Poll Closed (Former thread of TSW Draft 1.0)

[HappyDays]

14 minutes ago, LyndonvilleBill said:

What's the offer? I may change my vote.😁

 

This would be my offer to the Bills:

 

Raiders get:

Pick 27 (680 points)

Pick 91 (136 points)

Pick 137 (37.5 points)

=853.5 points

 

Bills get:

Pick 38 (520 points)

Pick 70 (240 points)

Pick 109 (76 points)

Pick 174 (20.2 points)

=856.2 points

 

For practical purposes:

-Bills move back from pick 27 to pick 38

-Bills and Raiders swap 3rds (Bills go up from the 28th pick to the 7th pick)

-Bills get an extra 4th round pick (7th pick in the 4th round)

-Bills and Raiders swap 5th round picks (Bills go down from the 2nd pick to the 39th pick)

[LyndonvilleBill]

2 minutes ago, HappyDays said:

 

This would be my offer to the Bills:

 

Raiders get:

Pick 27 (680 points)

Pick 91 (136 points)

Pick 137 (37.5 points)

=853.5 points

 

Bills get:

Pick 38 (520 points)

Pick 70 (240 points)

Pick 109 (76 points)

Pick 174 (20.2 points)

=856.2 points

 

For practical purposes:

-Bills move back from pick 27 to pick 38

-Bills and Raiders swap 3rds (Bills go up from the 28th pick to the 7th pick)

-Bills get an extra 4th round pick (7th pick in the 4th round)

-Bills and Raiders swap 5th round picks (Bills go down from the 2nd pick to the 39th pick)

Change pick 109 to pick 100 and I'd do it.😁. Glad I'm not Virgil or a GM.🤣

[Freddie's Dead]

What happened to Torrence?  Run the pick up there!

[DJB]

52 minutes ago, Virgil said:

We started at 17 options 

I realize that and I just think you limited the options too much. Should have been about 5 that’s all.

 

Just my opinion man and I appreciate you organizing this! 👊

[Virgil]

12 minutes ago, DJB said:

I realize that and I just think you limited the options too much. Should have been about 5 that’s all.

 

Just my opinion man and I appreciate you organizing this! 👊

No worries boss.  I typically eliminate the picks that have zero votes or went two hours without a vote.  It’s not science, but the best middle ground I could find 

[Sherlock Holmes]

8 minutes ago, Virgil said:

No worries boss.  I typically eliminate the picks that have zero votes or went two hours without a vote.  It’s not science, but the best middle ground I could find 

Trade for Crosby and Renfrow...

[NewEra]

55 minutes ago, HappyDays said:

 

This would be my offer to the Bills:

 

Raiders get:

Pick 27 (680 points)

Pick 91 (136 points)

Pick 137 (37.5 points)

=853.5 points

 

Bills get:

Pick 38 (520 points)

Pick 70 (240 points)

Pick 109 (76 points)

Pick 174 (20.2 points)

=856.2 points

 

For practical purposes:

-Bills move back from pick 27 to pick 38

-Bills and Raiders swap 3rds (Bills go up from the 28th pick to the 7th pick)

-Bills get an extra 4th round pick (7th pick in the 4th round)

-Bills and Raiders swap 5th round picks (Bills go down from the 2nd pick to the 39th pick)

That’s a good trade.  I hope we pull this off because Addison will be gone by the time we pick

37 minutes ago, Freddie's Dead said:

What happened to Torrence?  Run the pick up there!

We have 3 guards that are all better than our RT and you’d rather draft another guard?  I don’t get this

[JohnBonhamRocks]

2 minutes ago, NewEra said:

That’s a good trade.  I hope we pull this off because Addison will be gone by the time we pick

 

We have 3 guards that are all better than our RT and you’d rather draft another guard?  I don’t get this

 

On your first point, likely gone but would not be shocked if he fell. A run on QB and CB could happen. Plus I think anywhere from 3-5 WRs could go before him.

 

On your second point, I think one of those RTs who could either stay there or move inside would be a decent way to split the baby so to speak. Gouraige, Bergeron, Voorhees, Asim Richards, etc.

[chongli]

So only 93 people voted? I guess people were out this Saturday.

Edited April 9, 2023 by chongli

[Sherlock Holmes]

27 minutes ago, JohnBonhamRocks said:

 

On your first point, likely gone but would not be shocked if he fell. A run on QB and CB could happen. Plus I think anywhere from 3-5 WRs could go before him.

 

On your second point, I think one of those RTs who could either stay there or move inside would be a decent way to split the baby so to speak. Gouraige, Bergeron, Voorhees, Asim Richards, etc.

We gotta go Voorhees

[OldTimer1960]

2 hours ago, LyndonvilleBill said:

I'm just seeing a Slot guy that is no bigger,  faster or quicker than a 5th rnd pick we drafted last year that we didn't utilize fully.

I think Downs, Flowers or even Dell would eventually beat out Shakir.  I’m not dogging Shakir, I just think those three are a bit better.

[BigAl2526]

I missed the poll.  I would have chosen the trad3e back option.  I didn't like either player that were options in the poll.  If I had to pick a player given the way the first round fell, it would have been Anton Harrison. 

[JaCrispy]

54 minutes ago, chongli said:

So only 93 people voted? I guess people were out this Saturdy.

I came online tonight and never even knew the poll was up until it was closed…Would have liked Reid in the 2nd/3rd better than Addison in the 1st…Seems more like a typical Beane reach to fill a need type of pick…👎

[Freddie's Dead]

1 hour ago, NewEra said:

That’s a good trade.  I hope we pull this off because Addison will be gone by the time we pick

We have 3 guards that are all better than our RT and you’d rather draft another guard?  I don’t get this

 

We do?  Who are they?

[NewEra]

2 hours ago, Freddie's Dead said:

 

We do?  Who are they?

McGovern, Edwards and Bates are all better than Spencer brown to date. There is no debate  

[gobills404]

8 hours ago, KDIGGZ said:

Rookie receivers are usually terrible. I don't know if there is a rookie in this class that would even start for us. If he's playing it's because they spent such a high pick that they have to

JSN, Addison, and Zay Flowers would all be starting slot WR week 1 if we drafted them

[BillsShredder83]

11 hours ago, Nitro said:

The talent in this draft is lacking first round grades.  Approximately 20 as far as I can discern from the "experts".  I have been a trade down guy in years like this.  Find a partner and move back to the early second round.  There will be plenty of players to fill spots on the roster. 

the problem w/ that is you trade down value is lilkely well below what it'd typically fetch. im all aboard the addison train, but if forced to trade down take the ammo for 2024 draft