Laporta versus Kincaid?

[TH3]

2 hours ago, Toledo Bill said:

When not watching the Bills I watch most of the Lions games.

I am curious what people think… who is better?

If I remember correctly, Kincaid was the top rated tight end coming into the draft.

I wonder if Laporta is better suited to be a  tight end in the NFL..

Wait….you can go back and think you could have picked different in the draft? When did this start?

[mannc]

2 hours ago, Toledo Bill said:

When not watching the Bills I watch most of the Lions games.

I am curious what people think… who is better?

If I remember correctly, Kincaid was the top rated tight end coming into the draft.

I wonder if Laporta is better suited to be a  tight end in the NFL..

I love Kincaid but worry about his relatively slender frame.  Seems like he’s just not built to give and take the punishment necessary to play tight end in the NFL. Laporta seems like more of a prototypical TE…

[Goin Breakdown]

1 hour ago, Buffalo03 said:

I didn't insult anyone

It's kinda like when I watch the Bills and my wife says something like "nice your watching the stupid Bills again". She didn't technically say I'm stupid but I know what she's really saying. 

[Buffalo716]

13 minutes ago, mannc said:

I love Kincaid but worry about his relatively slender frame.  Seems like he’s just not built to give and take the punishment necessary to play tight end in the NFL. Laporta seems like more of a prototypical TE…

Kincaid weighed in at the combine 1 lb heavier than Sam

 

It's not like Sam has 20 lb on him

[mannc]

1 minute ago, Buffalo716 said:

Kincaid weighed in at the combine 1 lb heavier than Sam

 

It's not like Sam has 20 lb on him

That’s interesting…Kincaid looks a lot smaller.

[PBF81]

2 hours ago, Buffalo03 said:

There's no question to be had. If you honestly think LaPorta looks just as good in our offense as he does in Detroit, I hate to break it to you, it would make no difference. Kincaid would be the better TE if he was in Detroit 

 

Phrasing your original post a little differently may have been better.  

 

 

 

 

[Buffalo716]

1 minute ago, mannc said:

That’s interesting…Kincaid looks a lot smaller.

Well dalton is 1.5 inches taller so that would mean Sam is stockier 

[John from Riverside]

3 hours ago, Airseven said:

Right. Of course. That empty hypothetical that can’t be debated. 
 

Beane wanted a WR but then had to scramble for Kincaid. It may be that the type of pass-catching TE that Kincaid can become will take longer to develop.

 

 

I’m still glad that we took Dalton
 

But I really hope that our first round pick this next year is a wide receiver

1 hour ago, mannc said:

That’s interesting…Kincaid looks a lot smaller.

Those guys are very seldom at their final statistic. Whenever it comes to this I look for Dalton after a full off-season program to be bigger.

[mannc]

3 minutes ago, John from Riverside said:

I’m still glad that we took Dalton
 

But I really hope that our first round pick this next year is a wide receiver

 

Really wasn't an option this year.  Four WRs came off the board immediately before we took Kincaid... 

[Buffalo03]

1 hour ago, Goin Breakdown said:

It's kinda like when I watch the Bills and my wife says something like "nice your watching the stupid Bills again". She didn't technically say I'm stupid but I know what she's really saying. 

Yeah, she's not calling you stupid. She's saying football is stupid lol

[Buffalo716]

9 minutes ago, John from Riverside said:

I’m still glad that we took Dalton
 

But I really hope that our first round pick this next year is a wide receiver

Those guys are very seldom at their final statistic. Whenever it comes to this I look for Dalton after a full off-season program to be bigger.

Ofc weights fluctuate

 

But Sam isn't gigantic compared to Dalton 

[NewEra]

One is a tight end that is coached and schemed as if he’s an all pro

 

One is a tight end that is coached and schemed like he’s a backup fullback.

[julian]

Last years TE class will go down as one of the best all time IMO. Kincaid will be a star.

[Goin Breakdown]

27 minutes ago, Buffalo03 said:

Yeah, she's not calling you stupid. She's saying football is stupid lol

Well she's dead wrong my guy haha. Go Bills. Have a good Christmas too!!

[Buffalo03]

35 minutes ago, Goin Breakdown said:

Well she's dead wrong my guy haha. Go Bills. Have a good Christmas too!!

She is wrong lol. Merry Christmas 

[DJB]

5 hours ago, That's No Moon said:

LaPorta is a better all around TE, he also plays for a former TE who is committed to using him a lot. Kincaid was and is breasts on a bull when Knox is healthy. That makes LaPorta the better choice for the Lions, but LaPorta would have been a bad choice for the Bills too.

 

YESSSS please 

[That's No Moon]

39 minutes ago, DJB said:

 

YESSSS please 

Board's autofilter does fun things.

[BullBuchanan]

6 hours ago, Toledo Bill said:

When not watching the Bills I watch most of the Lions games.

I am curious what people think… who is better?

If I remember correctly, Kincaid was the top rated tight end coming into the draft.

I wonder if Laporta is better suited to be a  tight end in the NFL..

LaPorta is a monster. He's already an elite top-end TE. Kincaid has shown flashes of being a good player, but they aren't close to the same right now.

Edited December 25, 2023 by BullBuchanan

[Neo]

6 hours ago, Buffalo03 said:

I'll settle this real quickly. Take LaPorta out of the Lions offense and put him in the Bills offense and take Kincaid and put him in the Lions offense, production is flipped. There, now go back to not making stupid posts. It's not Kincaid, it's how they are used

I’m not sure what Toledo Bill did in your Wheaties, so I’ll set that aside.    To your analysis …  isn’t “who you are” the biggest indicator of “how you’re used”?  I’m not sure Toledo’s post was the stupid one.

[The Jokeman]

5 hours ago, Buffalo03 said:

LaPorta is also the main man in Derroit. They allow him to run seam routes and actually use him the way he should be. How did Kincaid look when he was the main man when Knox was out? He looked exactly like he was on LaPorta's level. Now Knox is back and Kincaid is basically taking a back seat again. LaPorta is not necessarily better

Exactly opportunity LaPorta competing against who for falls? St. Brown?