78thealltimegreat Posted January 25 Posted January 25 There isn’t a right or wrong answer just was curious as the top 4 seems pretty set in stone Patrick Josh Lamar Joey B after that you can throw names in a hat Id go Matt Stafford Dak Prescott Justin Herbert Jalen Hurts Aaron Rogers 1 Quote
MrEpsYtown Posted January 25 Posted January 25 I think its tiers… Josh Lamar Mahomes and Burrow are their own tier imo. Then it’s Herbert (he’s close to those guys and will get there with Harbaugh) Then its guys like Hurts, Stafford, Dak…Goff had a great year. Then young guys who are on their way, Lawrence, Stroud, Love Then its mid Tua, Purdy, Baker Mayfield… And old guys who were elite Rodgers, Wilson. And old guys who were meh Carr, Cousins etc. All my opinions. 7 1 Quote
Ya Digg? Posted January 25 Posted January 25 So it’s not that I don’t see it at times with the eye test, but I continue to question why Herbert gets ranked so highly and how he continues to evade criticism. Made it to the playoffs once, where they choked away a huge lead. Has come into the past 3 seasons with very high expectations and hasn’t delivered. Sure his team has dealt with injuries but what team (outside of KC) hasn’t? It seems people continue to judge other QBs on production while he still gets judged on potential. Would he be in my top 10 yes, but for me he’s closer to 10 than to 5 5 2 1 Quote
LABILLBACKER Posted January 25 Posted January 25 There's just 4 qbs worth getting excited about. 1. Mahomes 2. Allen 3. Lamar 4. Burrow ....Prescott, Herbert & Hurts have under performed. Aaron has one foot in retirement. And Stafford is not too far behind. Guys like Purdy or Tua are very good game managers but incapable of taking over a game. Stroud is the most promising rookie. 4 1 Quote
MrEpsYtown Posted January 25 Posted January 25 1 minute ago, Ya Digg? said: So it’s not that I don’t see it at times with the eye test, but I continue to question why Herbert gets ranked so highly and how he continues to evade criticism. Made it to the playoffs once, where they choked away a huge lead. Has come into the past 3 seasons with very high expectations and hasn’t delivered. Sure his team has dealt with injuries but what team (outside of KC) hasn’t? It seems people continue to judge other QBs on production while he still gets judged on potential. Would he be in my top 10 yes, but for me he’s closer to 10 than to 5 I think it is a fair question, I think it’s obvious his talent is off the charts, he just played for a complete idiot loser coach. I’m based because I have always loved his game. He can do everything those other guys can do. His 2021 season is pretty much what earned him that extension. 1 Quote
D. L. Hot-Flamethrower Posted January 25 Posted January 25 11 minutes ago, MrEpsYtown said: I think its tiers… Josh Lamar Mahomes and Burrow are their own tier imo. Then it’s Herbert (he’s close to those guys and will get there with Harbaugh) Then its guys like Hurts, Stafford, Dak…Goff had a great year. Then young guys who are on their way, Lawrence, Stroud, Love Then its mid Tua, Purdy, Baker Mayfield… And old guys who were elite Rodgers, Wilson. And old guys who were meh Carr, Cousins etc. All my opinions. That's a previous great list! Except Josh should have his own tier!😀 4 Quote
MrEpsYtown Posted January 25 Posted January 25 1 minute ago, D. L. Hot-Flamethrower said: That's a previous great list! Except Josh should have his own tier!😀 Agreed! I did not want to be too much of a homer! 1 Quote
chongli Posted January 25 Posted January 25 1. Mahomes 2. Jackson 3. Burrow 4. Allen 5. Rodgers 6. Herbert 7. Hurts 8. Stroud 9. Love 10. (tie) Prescott, Lawrence, Stafford 5 1 1 1 1 Quote
NeverOutNick Posted January 25 Posted January 25 4 minutes ago, 78thealltimegreat said: There isn’t a right or wrong answer just was curious as the top 4 seems pretty set in stone Patrick Josh Lamar Joey B after that you can throw names in a hat Id go Matt Stafford Dak Prescott Justin Herbert Jalen Hurts Aaron Rogers If I’m talking just QB not the team or coach and a guy would start a franchise with today, this would be my list: Tier 1 dealers choice all time greats 1a. Josh Allen 1b. Joe Burrow 1c. Patrick Mahomes Tier 2 - your going to the playoffs almost every year 4. CJ Stroud 5. Lamar Jackson Tier 3 - unlimited potential but still make so many mistakes 6. Justin Herbert 7. Trevor Lawrence Tier 4 - you can win with a good team around these guys 8. Jared Goff 9. Jalen Hurts 10. Dak Prescott Matthew Stafford and Aaron Rodgers are top 5 guys but they’re old and injury prone now. They don’t make the list of starting a franchise Jordan Love I need to see a full season. Great end of year but is it Lafleur scheming wide open targets? Guys like Purdy and Tua are great effecient quick thinking QBs but where is my franchise going to be? Do I want them out in the elements in Chicago or Buffalo Also, I’m not going to lie, I did consider Baker Mayfield in the top 10. He just has to show he can do what he did this year again since his first few years were not the best 3 Quote
Simon Posted January 25 Posted January 25 In alphabetical order: 1- Josh Allen 1- Patrick Mahomes 2 - Everybody else 2 1 3 Quote
Bills Bud Posted January 25 Posted January 25 1. Josh Allen 2. Joe Burrow 3. Lamar Jackson 4. Patrick Mahomes 5. Aaron Rodgers 6. Justin Herbert 7. Trevor Lawrence 8. Matthew Stafford 9. Jared Goff 10. Brock Purdy 3 Quote
Chaos Posted January 25 Posted January 25 Allen Mahomes Jackson Stroud Purdy Burrow (would be higher if he was not a part time player) A bunch of decent guys A few bums. Overall QB play is at pretty high level in NFL currently. 2 Quote
JimBob2232 Posted January 25 Posted January 25 Mahomes is great....I'd love to see what he does without Mr. Swift though 1 Quote
Chicken Boo Posted January 25 Posted January 25 No order Mahomes Jackson Allen Burrow Goff Purdy Murray Stroud Hurts Cousins Quote
Amaru523 Posted January 25 Posted January 25 1. Josh 2. Mahomes 3. Lamar 4. Burrow After that I have no idea. Lawrence, Stafford, Goff, Hurts, Dak, Herbert, Rodgers, could all be any number 5-10. I need to see a little more of Stroud before I put him in the top 10. I personally think Purdy excells because of the team he's on. Tua, I have him 15th. Quote
T.E. Posted January 25 Posted January 25 Anyone who has Jackson over either Burrow or Allen has just bought into media narratives. Not a single GM on earth, including Baltimore's, is taking Lamar over either of those guys. 1 7 2 Quote
Big Blitz Posted January 25 Posted January 25 All of America stops what it’s doing when Josh Allen is in on TV. I can testify to this living outside NY and what other fans say. Allen and Mahomes are in a tier of their own - but I’ll put Lamar here with them. Tier 1 - All they do is win and they are must see TV: 1. Allen 2. Mahomes 3. Jackson Tier 2 - I will start a franchise with them 3. Stroud 4. Herbert - but no playoff wins - the Dan Marino of this era so far; more talented teams than the Bills should make us appreciate McD more. Harbaugh to the rescue. Tier 3 - I think they’re here bc of surrounding talent tier: 5. Burrow - nice to have 2 of the 10 best WRs in the game and a top 10 RB. And a great 3rd WR. Seems to be piling up injuries. Feels like he’s deliberately cocky to make him seem better than he is. He’s this next guy: 6. Purdy - it’s like Burrow. There is no difference to me. They’re the same QB. 7. Hurts - everything went right in 2022 Tier 4: I have questions: 8. Lawrence - how do you lose to the Titans? 9. Love - made the top 10. But, can we see it for a full season 10. Dak - I’m not sure you’re good at throwing outside. The actual Philip Rivers of this era. 2 Quote
SinceThe70s Posted January 25 Posted January 25 26 minutes ago, JimBob2232 said: Mahomes is great....I'd love to see what he does without Mr. Swift though He's already managed pretty well without Tyreek. 1 Quote
DBilz2500 Posted January 25 Posted January 25 1 hour ago, NeverOutNick said: If I’m talking just QB not the team or coach and a guy would start a franchise with today, this would be my list: Tier 1 dealers choice all time greats 1a. Josh Allen 1b. Joe Burrow 1c. Patrick Mahomes Tier 2 - your going to the playoffs almost every year 4. CJ Stroud 5. Lamar Jackson Tier 3 - unlimited potential but still make so many mistakes 6. Justin Herbert 7. Trevor Lawrence Tier 4 - you can win with a good team around these guys 8. Jared Goff 9. Jalen Hurts 10. Dak Prescott Matthew Stafford and Aaron Rodgers are top 5 guys but they’re old and injury prone now. They don’t make the list of starting a franchise Jordan Love I need to see a full season. Great end of year but is it Lafleur scheming wide open targets? Guys like Purdy and Tua are great effecient quick thinking QBs but where is my franchise going to be? Do I want them out in the elements in Chicago or Buffalo Also, I’m not going to lie, I did consider Baker Mayfield in the top 10. He just has to show he can do what he did this year again since his first few years were not the best Couldn’t Allen also fall into your 3rd tier? 🤔 1 Quote
mannc Posted January 25 Posted January 25 I really don’t understand why Trevor Lawrence is showing up on so many peoples’ lists. He’s done nothing to merit top 10 inclusion. Allen Mahomes Burrow Jackson Stafford Stroud Goff Prescott Herbert Love Purdy Tua Hurts Murray Lawrence 1 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.