McD on late game decisions - "Hindsight is always 20/20"

[Yobogoya!]

11 minutes ago, Ramza86 said:

Did he really say that? lol

 

He was dumb to throw away a timeout to "ice" the kicker.

 

I wouldnt have played for OT with 20 secs and a timeout....but I get why he did.

 

We should have had 2 timeouts and 20 seconds and he would have gone for the win. 

 

If youre gonna play for OT and take it to OT.....at least dont be that soft on defense....my god. Pathetic mentality. 

 

Even with one TO you've got to at least try one pass there. If you pick up 15-20 yards, you take the timeout and have at least one if not two tries to get another 15-20 where you then spike the ball and try the kick. 

 

Can't agree with that decision. Even if Gabe had ran the correct read in OT and caught the winning touchdown, I'd still say he was wrong to pass up the chance to win with 20 seconds left. 

Edited November 27, 2023 by Yobogoya!

[ALLinALLEN]

I think the real reason he didnt push the 20 seconds there for a FG was because he was terrified of an Allen pick. I think that's a terrible reason NOT to try to win , but it's certainly a reason. 

[Aussie Joe]

Just now, ALLinALLEN said:

I think the real reason he didnt push the 20 seconds there for a FG was because he was terrified of an Allen pick. I think that's a terrible reason NOT to try to win , but it's certainly a reason. 

Bad reason… gunna finally cost him his job 

[CircleTheWagons99]

Hindsight??? we ALL saw that coming once they took a knee......and then again when they didnt go for it on 4th down in OT........McD needs to go.......Out Coached in EVERY BIG GAME he has been in.......

[BRH]

3 minutes ago, Yobogoya! said:

 

Even with one TO you've got to at least try one pass there. If you pick up 15-20 yards, you take the timeout and have at least one if not two tries to get another 15-20 where you then spike the ball and try the kick. 

 

Can't agree with that decision. Even if Gabe had ran the correct read in OT and caught the winning touchdown, I'd still say he was wrong to pass up the chance to win with 20 seconds left. 

Bingo. 
 

You have one of the best quarterbacks in the world at your disposal and the message you’re sending him is “thanks, but my defense has got this.”

 

I’m sure he was thinking about things that could go wrong during those 20 seconds ….strip sack, pick, etc. So instead of winning he coached not to lose.   And then he lost. Again. 
 

We have lost games in the past with Josh having the ball in his hands …Tennessee comes to mind.  But we’ve won more games with him having the ball in his hands at the end than we have relying on the defense to close it out. 
 

McDermott will never change.  And we will never take the next step with him in charge.  It took a long time for me to get to this point.  That’s why I’m so confident in what I just said. 

[YodaMan79]

“Sean, a pattern has emerged the past couple of seasons.  In high pressure situations in the final couple of minutes of the 4th quarter, or OT, when the team has the opportunity to solidify a win,  the team is consistently on the losing end.  With having the luxury of hindsight, and a number game determining scenarios to reflect upon over the past 18 months, what has been an area of growth, or improvement you’ve identified to help rectify this teams shortcomings at the end of 1 score games?”

 

If I was allowed to ask a follow up question. 

 

I’d have all the stats to back up what I’m saying, and wouldn’t let it go until an answer was given on what they were doing to improve. Mistakes happen, we all grow from them.  We all adapt and change professionally, and personally.  How are we getting better at what we do?  Every year I have to change the way I’m doing business to make sure I’m still relevant, and helping ppl solve problems.  What growth have we seen with this team over the past 24 months? 

Edited November 27, 2023 by YodaMan79

[Warcodered]

32 minutes ago, thenorthremembers said:

Why would you dislike McD as a human being?  You literally dont know the guy personally.  

Yeah as a human being generally what we've seen from him which take it for what you will as they're all observations from way outside he seems like a pretty good guy that cares about his players and staff.

 

As a coach, how about some ***** foresight.

[Captain Hindsight]

This is my Moment 

[Yobogoya!]

2 minutes ago, BRH said:

I’m sure he was thinking about things that could go wrong during those 20 seconds ….strip sack, pick, etc. So instead of winning he coached not to lose.   And then he lost. Again. 

 

Yep, exactly. 

 

Thing is, all of those things can happen in overtime as well. If you can't execute and score the needed points, you're losing the game whether there's 20 seconds on the clock or 10 minutes. At some point you've got to man up and play for the win, especially with a top QB. No excuse. 

[SectionC3]

38 minutes ago, thenorthremembers said:

Why would you dislike McD as a human being?  You literally dont know the guy personally.  

Seriously.  He’s super intense and unapproachable in public.  But that doesn’t mean he’s a bad guy at all.  He probably just has everyone up his butt asking him about every blessed thing all the time and he likes to be left alone.  His job performance and his humanity are two completely different things. 

[TheyCallMeAndy]

43 minutes ago, HomeskillitMoorman said:

https://www.nbcsports.com/nfl/profootballtalk/rumor-mill/news/sean-mcdermott-on-questioning-late-game-decisions-hindsight-is-always-20-20

 

This guy does not get it. At all. 

 

No, it's not hindsight. It's being prepared for late game situations. He's not prepared for them after 7 years on the top job and after 22 years of coaching in the NFL. 

 

I have never seen anyone take on less accountability than this clown. Who will the next scapegoat be? 

 

I'm not sure at this point who I dislike more, McD the coach or McD the human being. 

 

 

He doesn’t get it?

 

Fans who think you’ll get anything more than coach talk in press conferences don’t get it. 
 

He owes you and the reporters zero answers. 

[Billsatlastin2018]

 "Hindsight is always 20/20"
 

IF you’re trying to deflect from the reality of being an 84% LOSER in OT! (1 for 6)

 

McClapper has been loooong unmasked. He is one of the worst end of game HCs! Bills fans know given a 50/50 choice on what to do in a critical moment, he will always, always FUBAR it.

 

Take the lead up to the improbable but Billsy 59 yard FG.

 

You are a moron to call a TO, because:

 

a) You want Philly to rush to try and beat the Time Clock!

b) You want to save ALL available TOs ( if they do make it)so that your super freak QB can take THREE plays… remember that… in 20 seconds to come back with your winning FG or Hail Mary!

 

Bills fans 100% know he will do the wrong thing- ALWAYS!

[Bob Jones]

50 minutes ago, Gregg said:

Terry Pegula is the only one who can fix this. I doubt anything happens now but if the Bills miss the playoffs, then he has to do something. 

I dunno. Even if they miss the playoffs, he really doesn’t have to do anything....the NFL gold mine money will still keep rolling in.

 

Now, if he hopes to sell PSLs and season tickets, then for sure, before that shiny new ice bowl opens up, he'll probably have to do something.

[Einstein]

No Sean.

 

Many of us call out your mistakes in real time, before they hurt us, live in the game thread.

 

 

[RoyBatty is alive]

18 minutes ago, SectionC3 said:

Seriously.  He’s super intense and unapproachable in public.  But that doesn’t mean he’s a bad guy at all.  He probably just has everyone up his butt asking him about every blessed thing all the time and he likes to be left alone.  His job performance and his humanity are two completely different things. 

Is he?

 

Boy fan anger over this latest loss is near an all time high.  I already experienced my max frustration after the Mac Jones career day he had versus us a few weeks ago, I have since been talked off the ledge.

[Gregg]

4 minutes ago, Bob Jones said:

I dunno. Even if they miss the playoffs, he really doesn’t have to do anything....the NFL gold mine money will still keep rolling in.

 

Now, if he hopes to sell PSLs and season tickets, then for sure, before that shiny new ice bowl opens up, he'll probably have to do something.

 

The Bills will probably ask for fans to put a deposit down on PSL's in 2025 even though the stadium opens in 2026. The Jets and Giants did that when they moved to MetLife. 

[Rich Stadium Original]

If hindsight is 20/20, then McDermott needs a new optometrist, because HE is certainly not learning from his mistakes. 

I think he comes into the game extremely well prepared..look at the first half last night...then as the game goes on and you need to make further adjustments on the fly, he is unable to keep up.

It almost feels like a tidal wave overwhelming him in the fourth quarter..playing not to lose/soft zone/ill placed time outs and blitzes..and it comes back to bite him over and over.

Think:   Jets OT, Pats, Broncos, Giants(should have been a loss), and now Eagles.

What's the old definition of insanity?..doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different outcome.

 

Edited November 27, 2023 by Rich Stadium Original

[thenorthremembers]

21 minutes ago, SectionC3 said:

Seriously.  He’s super intense and unapproachable in public.  But that doesn’t mean he’s a bad guy at all.  He probably just has everyone up his butt asking him about every blessed thing all the time and he likes to be left alone.  His job performance and his humanity are two completely different things. 

My kid went to football camp with his son.    He happened to walk up and stand next to me while the kids were doing drills.   I chatted with him for a few minutes.  Didnt find him unapproachable or intense.  Then again I wasnt asking him for an autograph, a picture, or why he doesnt win games in overtime.  Tend to find if you treat people like human beings there isnt an issue.

[schoolhouserock]

Eh… this is just coach speak. What McD says there doesn’t really matter.

Consistent failures of the defense in clutch moments does matter. It matters significantly.

[Gugny]

28 minutes ago, TheyCallMeAndy said:

He doesn’t get it?

 

Fans who think you’ll get anything more than coach talk in press conferences don’t get it. 
 

He owes you and the reporters zero answers. 

I disagree, Donald.