Boogie traded to Giants

[transplantbillsfan]

Does anyone know the exact terms of the trade?  When they're announced can the OP please post them so we don't have to sift through 25 pages of crap that complain about a guy being moved who was never going to contribute to this team this year, anyway?

[Tipster19]

4 hours ago, Back2Buff said:

When is Beane going to be held accountable?

That is a great freaking question!!! The return on these early round draft picks are absolutely garbage!!! To make matters worse to me is at that draft I wanted Buffalo to draft DT Christian Barmore and of course the Patriots drafted him to compound matters even more! We would have had to trade up for him but it would have been worth it! Now after 2 years we trade him for a late rd draft pick in next year’s draft??!!! This is too much, I like Beane but this has gone on far too long!

[billieve420]

2 minutes ago, transplantbillsfan said:

Does anyone know the exact terms of the trade?  When they're announced can the OP please post them so we don't have to sift through 25 pages of crap that complain about a guy being moved who was never going to contribute to this team this year, anyway?

 

All that was posted was late round swap in 2025. Not sure about the exact terms.

[billsfan89]

Bills cutting their losses on this one. I am glad that McBeane is able to do so. There was a log jam at DE. Even with Von on the PUP you had Floyd, Shaq, Groot and AJ there. You then have Von coming back whose going to displace someone on the roster if they were carrying five DE's. Shorten the rotation a bit and see how those four play. Getting even just a late round pick back and stock up on the 2024 draft where you will need to acquire more cheap talent to replace some of the aging components on the team. 

[SoTier]

 

3 hours ago, SWATeam said:

LOL, the Jets are certainly the pinnacle of drafting!  🤣🤣🤣

 

It's hard to miss with 2 picks in the top ten (#4 and #10) in 2022, although the Jests have a tradition of doing so, especially when drafting QBs.  They missed on 2 of their 3 top ten picks since 2018: Sam Darnold in 2018 and Zach Wilson in 2021. 

 

3 hours ago, ScottLaw said:

I get it…. Unfortunately for Beane his 2021 and 2022 drafts were trash… and fortunately for him he drafted the best QB in franchise history. 
 

Not saying he should be fired, but his last two drafts(and other non transactions) have played a part in holding this team back from reaching a SB. 

 

I think it's very unfair, Nostradamus, that you already know the results of the 2023 NFL season and haven't shared them with your fellow Bills fans on TSW.

 

3 hours ago, hondo in seattle said:

 

I think Terry already did.  Beane took a team that never made the playoffs and transformed it into a team that always makes the playoffs.  Terry counted up the successes and failures and rewarded Beane with an extension.  

 

One of the things that made Basham expendable is that Beane has successfully acquired other good DEs.  

 

I do agree, though, Beane still needs to get better as a GM.  He's given McD a good roster to work with, maybe a very good one, but not a great one. 

 

 

 

I would like to see the Bills try to improve their scouting/collegiate player evaluation staff(s).  I think that would probably improve the Bills drafts somewhat.  As long as the Bills are winning double digit games and drafting in slots #21-32 in the first round regularly, though, they're not going to match the draft successes of teams regularly drafting in the top 5-10 positions.

 

 

 

[SoCal Deek]

The other day I googled the Bills all time draft history. I think people are glossing over just how bad the past few years have been in terms of the actual draft and then retaining (or choosing to keep) players who showed some level of promise. It’s really a mess! If you compare it to the drafts that lead to the Super Bowl teams there’s no comparison. 

[DCofNC]

2 hours ago, Bangarang said:

I don’t see why it would as long as we keep winning double digit games and contend for a SB.

Because you are never REALLY contenders.  They haven’t even made the AFC Championship game. 

[ngbills]

13 minutes ago, K-9 said:

I don’t think I even remotely suggested that drafting well and making smart FA moves aren’t important ingredients for success. What I did suggest is that all the great drafting and FA signings aren’t enough to get you there without the difference maker at QB ( this is when someone invariably mentions Trent Dilfer and a couple other lesser QBs that won SBs). 
 

To sum it up, great QBing gets you thru times of poor drafting and FA signings far better than crap QBing gets you thru times of great drafting and FA signings. 

Agreed. A lot of folks want to give Beane a pass forever because he drafted Allen. That cannot always be the argument back when discussing how well Beane has done. Its like the only options are getting the QB and nothing else or everything else but no QB. 

[Nuncha]

4 hours ago, Coach Tuesday said:

Beane has been tossing his 2nd round picks in the garbage since he became GM.

He needs to pick better in the 2nd round then obviously.  Boogie wasn't going to make it with all the depth at his position.

[Dopey]

4 hours ago, Coach Tuesday said:

Beane has been tossing his 2nd round picks in the garbage since he became GM.

He's not the only gm trading players before their rookie contracts are up, but hey you found something else to complain about. Even 1st rounders (Simmons) have been traded before their rookie contract is up. 

[GunnerBill]

3 minutes ago, DCofNC said:

Because you are never REALLY contenders.  They haven’t even made the AFC Championship game. 

 

Yes they have.

Just now, Dopey said:

He's not the only gm trading players before their rookie contracts are up, but hey you found something else to complain about. Even 1st rounders (Simmons) have been traded before their rookie contract is up. 

 

But the Cardinals GM isn't the point of comparison. And he is tossing someone else's 1st rounders... Beane did that when he arrived too. Now he has tossed three of his own day 2 picks before the end of their 3rd season - Ford, Moss, Boogie. 

[ngbills]

2 minutes ago, SoCal Deek said:

The other day I googled the Bills all time draft history. I think people are glossing over just how bad the past few years have been in terms of the actual draft and then retaining (or choosing to keep) players who showed some level of promise. It’s really a mess! If you compare it to the drafts that lead to the Super Bowl teams there’s no comparison. 

Free agency has been very similar. Since Diggs and Allen there has not been a lot of success. Remember Star, Addison, Trent Murphy, Vontae "retiring Davis", Kroft, Howard, Beasley round 2, Brown round 2, Jefferson, Norman, Sanders, Breida, Obada, Haack and on and on. Miller was the big name deal and many questioned giving that kind of money to him...

[Dopey]

4 hours ago, BarleyNY said:

 

For a moment ponder what the Bills would look like and what the prevailing opinion of McDermott and Beane would be had the Browns or Jets selected Allen in that draft. 

Same group of people bringing this up. Beane drafted him, end of story. Dumb 💩. Just dumb.

[machine gun kelly]

2 hours ago, ColoradoBills said:

 

I guess that is up to Poona Ford making the team or not.  He hasn't exactly torn it up this summer.

Colorado, I believe Poona’s making the team.  He was solid not when Carrol went to a 3-4, but the year prior in the 4-3.  He penetrates well.  Besides what’s the over/under on how many games Phillips lasts.  He’s great when he plays, but I just don’t know how long he’ll last so that begs other considerations.  Once Von is back, some of Groot’s snaps may come inside.  Shaq may be expendable.

 

I trust McD.  He knows what he wants.

[Dopey]

11 minutes ago, GunnerBill said:

 

Yes they have.

 

But the Cardinals GM isn't the point of comparison. And he is tossing someone else's 1st rounders... Beane did that when he arrived too. Now he has tossed three of his own day 2 picks before the end of their 3rd season - Ford, Moss, Boogie. 

So?! It happens. To all GM's. Mountain out of a molehill, guys. Surprised you, of all people got a little riled up about it. 

[WyoAZBillfan]

20 minutes ago, SoCal Deek said:

The other day I googled the Bills all time draft history. I think people are glossing over just how bad the past few years have been in terms of the actual draft and then retaining (or choosing to keep) players who showed some level of promise. It’s really a mess! If you compare it to the drafts that lead to the Super Bowl teams there’s no comparison. 

The Rams got a SB without a ton of hits from the draft, at least not their own drafts. There are other paths. 

[SoCal Deek]

8 minutes ago, ngbills said:

Free agency has been very similar. Since Diggs and Allen there has not been a lot of success. Remember Star, Addison, Trent Murphy, Vontae "retiring Davis", Kroft, Howard, Beasley round 2, Brown round 2, Jefferson, Norman, Sanders, Breida, Obada, Haack and on and on. Miller was the big name deal and many questioned giving that kind of money to him...

On offense, the household names acquired via the draft are/is just Josh Allen.

 

On defense via the draft the household names would be Tre White and only recently Milano. 

1 minute ago, WyoAZBillfan said:

The Rams got a SB without a ton of hits from the draft, at least not their own drafts. There are other paths. 

No argument there. And it’s looking more and more like that’s the path the Bills have chosen. 

[SoTier]

4 hours ago, JayBaller10 said:

I said it before and I’ll say it again. I do think if we held a TBD poll on who to draft when the pick is up, we’d have a better drafting history than Brandon Beane. BUT only after the 2018 draft. Allen wouldn’t be on this team if it were up to TBD at the time 😅

 

Isn't that like claiming Miami has a better team than the Bills while ignoring the most important position, QB?

 

4 hours ago, ScottLaw said:

Not really… your rounds 1-2 are where you get the elite difference makers statistically… Beanes been a hot mess there and it shows on the field. 

 

It would be much easier for the Bills to hit on their first and second round draft picks if they regularly drafted in the top ten spot in both rounds, but I don't miss all the years of the season being over by mid-October ... or even late September.

 

4 hours ago, RunninRebel37 said:

Hmmm…when are folks gonna really be objective about his drafting. Outside of the 2018 draft, what’s he done? The core of this team was truly drafted by - wait for it…Doug Whaley 

 

Beane 1st & 2nd round picks 

 

2018- knocked it out the park obviously 

 

2019 - Oliver : description of mediocre/ Ford: bust 

 

2020- Diggs: he’s Him….not a draft choice but I’ll give it to Beane/ Epenesa: we’ll below average to borderline bust 

 

2021- Rousseau: average to slightly above average/ Bassham: bust 

 

2022- Elam: BUST/ Cook: TBD (but it’s not to question this pick since this teams used 3 valuable picks since 2019 to draft RB and not one has shown they’re an answer or complimentary for this team

 

Another Nostradamus!  I'm shocked that you haven't already pronounced Kincaid and Torrence doomed to be busts.

[DC Grid]

5 hours ago, Bangarang said:

Boogie was a bad pick at the time. Head scratcher from Beane. 

At the time a number of post draft write ups criticized Bean for taking Rousseau saying Basham was the better passrusher.  Basham rated well out of school and was easily worth a 2nd round shot.  It didn’t pan out in part because this roster is simply a lot deeper than any Bills roster has been for 20 years. 
 

 

Edited August 29, 2023 by DC Grid

[balln]

11 minutes ago, SoCal Deek said:

On offense, the household names acquired via the draft are/is just Josh Allen.

 

On defense via the draft the household names would be Tre White and only recently Milano. 

No argument there. And it’s looking more and more like that’s the path the Bills have chosen. 

https://www.si.com/nfl/bills/news/buffalo-bills-win-projections-regular-season-super-bowl-chris-simms-josh-allen
 

They got no impact players