What is Your Recipe for Philly Cheese Steak — I Assume that is THE Obvious Game Meal

[frostbitmic]

What kind of Steak?  ... Shaved steak I've found at the grocery store with the other fresh meat. So much better than frozen stuff they call steak.

 

What kind of Cheese? ... Swiss or Provolone

 

What kind of Bread? ... Hoagie roll

 

Condiments? ... Sauteed sweet peppers and onions

[muppy]

is it sacrilegious to just go to a Jersey Mikes and buy one hence no dishes and at least decent Philly cheese steak. Thoughts?

maybe  buying a philly sandwich from a company from New Jersey is itself sacrilegious 🤭

 

haha

Edited November 21, 2023 by muppy

[RyanC883]

20 hours ago, TheFunPolice said:

For steak use the best deli roast beef you can get 

 

To clarify, you obviously cook it up with peppers, onions and mushrooms then melt the cheese of your choice right into it... Cheddar and swiss blend is our favorite. Mayo on the toasted roll 

 

We also add spinach to the mix, again cooked right in with everything 

had me till the Mayo.  Agree roast beef is the way to go 

[hondo in seattle]

I like a good Philly Cheesesteak

 

But on game day, it's all Buffalo!  I wear my Bills gear and eat wings!

 

[WhitewalkerInPhilly]

1 hour ago, hondo in seattle said:

I like a good Philly Cheesesteak

 

But on game day, it's all Buffalo!  I wear my Bills gear and eat wings!

 

Just as a note, calling the sandwich a Philly Cheese steak annoys locals like when we hear Buffalo Wings.

 

So call them Philly cheese steaks! 

[Pete]

Wit wiz is wit garbage.  
 

Allentown cheesesteak >Philly cheesesteak 

[Mikie2times]

2 hours ago, muppy said:

is it sacrilegious to just go to a Jersey Mikes and buy one  nhence no dishes and at least decent Philly cheese steak. Thoughts?

maybe  buying a philly sandwich from a company from New Jersey is it self sacrilegious 🤭

 

haha

I love making Philly's but I'm going to be in Ohio. Nothing wrong with Jersey Mikes! 

[jethro_tull]

13 hours ago, mikemac2001 said:

Freeze it for like 20 mins before slicing/cutting

that is the secret- exactly how they do it in Philly.  

[zow2]

If I’m having a Philly Cheesesteak i’m definitely ordering it from somewhere, not making it.

[DrBob806]

Tailgate Cheesesteak

 

I use this one constantly, whether it's a tailgate or at the campground. Malcom Reed, he's never done us wrong!!!!!

 

I usually use a London broil, put it in the freezer for an hour or 2, then slice it up.

Edited November 21, 2023 by DrBob806

[Pine Barrens Mafia]

1 hour ago, Pete said:

Wit wiz is wit garbage.  
 

Allentown cheesesteak >Philly cheesesteak 

Calling horseshit on that, having actually lived in the Lehigh valley.

 

 

23 hours ago, Chaos said:

This is close to right. 

Fried onions (a slightly different thing than carmelized onions).  And if you want the true Philly experience, you have to find a way to acquire some Amoroso rolls. Every top cheesesteak place in philly uses these.  They have some magically property. (Philadelphia is my second home my whole life. Almost my entire family still lives there. American Cheese or certain home made cheese whiz's are legit substitutes for provolone. note- the rib-eye should be shaved. 

https://www.amazon.com/Amorosos-Italian-Style-Hoagie-Rolls/dp/B0CJP6CLDS

 

If they're in a plastic bag, they're already bad.

 

That's the hardest part of any Philly sandwich recipes. Getting the bread right 

[Pine Barrens Mafia]

Ok, let me lay out some hard truths here:

 

1) probably 90% of cheesesteaks use wiz or American.

 

2) usually, the only vegetable option on a cheesesteak outside of things like cherry peppers or pickles are fried onions 

 

3) roast pork as found at John's or DiNics is superior to cheesesteaks in every way. I like mine with provolone, rabe, long hots and extra jus

 

4) no, roast beef won't adequately substitute for thin chopped ribeye.

 

5) bread will make or break your sandwich. It should be soft and pliable enough to wrap the meat like a warm blanket, but crusty enough to not fall apart. Has to have good chew. Same rile applies to roast pork or quality hoagies.

 

6) also, WRAP the sandwich in something. Parchment, foil, wax paper. That way the sandwich doesn't fall apart 

 

Any questions, send PM.

 

 

 

 

Edited November 21, 2023 by Pine Barrens Mafia

[Tenhigh]

13 hours ago, WhitewalkerInPhilly said:

 

you say that, but it's freaking delicious

I have never heard of "stuck between your teeth" referred to as a flavor.

Let alone as delicious. 

[Mike in Horseheads]

I had leftover meatloaf

[Bad Things]

4 hours ago, hondo in seattle said:

I like a good Philly Cheesesteak

 

But on game day, it's all Buffalo!  I wear my Bills gear and eat wings!

 

I'm with you 100%, Honda.

 

We can talk all we want about Philly Cheese Steaks  (I miss them so much here in NZ) but... on gameday it's Buffalo Rochester food.

 

(However, I think it was my wife that lost us that Jaguars game, when I came home to see that she made Ranch dressing because we didn't have any Blue Cheese in the house.)

[AlfaBill]

17 hours ago, Boatdrinks said:

Gotta be ribeye and cheese whiz for starters. Add  peppers, mushrooms etc from there. 

 Are you serious with cheese whiz or a joke? I use that to repair tire flats 

 

[Gugny]

Shaved steak. Salt-n-pepa. 
 

Wiz - wit. 
 

Here’s the game changer … hear me out … Miracle Whip. 
 

You’ll thank me later. 
 

This is thanks to @CountryCletus  

[Low Positive]

4 hours ago, Pine Barrens Mafia said:

Ok, let me lay out some hard truths here:

 

1) probably 90% of cheesesteaks use wiz or American.

 

2) usually, the only vegetable option on a cheesesteak outside of things like cherry peppers or pickles are fried onions 

 

3) roast pork as found at John's or DiNics is superior to cheesesteaks in every way. I like mine with provolone, rabe, long hots and extra jus

 

4) no, roast beef won't adequately substitute for thin chopped ribeye.

 

5) bread will make or break your sandwich. It should be soft and pliable enough to wrap the meat like a warm blanket, but crusty enough to not fall apart. Has to have good chew. Same rile applies to roast pork or quality hoagies.

 

6) also, WRAP the sandwich in something. Parchment, foil, wax paper. That way the sandwich doesn't fall apart 

 

Any questions, send PM.

 

 

 

 

I don't know about Johns, but DiNics is the best thing that I have ever eaten. It has all the flavors that a human tongue can experience in one sandwich. I was at a conference at the convention center, and I was told by a local to go across the street and get the sandwich. I ate nothing else but that and Tomato pie for three days. I took my family on a detour on a vacation to NYC from Cincinnati just to get another sandwich. It's worth the 8-hour drive from Cincinnati to Philly just to get one. It's that good.

[Pete]

8 hours ago, Pine Barrens Mafia said:

Calling horseshit on that, having actually lived in the Lehigh valley.

 

 

 

My father's family moved to Lehigh Valley in the 50s, and I have frequented Lehigh Valley hundreds of times since the 70s.

 

Genos, Pats, Mike Schmidts, Jimmy's yada yada I have tried every Philly cheesesteak hotspot.  Cheese wiz is garbage.  Allentown uses real cheese, and sometimes a little sauce.  The Brass Rail (RIP) used to make a cheese steak omelette that was divine.  One of best cheesesteaks I ever had was Augies in Reading.

If you want a good hot dog, get to Yaccos.

Edited November 21, 2023 by Pete

[Boatdrinks]

5 hours ago, AlfaBill said:

 Are you serious with cheese whiz or a joke? I use that to repair tire flats 

 

Hahahahaha… completely serious. In Philly it ain’t a cheesteak if it doesn’t have cheese whiz.