 

 

[Scott7975]

21 hours ago, GunnerBill said:

 

MVS did, sure. And I'd take MVS over Sherfield and Harty obviously. But he isn't the Sherfield and Harty equivalent he is the Gabe Davis equivalent.

 

Their depth receivers have been no shows. Skyy Moore has yet to touch the ball. Mercole Hardman had a fumble that if the Bills had executed at the end would have cost them the game and Toney's contribution these playoffs has been to rant his way out of the NFL on twitter. 

 

Thats true but even when Gabe was on the field, Shefield was getting on a lot too. Sherfield was almost 34% on the year. Harty was only like 13% though. 

 

We can say our weapons are better but they were not playing like it.  This team needs an elite outside receiver. 

[GunnerBill]

3 hours ago, Scott7975 said:

 

Thats true but even when Gabe was on the field, Shefield was getting on a lot too. Sherfield was almost 34% on the year. Harty was only like 13% though. 

 

We can say our weapons are better but they were not playing like it.  This team needs an elite outside receiver. 

 

No question this team needs better weapons. No question at all. But so do the Chiefs. Their receivers (I stress receivers not pass catchers, excluding Kelce) were bottom 3 in the NFL this year.

[Ridgewaycynic2013]

Gettleman's semi retired, isn't he?  He could do a fine job belittling the QBs, and keep an eye on players visiting the training table snack bar too much.

 

[GunnerBill]

17 hours ago, MrEpsYtown said:

 

So Carmichael to the Broncos. I still think Sean Ryan makes a lot of sense. He is freely available working for a college I believe. 

 

In the least shocking development of the year....

[RyanC883]

On 1/30/2024 at 12:48 PM, 90sBills said:

This part of the game is what’s holding him back. He has all the physical tools. It’s the processing part that separates the best of the best. I hope he devotes time to improve this aspect in the offseason. 

 

yeah, agreed.  And he needs a top QB coach to develop that.   Or like hire Romo as a film watching consultant.  

[GETTOTHE50]

This dude could further help Josh’s mechanics. Worth a shot imho

 

 

[zow2]

19 hours ago, CincyBillsFan said:

KC had much better skill players in 2019, 2020 & 2021.  They had a much better offensive line in 2022. 

 

As for Mahomes being ahead of Allen in the "mental" aspects of football I agree and would point a finger at Reid as the reason.  On his best day DaBoll was only a fraction as smart an offensive guy as Reid.

 

 

 

I agree that Mahomes is ahead but i think it's much more than Reid.  He makes these little decisions during a play that other QBs just screw up or panic about.  

For example, against the Ravens it was a 3rd down around midfield still early in the game.  The edge rusher was right in Mahomes' face so fast on a screen pass.  Most QBs would have thrown it right into the defender for a deflected incompletion or taken a sack. Mahomes calmly lobbed it very high over the edge rusher's arms with nice little touch right to his RB in stride for a conversion and nice gain.  Very underrated stuff like that and it's all Mahomes on instinct,

[CincyBillsFan]

40 minutes ago, zow2 said:

 

I agree that Mahomes is ahead but i think it's much more than Reid.  He makes these little decisions during a play that other QBs just screw up or panic about.  

For example, against the Ravens it was a 3rd down around midfield still early in the game.  The edge rusher was right in Mahomes' face so fast on a screen pass.  Most QBs would have thrown it right into the defender for a deflected incompletion or taken a sack. Mahomes calmly lobbed it very high over the edge rusher's arms with nice little touch right to his RB in stride for a conversion and nice gain.  Very underrated stuff like that and it's all Mahomes on instinct,

Again though Mahomes benefited from a shut down defense in the Ravens game.  After going up 17 - 7 how many times did the Chiefs drive the ball?  Mahomes enjoyed a luxury that Allen has rarely enjoyed in the playoffs:  the ability to repeatedly not score points on offense with the expectation that the opponent wouldn't be able to score either.