Giants @ Bills Postgame thread

[Beck Water]

21 minutes ago, mykidsdad said:

From the intensity I saw in the Giants I feel like Daboll and the team saw this is their kind of Super Bowl. Plus, that D sees this O in practice every day. We are blessed to survive this one. Phew.

 

There were many comments over the years about how ultra-competitive Daboll is. 

 

There was (unsubstantiated) talk that there was enough friction between Daboll and McDermott that Daboll might have wanted to take a parallel move if he wasn't hired as a HC which would surely provide additional "juice" to an already ultra-competitive guy

 

And, with last year's playoff team coming into the game 1-4 and looking, at times, undisciplined and unprepared, Daboll has been facing the criticism of the NY media, justly.

 

He had his guys fired up and ready to rock -n- roll.  Fortunately, they rocked but didn't roll us.

Edited October 16, 2023 by Beck Water

[Chandler#81]

Tre, Milano & D. Jones losses are too much. Both from a significant loss of talent & skill as well as significant financial impact. Very gutty performance by the rest of the team, but it was the Giants. We can’t play like this a beat NE -or anybody else, for that matter. I get that Diggs is often the 1st read on pass plays and when he’s immediately open, Allen throws him the ball. My issue is with Knox who isn’t an NFL starting caliber TE. Barely adequate blocker and very suspect hands. Davis isn’t worthy of a 2nd contract (Knox wasn’t either..) Barely adequate route runner with average to suspect hands. He is very good at staying inbounds along the sideline. So when we’re bitching about only Allen & Diggs being productive, it’s part scheme and part that no other starter is worthy. How to fix this? Bench Davis & Knox. Pick any other WR and start Quinton Morris with Kincaid. Has anyone seen Morris drop a pass he should catch since he’s been here? Davis is not the 2nd best WR on the team. He just CAN’T be! We just don’t know for sure how many others are better given they’re not being given opportunities. We’re not going to improve by keeping status quo with our WRs/TEs.

[Beck Water]

34 minutes ago, newcam2012 said:

I feel the same way. The Bills are

4-2 but it feels like 2-4. 

 

That sounds like a You problem.

[Low Positive]

The longer that I sit with this, the more I think that it’s better to win than to lose. Also, we have two week in a row where the Bills played against teams where opposing coaches had the playbook. That ends now. 

[ExiledInIllinois]

1 hour ago, dhg said:

This game was gross

But like a lot of gross things, it had a happy ending! 😆 

[MAJBobby]

1 hour ago, FireChans said:

AKA you were wrong.  We could've had Claypool but you and Beane were sitting on your hands thinking Sherfield was the answer LMAO

Claypool tada yada yada no better than what we have below Diggs. 
 

and sorry cupcake you can go read my posts to you. I was clear with what I said. 

[ExiledInIllinois]

2 minutes ago, FrenchConnection said:

The longer that I sit with this, the more I think that it’s better to win than to lose. Also, we have two week in a row where the Bills played against teams where opposing coaches had the playbook. That ends now. 

How did JAX get the drop? Do they have any ex-Bills players or coaches on the Jaguars?

[Low Positive]

2 minutes ago, ExiledInIllinois said:

How did JAX get the drop? Do they have any ex-Bills players or coaches on the Jaguars?

Chad Hall, WR coach. They get the playbook, don’t they?

[Richard Noggin]

10 minutes ago, arcane said:

Maybe the tv levels were just warped, but it sure sounded like the crowd did not get loud on the last giants drive until the last couple plays. I do not like night games in OP 

 

Perspective from the game on that drive: I kind of agree. The fans in general brought solid energy and noise all night, but on that drive the fans were weirdly slow to get riled up. 

 

Also, there were a decent amount of Giants fans in attendance. The similar jerseys and colors made it difficult to ascertain visually, but they were making some noise when the Bills were on offense.

 

[Royale with Cheese]

11 minutes ago, arcane said:

Maybe the tv levels were just warped, but it sure sounded like the crowd did not get loud on the last giants drive until the last couple plays. I do not like night games in OP 

I was at the game.  It wasn’t that loud.  I think it had a lot to do with the fans being frustrated.  Everyone around me was pretty pissed with the offense and had the mindset that we should beat this team by 20.

[Buffalo716]

1 minute ago, FrenchConnection said:

Chad Hall, WR coach. They get the playbook, don’t they?

They do not get to keep a playbook

[Beck Water]

16 minutes ago, Chandler#81 said:

Tre, Milano & D. Jones losses are too much. Both from a significant loss of talent & skill as well as significant financial impact. Very gutty performance by the rest of the team, but it was the Giants. We can’t play like this a beat NE -or anybody else, for that matter. I get that Diggs is often the 1st read on pass plays and when he’s immediately open, Allen throws him the ball. My issue is with Knox who isn’t an NFL starting caliber TE. Barely adequate blocker and very suspect hands. Davis isn’t worthy of a 2nd contract (Knox wasn’t either..) Barely adequate route runner with average to suspect hands. He is very good at staying inbounds along the sideline. So when we’re bitching about only Allen & Diggs being productive, it’s part scheme and part that no other starter is worthy. How to fix this? Bench Davis & Knox. Pick any other WR and start Quinton Morris with Kincaid. Has anyone seen Morris drop a pass he should catch since he’s been here? Davis is not the 2nd best WR on the team. He just CAN’T be! We just don’t know for sure how many others are better given they’re not being given opportunities. We’re not going to improve by keeping status quo with our WRs/TEs.

 

Agree with you that the Tre, Milano, and D. Jones losses are huge.  Rousseau is said to be playing with a broken bone in his foot (per @HappyDays source).  Von Miller is getting a lot of face time with the press, but not contributing on the field.  Dane Jackson out with a foot injury.  So our CB were Christian Benford and a guy who didn't have a game-day jersey 2 weeks ago.

 

Bottom line is I had no idea what to expect from the defense, and they stood up.  They delivered a performance that hopefully they can build on in coming weeks.  Because you're right, they'll have to.

 

Make no mistake - the Giants have not been a good football team this year, but they have 3 coaches who are intimately familiar with our offense and quite familiar with our defense as well.  They are easily the equivalent of a divisional opponent who knows us well, and more.

 

Disagree with you on Knox.  He is a starting caliber TE.  He is said to be playing in a brace, with a torn ligament and a broken bone in his hand.  He hasbecome quite a good blocker - when he has two hands.

I would have liked to see us continue to run 12 sets with Morris while Kincaid is out.  I think Morris has shown flashes, and should get more looks.  He runs receiver-worthy routes, and his blocking has improved.

 

I'm afraid Davis *is* the 2nd best receiver on the team.  Unfortunately.  I'm not saying he's enough.  The coaches see these guys in practice.  Fans love to believe that the coaches like to sit more talented players because....they're playing Candy Crush during practice?  They don't watch film?  They're dumb?  What I think is that Josh needs to see other guys than Diggs.  Cook, for example.  Sherfield could use some love when he's out there.  And we're paying Harty for more use than he's getting

 

8 minutes ago, ExiledInIllinois said:

How did JAX get the drop? Do they have any ex-Bills players or coaches on the Jaguars?

 

Yes, of course they do.  They have Chad Hall, and their ST coordinator is Heath Farwell.

Edited October 16, 2023 by Beck Water

[newcam2012]

36 minutes ago, RunTheBall said:

W. That’s all that matters this early in the season. Now let me complain…

 

I called this in the lead-up thread. This was a perfect Billsy game playing down to the competition. When do we ever blow the doors off a team when every single angle points to a Bills blow out? Never.

 

#1 problem is Dorsey. I held my tongue last year, I defended him in the first 3 games because his game plans were good, the last 3 games he’s absolutely sucked. It’s like he spends all off season coming up with a plan, teams adjust after a few games and his play sheet becomes 90% “Josh make a play”

 

This offense has NO identity. It looks like sandlot football where guys just call plays in the huddle. Zero set up, zero flow. It’s an abomination not to start running the ball until the second quarter. No one gets open besides Diggs and the play calling isn’t helping matters much. Too much shotgun, and that shotgun run on the goal line is a fireable offense.

 

I really think they’ve coached the dog out of Josh. There were at least 3 first downs Josh could have easily run and slid for where he hesitated and threw short or incomplete. This is a big problem. I agree we want him to take fewer hits but it’s obvious he’s thinking too much when there’s tons of green in front of him for easy yards. We need those legs in the right situations and I think Dorsey/McD have done him and the team a disservice by taking that away.

 

Love the W. Hope they figure it out on offense. Lots of games left to be played.

 

 

 

 

Well stated and well done. 

[Beck Water]

6 minutes ago, Buffalo716 said:

They do not get to keep a playbook

 

They do not get to keep a playbook, but a lot of football players seem to have phenomenal memories which I'm sure they carry over into their coaching days, and of course you can't take away a man's personal notes.

 

6 minutes ago, Royale with Cheese said:

I was at the game.  It wasn’t that loud.  I think it had a lot to do with the fans being frustrated.  Everyone around me was pretty pissed with the offense and had the mindset that we should beat this team by 20.

 

Well, if we hadn't missed 2 makeable FG, we would have scored 20

Edited October 16, 2023 by Beck Water

[ExiledInIllinois]

Thnx guys... I didn't know that JAX had the drop too!

 

[newcam2012]

26 minutes ago, mykidsdad said:

This is the post that sums it up well. Agree. The nfl is almost always close games decided by a bounce or a tip or a big play each and every time. We need to get to the playoffs and be playing well then. In the mean time I need to stock up on my heart medication!

This kind of thinking is a cop out and total bs. A fifteen point favorite doesn't often struggle and hold on to dear life to win. 

 

Yes there are close games every week in the NFL but not ones like today when you factor in all the variables. The Bills should have smoked the Giants from the opening snap. 

 

I'm happy the Bills won. It gives me hope for the rest of the season and hopefully post season. My fear is it's false hope, a wish, prayer, and a fantasy. 

 

Realistically this Bills have a really big uphill battle to compete with the likes of the top tier teams. I can't help but think by season's end Cinci and KC will be much improved. Can we say the same about Buffalo?

26 minutes ago, Beck Water said:

 

That sounds like a You problem.

Sounds like I'm not alone. 

[plenzmd1]

27 minutes ago, arcane said:

Maybe the tv levels were just warped, but it sure sounded like the crowd did not get loud on the last giants drive until the last couple plays. I do not like night games in OP 

No one does. But to critique people like me and the others that were there when you were not is something. 

 

and I just got home at 1:37 , and have an 8 hour ride home tomorrow. That game was exhausting from start to finish, crowd noise should be the last thing the Bills or those fans are worried about. 
 

[Westside]

2 minutes ago, newcam2012 said:

This kind of thinking is a cop out and total bs. A fifteen point favorite doesn't often struggle and hold on to dear life to win. 

 

Yes there are close games every week in the NFL but not ones like today when you factor in all the variables. The Bills should have smoked the Giants from the opening snap. 

 

I'm happy the Bills won. It gives me hope for the rest of the season and hopefully post season. My fear is it's false hope, a wish, prayer, and a fantasy. 

 

Realistically this Bills have a really big uphill battle to compete with the likes of the top tier teams. I can't help but think by season's end Cinci and KC will be much improved. Can we say the same about Buffalo?

Sounds like I'm not alone. 

What good does bitching do? Just enjoy the game.

[newcam2012]

31 minutes ago, Generic_Bills_Fan said:

Do only our opponents have injuries that matter? 

Great point. So you admit the injuries to Tre, Milano, and Jones will be difficult to overcome? 

 

The point is the defense played a terrible offense. Not there fault but it still has to be put in it's proper perspective. The defense still has a lot of work to do. It's nowhere near super bowl quality. 

[Low Positive]

19 minutes ago, Buffalo716 said:

They do not get to keep a playbook

But he knew it inside and out for three years. You would think that he sat down with the defensive coaches and let them know some tendencies.