TSW 1.0 Draft Poll - Who should the Bills select at #59

[Virgil]

Who should the Bills select at #59

 

There really weren't a lot of 2nd round grades at positions of need.  If you see someone missing that you think is a glaring miss, please post their name a reason why they should be added.  

 

Thank you

Edited April 12, 2023 by Virgil

[Virgil]

I almost threw up in my mouth when I made this pick, but Benton DT jumped out as the best value pick.  And it wasn't close...

[The Jokeman]

Just now, Virgil said:

I almost threw up in my mouth when I made this pick, but Benton DT jumped out as the best value pick.  And it wasn't close...

Benton is the best player you listed. I'd run up the podium to grab him. 

[gonzo1105]

I mean its between Benton and Kraft for me but there is a bigger need at DT now especially since this board took Addison in the first round as the weapon. 

[strive_for_five_guy]

Beane may need to figure out how to move us up for this pick

[Yantha]

I've got a 2nd round grade on Henley.  Tough call though....  Not really an MLB build.

I also went with Benton.

 

Can we trade Oliver for a starting OT or MLB straight up?  lol......

 

 

[mannc]

10 minutes ago, Virgil said:

I almost threw up in my mouth when I made this pick, but Benton DT jumped out as the best value pick.  And it wasn't close...

Assuming pick 27 was a WR, I agree...Or Kraft

[NeverOutNick]

I agree it has to be Benton but I don’t have an issue with Freeland or Henley either because of upside 

[Virgil]

Good news is, I may not to leave the poll open for long

[Dr. Who]

2 minutes ago, Virgil said:

Good news is, I may not to leave the poll open for long

Fella is a DT and former wrestler. Sean McD approves of this message.

[ROCBillsBeliever]

It wasn't really a choice: Benton or trade back. 

 

I went with Benton.

Edited April 11, 2023 by ROCBillsBeliever

[section122]

Benton was the other guy other than Downs that I was targeting with the Seahawks. So I'm not voting for him here out of principle lol. 

 

Drafttek offers up the additional people if you want some more positional flexibility:

Tyrique Stevenson CB Miami

DJ Turner NCB Michigan

Felix Anudike-Uzomah Edge KSU

Blake Freeland OT BYU

Ji'Ayir Brown S Penn St

[Virgil]

4 minutes ago, section122 said:

Benton was the other guy other than Downs that I was targeting with the Seahawks. So I'm not voting for him here out of principle lol. 

 

Drafttek offers up the additional people if you want some more positional flexibility:

Tyrique Stevenson CB Miami

DJ Turner NCB Michigan

Felix Anudike-Uzomah Edge KSU

Blake Freeland OT BYU

Ji'Ayir Brown S Penn St

 

I added a few.  Thanks boss

[John from Riverside]

Benton and it’s not close

[GunnerBill]

Well it looks like I am waaaaay off the consensus here. I don't even have a 3rd on Benton. I have a high 4 on him. He is the slowest guy off the ball every snap. I think he is a decent run stuffer but we are talking about the 59th overall pick. This is a guy who is barely in the top 100 for me (I need to count up but he is right around the point on my board this year where the 100th rated player is). He can be an NFL starting 1 tech but he has almost no use on passing downs. 

 

He would be a good replacement for Daquan Jones. Who was drafted in the 4th round too btw. He would be horrible value for me at #59. I get it he might have a higher grade in other places, I'm just one guy, what do I know? But there is no way based on my evaluation of his tape I'd consider him at this spot. 

 

The top 3 guys left by my board are not on the poll. Two of them are corners (which might be why), the other is a pass rusher who I'd take in an instant here. The best player left on my board who is on the poll is Keion White, but I'm not sure he is a perfect scheme fit for the Bills. Likewise the second highest graded player I have off the list Daiyan Henley. Not sure he fits what the Bills want to do. So my vote is for Byron Young, Defensive End, Tennessee. He DOES fit the Bills scheme, very well indeed. And they have had him in for a visit. Not only would I make him the pick, presented with this board I think he is who Brandon Beane would pick. 

Edited April 11, 2023 by GunnerBill

[Dr. Who]

2 minutes ago, GunnerBill said:

Well it looks like I am waaaaay off the consensus here. I don't even have a 3rd on Benton. I have a high 4 on him. He is the slowest guy off the ball every snap. I think he is a decent run stuffer but we are talking about the 59th overall pick. This is a guy who for is barely in the top 100 (I need to count up but he is right around the point on my board this year where the 100th rated player is. He can be an NFL starting 1 tech but he has almost no use on passing downs. 

 

He would be a good replacement for Daquan Jones. Who was drafted in the 4th round too btw. He would be horrible value for me at #59. I get it he might have a higher grade in other places, I'm just one guy, what do I know? But there is no way based on my evaluation of his tape I'd consider him at this spot. 

 

The top 3 guys left by my board are not on the poll. Two of them are corners (which might be why), the other is a pass rusher who I'd take in an instant here. The best player left on my board who is on the poll is Keion White, but I'm not sure he is a perfect scheme fit for the Bills. Likewise the second highest graded player I have off the list Daiyan Henley. Not sure he fits what the Bills want to do. So my vote is for Byron Young, Defensive End, Tennessee. He DOES fit the Bills scheme, very well indeed. And they have had him in for a visit. Not only would I make him the pick, presented with this board I think he is who Brandon Beane would pick. 

Switched my vote to Young. 

[NewEra]

🤮

 

in hindsight-  I would have drafted Anton Harrison and drafted Cedric Tillman.  
 

This being the case, I think drafting Byron Young, followed by Foskey would be best.  Benton would likely be the pick if it’s Beane….. but I just haven’t watched enough of him to take him over guys that I’ve watched.  I’ll watch some today

 

but I’d probably draft Freeland because Brown.  

Edited April 11, 2023 by NewEra

[aristocrat]

Benton is wrestler. Nuff said 

[NewEra]

9 minutes ago, GunnerBill said:

Well it looks like I am waaaaay off the consensus here. I don't even have a 3rd on Benton. I have a high 4 on him. He is the slowest guy off the ball every snap. I think he is a decent run stuffer but we are talking about the 59th overall pick. This is a guy who is barely in the top 100 for me (I need to count up but he is right around the point on my board this year where the 100th rated player is). He can be an NFL starting 1 tech but he has almost no use on passing downs. 

 

He would be a good replacement for Daquan Jones. Who was drafted in the 4th round too btw. He would be horrible value for me at #59. I get it he might have a higher grade in other places, I'm just one guy, what do I know? But there is no way based on my evaluation of his tape I'd consider him at this spot. 

 

The top 3 guys left by my board are not on the poll. Two of them are corners (which might be why), the other is a pass rusher who I'd take in an instant here. The best player left on my board who is on the poll is Keion White, but I'm not sure he is a perfect scheme fit for the Bills. Likewise the second highest graded player I have off the list Daiyan Henley. Not sure he fits what the Bills want to do. So my vote is for Byron Young, Defensive End, Tennessee. He DOES fit the Bills scheme, very well indeed. And they have had him in for a visit. Not only would I make him the pick, presented with this board I think he is who Brandon Beane would pick. 

Agreed on Keion.  Seems like a McD type too. Big with traits 

 

didn’t realize he was still available.  I think he goes early rd 2 maybe rd 1

Edited April 11, 2023 by NewEra

[MrEpsYtown]

8 minutes ago, GunnerBill said:

Well it looks like I am waaaaay off the consensus here. I don't even have a 3rd on Benton. I have a high 4 on him. He is the slowest guy off the ball every snap. I think he is a decent run stuffer but we are talking about the 59th overall pick. This is a guy who for is barely in the top 100 (I need to count up but he is right around the point on my board this year where the 100th rated player is. He can be an NFL starting 1 tech but he has almost no use on passing downs. 

 

He would be a good replacement for Daquan Jones. Who was drafted in the 4th round too btw. He would be horrible value for me at #59. I get it he might have a higher grade in other places, I'm just one guy, what do I know? But there is no way based on my evaluation of his tape I'd consider him at this spot. 

 

The top 3 guys left by my board are not on the poll. Two of them are corners (which might be why), the other is a pass rusher who I'd take in an instant here. The best player left on my board who is on the poll is Keion White, but I'm not sure he is a perfect scheme fit for the Bills. Likewise the second highest graded player I have off the list Daiyan Henley. Not sure he fits what the Bills want to do. So my vote is for Byron Young, Defensive End, Tennessee. He DOES fit the Bills scheme, very well indeed. And they have had him in for a visit. Not only would I make him the pick, presented with this board I think he is who Brandon Beane would pick. 

Yeah I have been back and forth on the edge guys. I don’t love Benton, but I get why people like him. 
 

I like Keion White, Foskey, they seem to be the long versatile guys McBeane loves.