90sBills Posted January 24 Posted January 24 1 hour ago, chongli said: Lots of great QB's have never won the SB for various reasons. Partly because it's a matter of luck and is a team sport. It's not the end of the world. I think the Bills mafia could get to a healthier place mentally if they stopped focusing on Super Bowls. Focus on being the best team you can be, and not on long-term goals and other teams. Also, where is Dan Fouts on that list? This is a difficult thing to do because most in the fanbase already shoed Allen in for at least 2 titles. It’s hard to accept that he might not even get to one much less win it. 1 Quote
transient Posted January 24 Posted January 24 7 hours ago, pennstate10 said: I actually consider Kelly to be a Super Bowl winning QB. he did exactly what Brady did to win his first Super Bowl. Guided his team to a game winning FG in the last minute of the game. Not his fault that the kicker failed. 33 minutes ago, chongli said: Well, ok, if that's the case, then Buffalo won the SB in 2021. It's not Josh's fault 13-sconds occurred. If we had beaten KC, then most agree Buffalo would have beaten Cincy and then the Rams. See how that works? 36 minutes ago, Success said: Honestly, I'm in the "one before I die" crowd. I'm sure when we win one, I'll want more - but just one will bury all of the demons. Then, it will just be about enjoyment. I'm sure of that. I think Allen gets one in the next few years, and who knows - maybe another when he's in his 30's. And that's fantastic. Brady changed a lot of perspectives on this. All of a sudden, unless you have a dynasty or get a bunch of titles, it's insufficient. But for this fan, 1 is just fine. Well look at that, we've actually won 2 Super Bowls!! @Success, it looks like you can die a happy person! 1 3 Quote
Nextmanup Posted January 24 Posted January 24 The names on your respective lists are a bit suspect. QB and "super bowl wins" don't really go together; it's a team sport. If you don't have the complete picture, you aren't going to be winning multiple Super Bowls. I know the media likes to make this a topic; it's stupid. 1 Quote
Alphadawg7 Posted January 24 Posted January 24 Elway got there and lost multiple times before he got there late and won back to back SB's. Manning was in his 9th year before he won one. And the 2nd one that he "won" was more the Broncos won INSPITE of Manning as he sucked all season (31st ranked QB that year) where he almost didn't get his job back from Brock Osweiler, and then had the worst QB performance for a winning team in SB history. Rodgers, Brees, and Young only reached 1 SB (and won it). Those 5 guys are in everyones top 10 all time list and several on in most peoples top 5 all time list. What pisses me off is that Allen gets crucified for not being Mahomes and having "early" SB visits and wins. But what would their careers look like if they swapped places? Guarantee you Allen has multiple Super Bowls too and Mahomes has none. Another thing that pisses me off...everyone said Allen cant be MVP this year because of turnovers and how he has sooo many. Mahomes had 21 turnovers the year he won MVP (Allen only had 1 more this year with 22) and Mahomes had the best WR in football, the best TE in maybe history, a top OL and one of the best offensive coaches in history when he had 21 turnoers and still won MVP. Alles only crime is that he doesn't play for KC and he gets crucified for it. It is so stupid and it is a shame more people can't appreciate how special he really is and just how much fun he is to watch. 1 Quote
C.Biscuit97 Posted January 24 Posted January 24 9 hours ago, pennstate10 said: I actually consider Kelly to be a Super Bowl winning QB. he did exactly what Brady did to win his first Super Bowl. Guided his team to a game winning FG in the last minute of the game. Not his fault that the kicker failed. Kelly was an awful postseason qb. His ego shirk have had Thurman getting 30 Carries that game and had the giants adjust their defense. Quote
stuvian Posted January 25 Posted January 25 Jim Plunkett won two Superbowls. Elway didn't win until he had Terrell Davis. I like Cook but he's not a gamechanger. Maybe a star RB is what would improve our fortunes the fastest and preserve Josh. Quote
Chicken Boo Posted January 25 Posted January 25 16 hours ago, boyst said: Romo, Allen, Burrow, McNair, and Cunningham were not great QB's. Rivers was not great, either, but threw a ton. I fully understand what you're getting at. Your criteria for "great" is a high bar and there's nothing wrong with that. 1 Quote
GunnerBill Posted January 25 Posted January 25 8 hours ago, Ed_Formerly_of_Roch said: Always have had a hard time calling Kurt Warner a great QB. He had a 12 year career, out of them 6 good years, but of those 6, only 3 the team did well. Other years he barely played half the games, not sure if it was due to injury or benched? Lost his job with the Rams through injury. With the Giants was benched with a winning record to go with Eli. 1 Quote
MJS Posted January 25 Posted January 25 You've come to the realization of something in the future? Something that hasn't happened yet? How? Quote
Awwufelloff Posted January 25 Posted January 25 17 hours ago, Bills!Win! said: This has been on my mind ever since Sunday night and I just have to get it out there. The list of great QBs who never won a Super Bowl. I define “Great” as having consistent success, excelling at the position and not a player who had an up and down career. Jim Kelly Josh Allen Joe Burrow Philip Rivers Tony Romo Dan Marino Donovan McNabb Steve McNair Frank Tarkenton Randall Cunningham Warren Moon Great QBs who only won one superbowl (shows how hard it is) Kurt Warner Steve Young Brett Favre Aaron Rodgers Drew Brees Matt Stafford (Namath, Dawson, Unitas, Stabler, Simms, Doug Williams) - I never really watched film on these guys to see if they were good/great but I can only assume they were. Shows my age QBs who won multiple Superbowls Peyton Manning Patrick Mahomes Troy Aikman Joe Montana Eli Manning Bart Starr Bob Griese Terry Bradshaw Ben Roethlisberger Tom Brady Roger Staubach Which category will Allen fall in? I’ve come to the realization that Allen will not win multiple Superbowls and it won’t be because of Josh Allen but because of the team he plays for. We will never be a dynasty. I say he wins one in 2-3 years from now and that’s it. Matt Ryan was a great QB, nearly had one but coaching prevented that. Quote
reddogblitz Posted January 25 Posted January 25 (edited) Hall of Famers Sonny Jergensen and Fran Terkenton never won SBs either. It takes a lot more than a great QB and a coach that can tie his own shoes to win a SB. Luck and not getting bitten by the injury bug helps too as do calls by the officials. I reject the notion that since we're not advancing to CG must be because some else besides he who shall not be criticized must be at fault. It's a team fail (including he who shall not he criticized). Edited January 25 by reddogblitz Quote
Old Coot Posted January 25 Posted January 25 This stat is a bit misleading for the older QBs who played part of their careers before the Superbowl era. Bart Starr actually won 5 NFL championships: Three before the Superbowl era. Unitas won three NFL championships: two before the Superbowl era 1 1 Quote
longtimebillsfan Posted January 25 Posted January 25 21 hours ago, Bills!Win! said: This has been on my mind ever since Sunday night and I just have to get it out there. The list of great QBs who never won a Super Bowl. I define “Great” as having consistent success, excelling at the position and not a player who had an up and down career. Jim Kelly Josh Allen Joe Burrow Philip Rivers Tony Romo Dan Marino Donovan McNabb Steve McNair Frank Tarkenton Randall Cunningham Warren Moon Great QBs who only won one superbowl (shows how hard it is) Kurt Warner Steve Young Brett Favre Aaron Rodgers Drew Brees Matt Stafford (Namath, Dawson, Unitas, Stabler, Simms, Doug Williams) - I never really watched film on these guys to see if they were good/great but I can only assume they were. Shows my age QBs who won multiple Superbowls Peyton Manning Patrick Mahomes Troy Aikman Joe Montana Eli Manning Bart Starr Bob Griese Terry Bradshaw Ben Roethlisberger Tom Brady Roger Staubach Which category will Allen fall in? I’ve come to the realization that Allen will not win multiple Superbowls and it won’t be because of Josh Allen but because of the team he plays for. We will never be a dynasty. I say he wins one in 2-3 years from now and that’s it. I would be happy with that. I am not greedy. 12 hours ago, Success said: Honestly, I'm in the "one before I die" crowd. I'm sure when we win one, I'll want more - but just one will bury all of the demons. Then, it will just be about enjoyment. I'm sure of that. I think Allen gets one in the next few years, and who knows - maybe another when he's in his 30's. And that's fantastic. Brady changed a lot of perspectives on this. All of a sudden, unless you have a dynasty or get a bunch of titles, it's insufficient. But for this fan, 1 is just fine. I agree with you 100%. 1 Quote
boyst Posted January 25 Posted January 25 6 hours ago, GunnerBill said: Lost his job with the Rams through injury. With the Giants was benched with a winning record to go with Eli. I see this now, missed it. @Ed_Formerly_of_Roch ... I'd say Kurt Warner was one of the smartest QBs to play the last 40 years. In the modern era of QB's he had a processing ability that was beyond all not named Manning. It made him excellent. 2 1 Quote
SirAndrew Posted January 25 Posted January 25 Dan Marino and Josh Allen are the best QB’s on that list who never/haven’t won a Super Bowl. The other guys are a level lower than those two. 1 Quote
ProcessImproverMan Posted January 25 Posted January 25 Terry Bradshaw was not a great QB. Dude got carried by the Steel curtain Steelers defense. Eli Manning wasn't a great QB either. His defense is the big reason why he won his super bowls. Allen and Marino have put up better statistical games in the post season but don't have super bowl wins because their teams were worse at each given time. Judging a QB by super bowl wins is flawed as many bad QBs have been carried to super bowl wins by awesome teams while better QBs have not gotten Super Bowl wins due to weaker teams. Trent Dilfer got a ring with the 2000 Ravens, one of the best defenses ever. I had a Dolphins fan tell me that Allen is a bum because he hasn't gotten a ring yet and I told that idiot that Dilfer must be the goat then and Marino a bum because "no ring " 1 1 Quote
Bills!Win! Posted January 25 Author Posted January 25 11 minutes ago, ProcessImproverMan said: Terry Bradshaw was not a great QB. Dude got carried by the Steel curtain Steelers defense. Eli Manning wasn't a great QB either. His defense is the big reason why he won his super bowls. Allen and Marino have put up better statistical games in the post season but don't have super bowl wins because their teams were worse at each given time. Judging a QB by super bowl wins is flawed as many bad QBs have been carried to super bowl wins by awesome teams while better QBs have not gotten Super Bowl wins due to weaker teams. Trent Dilfer got a ring with the 2000 Ravens, one of the best defenses ever. I had a Dolphins fan tell me that Allen is a bum because he hasn't gotten a ring yet and I told that idiot that Dilfer must be the goat then and Marino a bum because "no ring " Add or remove a few, the list mostly stays the same Quote
SoMAn Posted January 25 Posted January 25 23 hours ago, Bills!Win! said: This has been on my mind ever since Sunday night and I just have to get it out there. The list of great QBs who never won a Super Bowl. I define “Great” as having consistent success, excelling at the position and not a player who had an up and down career. Jim Kelly Josh Allen Joe Burrow Philip Rivers Tony Romo Dan Marino Donovan McNabb Steve McNair Frank Tarkenton Randall Cunningham Warren Moon Great QBs who only won one superbowl (shows how hard it is) Kurt Warner Steve Young Brett Favre Aaron Rodgers Drew Brees Matt Stafford (Namath, Dawson, Unitas, Stabler, Simms, Doug Williams) - I never really watched film on these guys to see if they were good/great but I can only assume they were. Shows my age QBs who won multiple Superbowls Peyton Manning Patrick Mahomes Troy Aikman Joe Montana Eli Manning Bart Starr Bob Griese Terry Bradshaw Ben Roethlisberger Tom Brady Roger Staubach Which category will Allen fall in? I’ve come to the realization that Allen will not win multiple Superbowls and it won’t be because of Josh Allen but because of the team he plays for. We will never be a dynasty. I say he wins one in 2-3 years from now and that’s it. Good fact-based collection of info. There are people here who seem to think that winning Championships is easier than it actually is and are ready to turn their backs on our team/coaches because they've yet to get to the promised land. Here's some other facts to chew on: 4 teams have yet to appear in a Superbowl. 12 teams have never won it. A few teams have won only once (Bears, Eagles, Jets) Other teams haven't won in close to 30 or more years (Cowboys, 49ers, Washington, Dolphins), so for many fans under 40, there's little if any memory of those victories. Add it up. Soak it in. We tend to measure achievement against Brady and the Patriots, or now KC. Those streaks are far more uncommon than common. It's not realistic to expect championships to fall in your lap. It takes consistent play and a little luck. Getting to a Superbowl is very difficult. Winning one is even tougher. The Bills have been competitive for several years under McD. They've had a chance to get there. I expect it will continue. Injuries and other external factors will always play into the results. If the disappointment is too great, you should find some other form of entertainment. For me, there's always another season and hope. 2 Quote
Gregg Posted January 25 Posted January 25 Watch Brock Purdy win a Super Bowl and the "experts" will be saying Purdy is a better QB than Allen. 1 Quote
Bob Jones Posted January 25 Posted January 25 17 hours ago, BillsPride12 said: I like Kelly but that's kind've silly. Wasn't the knock on Kelly he didn't do enough on that last drive to get the Bills closer to Norwood's ideal yard range? 47 yards was no chip shot back in 1991 This is 100% spot on. They let their foot off the gas at the end, and it cost them, big time. And that loss affected me greatly. I was 30, and had a huge SB party in my basement, in Rome, NY, with a lot of my USAF coworkers. I was expecting a win. Nowadays, I guess with age, we all mellow out and realize there are many more important things in life to get upset about. And of course with this current Bills team, I expect nothing! LOL 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.