RuntheDamnBall Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 Since we're all arguing about how Brady is or isn't top 5, who is?: I'd take: 1) Favre till the day he retires 2) McNabb 3) Culpepper - huge and he can run, when coached well he's got it 4) McNair 5) TIE: Brady, hate to say it. BUT, I think Pennington has got everything Brady's got besides the support network, and thus, the hardware. Hasselbeck is on the verge of something good, too. I see the 'Hawks in the NFC championship game. Jury's out on Vick.
drnykterstein Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 manning didnt have that bad of a game.
ajzepp Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 FINALLY someone recognizes the ACTUAL best QB in football......I wonder how long it will take some moron to bring up his interception last year now....no matter, you got it right - Favre rules.
Foxboro Mike Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 I swear I think I'm the only person alive who thinks that for the last 5 years that Favre is grossly overrated.
Guest Guest_dan_* Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 Are you serious?!? First, you forget Manning. Second, Pennigton is not even in the same class as Brady. And Culpepper... ? please, without Moss he's average at best. I think too many people let their personal feelings cloud good judgment. Look at Brady's stats, his W/L record, his Superbowl record - anyway you slice it Brady is currently one of the best QB's in the game. He's currently one of the top 2 or 3, period. And by the way, Favre was definitely a great QB; but is he currently one of the best in the game? I think that's definitely debateable.
RuntheDamnBall Posted September 10, 2004 Author Posted September 10, 2004 I swear I think I'm the only person alive who thinks that for the last 5 years that Favre is grossly overrated. 26125[/snapback] You can say that, but he does a hell of a lot (and always has) without top-flight receivers, and there is never a moment on the field where it doesn't look like Favre is in charge. If he were cut tomorrow the Bills would be absolute fools not to sign him. As for Manning, yeah, shouldn't have left him out.
CoachChuckDickerson Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 I swear I think I'm the only person alive who thinks that for the last 5 years that Favre is grossly overrated. 26125[/snapback] If it wasn't for the fact that he led the league in TD passes last year I might agree with you.
RuntheDamnBall Posted September 10, 2004 Author Posted September 10, 2004 Are you serious?!? First, you forget Manning. Second, Pennigton is not even in the same class as Brady. And Culpepper... ? please, without Moss he's average at best. I think too many people let their personal feelings cloud good judgment. Look at Brady's stats, his W/L record, his Superbowl record - anyway you slice it Brady is currently one of the best QB's in the game. He's currently one of the top 2 or 3, period. And by the way, Favre was definitely a great QB; but is he currently one of the best in the game? I think that's definitely debateable. 26133[/snapback] In the words of the Dude, that's like, your opinion, man. Montana is nothing without Rice. Brady is nothing without his system. Most of these guys are nothing without the coaching, the opportunity, and the right moment at the right time. What's your point? Favre has been consistently excellent, and watching him last year he still had the touch, and still plays with the fire he had in his mid-20s. I'd take him over Brady because he's been good over multiple coaches and systems, with often limited personnel. Brady has nothing to prove to me, he has two rings and MVP trophies. BUT, I think Pennington has the same capacity for quick decision making, fired-up leadership and awareness of the field that Brady has. Plug him in to that team and I think he succeeds as easily as Brady. Fire away.
soljc Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 The top 5 QBs I'd take right now: 1. Manning 2. Culpepper 3. Favre 4. Brady 5. McNair There's no way McNabb gets his name in that group, at least yet.
ajzepp Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 Could you imagine if Moss was on the Colts? I think Harrison is a stud, but Moss is in a league by himself.......Manning to Moss would be unstoppable.
stevestojan Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 1) Manning (MVP last year folks, and had a pretty damn good game yesterday) Before last nights sack at the end, no one would leave him off a top 5 list. 2) McNair 3) McNabb 4) Tom Brady 5) Delhomme (if anyone else saw him throw a football last night from about 30 yards out into a trash can, you'd know why he made this list)... oh, that, and the whole SB thing.
slothrop Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 1. Manning 2. Brady 3. Culpepper 4. McNair 5. Pennington Favre was in the top five - he has dropped off the past two seasons. Pennington is amazingly accurate, smart, and effective. I would have him as my QB ANY day.
Rico Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 I swear I think I'm the only person alive who thinks that for the last 5 years that Favre is grossly overrated. 26125[/snapback] I'm with you there. The only QB more overrated is Manning.
Foxboro Mike Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 Could you imagine if Moss was on the Colts? I think Harrison is a stud, but Moss is in a league by himself.......Manning to Moss would be unstoppable. 26176[/snapback] It's not Moss. It's not Harrison. It wasn't Montana. It wasn't Unitas. It wasn't Kelly. It wasn't Elway. IT WAS THE SYSTEM!!!!! Right, RunTheBall?
Guest Guest Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 1. Huard 2. Palmer 3. Flutie 4. Mirer 5. testaverde
Rico Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 Manning to Moss would be unstoppable. 26176[/snapback] Until the AFC championship game... maybe sooner depending on their draw.
Foxboro Mike Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 I'm with you there. The only QB more overrated is Manning. 26182[/snapback] The ballwashing Favre gets from Peter King (among others) is sickening. If Drew is The Cerebral Statue, and Peyton is Tin Man-ning, Favre has GOT to be BrettNeck (as in Redneck)
RuntheDamnBall Posted September 10, 2004 Author Posted September 10, 2004 It's not Moss. It's not Harrison. It wasn't Montana. It wasn't Unitas. It wasn't Kelly. It wasn't Elway. IT WAS THE SYSTEM!!!!! Right, Coach Chuck? 26186[/snapback] What the hell difference does it make? If you lost Brady and someone else stepped in and performed capably and the Pats got the same results, you'd be crowing about Belicheck's genius. Are you intimating that Belicheck / Weis are overrated and it's Brady that's the man? Again, Favre definitely is the man.
Foxboro Mike Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 What the hell difference does it make? If you lost Brady and someone else stepped in and performed capably and the Pats got the same results, you'd be crowing about Belicheck's genius. Are you intimating that Belicheck / Weis are overrated and it's Brady that's the man? Again, Favre definitely is the man. 26196[/snapback] Charlie Weis should have been flogged for his shameful playcalling last night.
RuntheDamnBall Posted September 10, 2004 Author Posted September 10, 2004 1. Huard2. Palmer 3. Flutie 4. Mirer 5. testaverde 26187[/snapback] Dude, don't count out Marinovich, Dan McGwire or David Klingler.
Recommended Posts