If Josh went on IR do the Bills win a game?

[Bubba Gump]

NFW! 0'fer rest of the season, easily. This team is garbage without Josh. How in the ***** is Kyle Allen gonna win a game??

Edited November 6, 2023 by Bubba Gump

[90sBills]

40 minutes ago, Blackbeard said:

What is the actual point of this thread?  Except to clog the forum.

 

 

It’s a ridiculous scenario to point out how great Allen is and people shouldn’t criticize him after losses. 

 

 

 

 

[DabillsDaBillsDaBills]

I'd put the over/under at 1 win if Kyle Allen were to finish the remainder of the season as our QB. "Any given sunday" and all that could lead to a fluky win. Really hard to see a second win though. 

 

The defense without Tre, Milano, and Jones are a below average unit. Bottom 10 if not bottom 5.

 

On the offensive side we have Diggs, a superstar #1 WR, and that's about it. Kincaid might be a good TE. The O-line is average-ish. No running game to speak of.  

 

 

[Gugny]

1 hour ago, 78thealltimegreat said:

See agreement let’s shut him down and let Kyle take the controls 

Josh isn’t hurt. He’s lazy and he’s mentally weak. 

[billybob71]

One at most

[78thealltimegreat]

12 minutes ago, Gugny said:

Josh isn’t hurt. He’s lazy and he’s mentally weak. 

Yes a guy with a Mets mascot avatar knows a lot about mentally weak things point taken 

[Gugny]

2 hours ago, 78thealltimegreat said:

Yes a guy with a Mets mascot avatar knows a lot about mentally weak things point taken 

Other than making no sense at all, this makes a lot of sense. 

[78thealltimegreat]

53 minutes ago, Gugny said:

Other than making no sense at all, this makes a lot of sense. 

Thank you I try my best 

[ALG1130]

4 hours ago, Einstein said:

Some of you really need to watch some other NFL games. 

 

Allen is not perfect, but he is better than 30 of the other QB's starting right now. 

Every time we lose, his haters on this forum come out in full force and say this stuff. He is not the reason we lost last night, though he did have one INT(and no points were made off of it) but he is low hanging fruit for his haters in this forum. It's sad. The team is a hot mess right now. The offense has no identity. A lot of our defense died, and we didn't do jack **** in the off season to keep us competing with the teams that give us a hard time, or compete with the up and coming teams. We brought our ailing and old defense back, and Gabe Davis back, and our OL that sometimes plays okay and sometimes like utter crap. These are the reasons why we are 5-4, but again, it's easier to blame the QB.

[dorquemada]

18 minutes ago, Aimee75 said:

Every time we lose, his haters on this forum come out in full force and say this stuff. He is not the reason we lost last night, though he did have one INT(and no points were made off of it) but he is low hanging fruit for his haters in this forum. It's sad. The team is a hot mess right now. The offense has no identity. A lot of our defense died, and we didn't do jack **** in the off season to keep us competing with the teams that give us a hard time, or compete with the up and coming teams. We brought our ailing and old defense back, and Gabe Davis back, and our OL that sometimes plays okay and sometimes like utter crap. These are the reasons why we are 5-4, but again, it's easier to blame the QB.

 

Agreed, Allen is far from the main reason we are not good at playing football now.  We've come to rely on him to cover for a lot of other issues, but now that The Very Smartest People have coached that out of him, we're not going to get that, and he looks like an above average QB that isn't going to hero ball his way to victories the way he did before.

 

No, most of the blame falls on Beane and McD, and his little friend Dorkey.  We have an elderly and infirm D, and a whole lotta sub-JAG level guys on O, and a game plan that doesn't play to any existing strength, but rather is too cute by half on O, and just bad on D

[Hebert19]

No.  Not with this schedule. 

[oldmanfan]

I’m going to be brutally honest, and find it hard to say this as a 63 year fan of the team and normally one who leans towards the glass being half full:

 

i don’t think they’ll win another game even with Josh.  I think the offense is completely non-functional at this point, a combination of Dorsey not being up to the job, Josh not being Josh either due to injury or other factors, and a complete inability or unwillingness to run the ball.  And on defense the number of critical injuries has just been too much, and if Bernard is out for a time then we simply can’t hold up against some of the teams we’ve yet to play.

 

i hope I’m as wrong as I can be, but this team may have to hit rock bottom before riding from the ashes.

[Just Jack]

The Bills are 4-0 when Kyle Allen plays, and 1-4 when he does not.