The Big Lie we were fed that McDermott is a disciplined, prepared, hard worker

[Bruffalo]

Just now, BullBuchanan said:

Absolutely insane take. Best case scenario he's near the bottom of the top 15. there are 10 coaches I would take over him without hesitation and a good handful more that have a clear edge.
 

When I look at coaches that are definitively worse than McD, it's a very short short list. There are a lot of first year head coaches that will probably end up better too.

I get that we're all on edge about this season, but I don't know how you can believe what you just wrote.

[Bleeding Bills Blue]

Just now, BullBuchanan said:

Absolutely insane take. Best case scenario he's near the bottom of the top 15. there are 10 coaches I would take over him without hesitation and a good handful more that have a clear edge.
 

When I look at coaches that are definitively worse than McD, it's a very short short list. There are a lot of first year head coaches that will probably end up better too.

 

Lets Run down the list then...

 

 

Yes - Reid, McVay, Belichick, Shanahan, Pederson; Harbaugh, I'm iffy on McDaniel but I'll put him here

Maybe - Vrabel, Carroll, Tomlin, Saleh, O'Connell, LaFleur, Campbell, Stefanski, Taylor

No - Reich, Eberflus, Gannon, McDaniels, McCarthy, Payton, Ryans, Steichen, Rivera, Bowles, Daboll, Allen, Staley, Smith

[DuckyBoys]

Well his use of time outs and in game management is not good and his inability to get away certain tactics costs us games  He has a relatively healthy offense yet makes them go conservative putting more pressure onto his defense which is missing a ton of key pieces  I question how he handles personnel as well  Always be in the back of my mind thanks to Natham Peterman  He lacks the ability to grow and adapt  McDermott is the same  guy coaching this team like they were the 2017 team he inherited

[BullBuchanan]

5 minutes ago, Bruffalo said:

I get that we're all on edge about this season, but I don't know how you can believe what you just wrote.

I don't know how you can't. You're taking McDermott over Reid, Shanahan, Siriani, McVay or Belichick?

Edited October 27, 2023 by BullBuchanan

[GoBills808]

Just now, Bleeding Bills Blue said:

 

Lets Run down the list then...

 

 

Yes - Reid, McVay, Belichick, Shanahan, Pederson; Harbaugh, I'm iffy on McDaniel but I'll put him here

Maybe - Vrabel, Carroll, Tomlin, Saleh, O'Connell, LaFleur, Campbell, Stefanski, Taylor

No - Reich, Eberflus, Gannon, McDaniels, McCarthy, Payton, Ryans, Steichen, Rivera, Bowles, Daboll, Allen, Staley, Smith

Explain how McCarthy is so clearly inferior to McDermott 

[Generic_Bills_Fan]

9 minutes ago, BullBuchanan said:

Absolutely insane take. Best case scenario he's near the bottom of the top 15. there are 10 coaches I would take over him without hesitation and a good handful more that have a clear edge.
 

When I look at coaches that are definitively worse than McD, it's a very short short list. There are a lot of first year head coaches that will probably end up better too.

Under a microscope though supposedly great/good coaches frequently make terrible decisions also to be fair.  We’re just not putting other teams coaches under the same level of criticism understandably 

 

andy Reid made some absolutely disastrous decisions in that week 1 game 

 

There’s also a lot of terrible coaches in this league and many that are overrated in the same way you are criticizing McDermott so your numbers are way off regardless 

Edited October 27, 2023 by Generic_Bills_Fan

[BuffaloRebound]

I’d take reid, hoodie, mcvay, sirianni, payton, Harbaugh, Tomlin, Shanahan, Caroll, Vrabel, pederson, and maybe a couple more like the guys in green bay and detroit and a few others.  Mcdermott objectively fits in the 12-18 range and could be bumped down because he’s doing it with a top 5 QB.  

[Gregg]

1 minute ago, Bleeding Bills Blue said:

 

Lets Run down the list then...

 

 

Yes - Reid, McVay, Belichick, Shanahan, Pederson; Harbaugh, I'm iffy on McDaniel but I'll put him here

Maybe - Vrabel, Carroll, Tomlin, Saleh, O'Connell, LaFleur, Campbell, Stefanski, Taylor

No - Reich, Eberflus, Gannon, McDaniels, McCarthy, Payton, Ryans, Steichen, Rivera, Bowles, Daboll, Allen, Staley, Smith

 

I would put Tomlin in the yes category. He has been winning a lot longer than McDermott and has a Lombardi to show for it. Saleh belongs in the no category. He hasn't had one winning season yet.

[Bleeding Bills Blue]

Just now, GoBills808 said:

Explain how McCarthy is so clearly inferior to McDermott 

 

Put him in the maybe column if you want, but everything people dislike about mcdermott are things mccarthy does.  

[Big Turk]

It's amazing that at a time when we have the winningest team in franchise history that we still have endless complainers who would find something to complain about no matter what would happen.

 

Honestly, get a life dude. Go find a hobby.

[BullBuchanan]

1 minute ago, Bleeding Bills Blue said:

 

Lets Run down the list then...

 

 

Yes - Reid, McVay, Belichick, Shanahan, Pederson; Harbaugh, I'm iffy on McDaniel but I'll put him here

Maybe - Vrabel, Carroll, Tomlin, Saleh, O'Connell, LaFleur, Campbell, Stefanski, Taylor

No - Reich, Eberflus, Gannon, McDaniels, McCarthy, Payton, Ryans, Steichen, Rivera, Bowles, Daboll, Allen, Staley, Smith

McDaniel is a hard yes as is Saleh, I'd also take everyone in your maybe category except Carroll and O'Connell and I'd strongly consider Ryans, though he is a rookie. for me that puts McD as my 15th choice, best case.

[GoBills808]

Just now, Bleeding Bills Blue said:

 

Put him in the maybe column if you want, but everything people dislike about mcdermott are things mccarthy does.  

Yes, and McCarthy has a Super Bowl

 

 

[Mango]

22 minutes ago, GoBills808 said:

What if it's McDermott tho

 

The players like Allen and Diggs know their legacies are tied to the length of their playing careers, they have incentive to do what it takes to win now...where is that incentive from the HC? He has the job security to put it on cruise control in the off-season, focus on his defensive pet project, and win a few playoff games while he's got a top QB. 

 

From a general NFL franchise perspective I am fine with moving on from McD. I think he is a good HC, but may have run his course in Buffalo. These things happen when teams are legitimately close to winning championships. The team has topped out under Sean. I don't think they are doomed under him this season and this team can still get it done if they get hot, but I am OK with upgrading. 

My biggest pause in replacing any combination of McBeane is Terry Pegula. He has proven to be a historically bad owner in the NHL. It scares me that his 12 year NHL playoff draught could easily convert to a 25 year NFL playoff draught. 

 

I have a lot of criticism for our roster development, draft, and player utilization. Our constant redrafting of positions drives me crazy and is a huge part of why we struggle in a bunch of areas on the field.  I think this team is in trouble next year with our cap, rookie production, and upcoming UFA's. 

 

In season I am a bit harder on Allen because he is the only player who is in charge of distributing the ball to everybody else. Allen improving his game is the quickest and surest way for this team to get better immediately in season. We aren't moving on from Beane, McDermott, or Dorsey tomorrow, and even if we did it wouldn't make the team better. 

 

 

[I'm Spartacus]

I'll take Schottenheimer cause he was a former Bill 🙂

[Einstein]

McD has his faults but I don't think a lack of hard work is one of them.

[BullBuchanan]

Just now, Big Turk said:

It's amazing that at a time when we have the winningest team in franchise history that we still have endless complainers who would find something to complain about no matter what would happen.

 

Honestly, get a life dude. Go find a hobby.

When the bar is so low that the winningest team has never ever made a championship experience, the team is the problem, not the fans.

[HomeskillitMoorman]

18 minutes ago, EasternOHBillsFan said:

 

I have had people work for me who worked very hard at what they do, no discipline problems, prepared, but when it is time to execute they struggle. It's extremely frustrating but in the end you would hope that experience breeds familiarity and improvement. McDermott seems like he is not getting better...

 

I haven't seen that when it comes to the same issues over and over through a long period of time.

 

I don't see this as the same as physical performance where maybe a guy gets bad anxiety in the biggest moments and can't replicate what he can normally do well in that moment. You can literally map out your plans for those scenarios and especially if you are aware that you are struggling when it comes time to execute. 

 

I'm not a huge pure analytics guy because obviously this is a human game and I do think it discounts that to an extent..but I do like the of its philosophy on some of the aspects of game/time management, that it cuts the emotion out and maps out the best possible call when you methodically prepare for it before you set foot on the field when you are clear-headed and have looked at all the facts. But again all of this takes preparation and hard work. 

 

Think about his whole body of work, from the early years when he literally didn't know we needed a win over a tie in the Snow Game vs Indy, to the ways he's coached and all of his mistakes in all of our playoff losses - some of them recurring - it all points to a guy that just isn't prepared. He's not taking the time and putting in the work to learn from those mistakes that he's made. 

[Straight Hucklebuck]

5 minutes ago, BufBills83 said:

I hate reading this board right now, the takes are just totally out of wack.  The game was close because the last drive had incredibly unfortunately penalties in situations where (the facemask penalty) the play should have been blown dead, or, on the same drive, the TD AND the 2 pt conversion were deflected off of defenders into the arms of a receiver.  That isn't going to happen again.

You’ve watched a Jets team with Zach Wilson beat the 100% healthy Bills by chipping away all game.

 

You’ve watched the 1-5 Giants come within 1-yard from winning.

 

You saw a 1-5 Patriots team drive the length of the field in 1:20 for the GW drive.

 

You see a 3-3 Bucs team have a Hail Mary land inside the end zone with a chance to walk off on the last play of the game.

 

And the conclusion is that will never happen again?

[LyndonvilleBill]

11 minutes ago, Joe Ferguson said:

5 times he's been eliminated in the playoffs. 5 times Allen's years have been wasted 

I wouldn't say we've wasted 5 years. He's gained a lot of experience over that time.

 

If you really thought the Bills were Superbowl contenders for his first 3 yrs, that was a big mistake! 

[Bleeding Bills Blue]

1 minute ago, Gregg said:

 

I would put Tomlin in the yes category. He has been winning a lot longer than McDermott and has a Lombardi to show for it. Saleh belongs in the no category. He hasn't had one winning season yet.

 

My only issue with Tomlin is like... why is the offense SO bad for SO long?  5 straight years of bad offense now.  

 

And it is certainly not an asterisk... but his one SB win was the year brady blew out his knee and they got to avoid manning because of the chargers.