NFL draft rumors 2023

[Chicken Boo]

On 4/10/2023 at 7:46 PM, gonzo1105 said:

 

Extremely happy and surprised to see Jalin Hyatt on there.

[NewEra]

On 4/11/2023 at 7:44 AM, OldTimer1960 said:

I don’t think Avila will be there at pick 59.

 

All the WRs are compromises.  I could see Flowers or Downs helping in the slot, love they’re quick, but so small.  I would understand if they took Hyatt, but he is slightly built and is he a one-trick pony?  JSN will be a very good slot receiver- if he stays healthy and I would not touch Quentin Johnston- his hands and not-so-great contested catch ability are a big red flag for me.

 

None of the above are what people think of as great value for round 1 in most years.

 

I can’t find any player who’s likely to be available at pick 27 that they “gotta have”.

Agree with most of this, but I’d draft Johnston if he’s there based on traits.  Usually not a good enough reason to do so, but this draft blows and trading down may be tough.  
 

I’d be happy with any of the top 4 WRs @ 27.   I might even be ok with Hyatt and Downs.  If drafting Downs @ 27 means we don’t draft a DT, LB or CB, then I’m good with it.  
 

The more I watch of Hyatt- the more I dislike him.  But the speed trait would help me come around to it.  

 

The more I watch Downs, the more I love him.  The only thing I don’t love is his size. If we got 8 years of a Cole Beasley 2020 play and trust (with Josh) I’d be happy with the pick.  Could happen. He’s tough to cover.
 

The more I watch Kincaid, the more I want him.  I think he’d be my first choice over every pass catcher

 

[OldTimer1960]

1 hour ago, NewEra said:

Agree with most of this, but I’d draft Johnston if he’s there based on traits.  Usually not a good enough reason to do so, but this draft blows and trading down may be tough.  
 

I’d be happy with any of the top 4 WRs @ 27.   I might even be ok with Hyatt and Downs.  If drafting Downs @ 27 means we don’t draft a DT, LB or CB, then I’m good with it.  
 

The more I watch of Hyatt- the more I dislike him.  But the speed trait would help me come around to it.  

 

The more I watch Downs, the more I love him.  The only thing I don’t love is his size. If we got 8 years of a Cole Beasley 2020 play and trust (with Josh) I’d be happy with the pick.  Could happen. He’s tough to cover.
 

The more I watch Kincaid, the more I want him.  I think he’d be my first choice over every pass catcher

 

I like Downs very much and I think that he would provide a nice target in the short to intermediate area - sort of a bit faster Cole Beasley.

 

If that comparison is accurate, it would certainly help the offense, but can you not find reliable slot receivers in other ways and use the pick to help an area that isn’t as easy to address?

[whorlnut]

1 hour ago, NewEra said:

Agree with most of this, but I’d draft Johnston if he’s there based on traits.  Usually not a good enough reason to do so, but this draft blows and trading down may be tough.  
 

I’d be happy with any of the top 4 WRs @ 27.   I might even be ok with Hyatt and Downs.  If drafting Downs @ 27 means we don’t draft a DT, LB or CB, then I’m good with it.  
 

The more I watch of Hyatt- the more I dislike him.  But the speed trait would help me come around to it.  

 

The more I watch Downs, the more I love him.  The only thing I don’t love is his size. If we got 8 years of a Cole Beasley 2020 play and trust (with Josh) I’d be happy with the pick.  Could happen. He’s tough to cover.
 

The more I watch Kincaid, the more I want him.  I think he’d be my first choice over every pass catcher

 

I agree with all of this. Anything but defense for me. Show Allen good faith by getting him someone in the first. There are other rounds to “address defense”. The fact that we have to keep having this discussion every year with how much they prioritize defense is awful as it is. 
 

I also really like Zay flowers and Addison. Both would be good gets for our franchise qb. 

[NewEra]

Just now, OldTimer1960 said:

I like Downs very much and I think that he would provide a nice target in the short to intermediate area - sort of a bit faster Cole Beasley.

 

If that comparison is accurate, it would certainly help the offense, but can you not find reliable slot receivers in other ways and use the pick to help an area that isn’t as easy to address?

Sure you can.  You can sign Jamison Crowder and Isiah Mckenzie. 😉 

[whorlnut]

1 minute ago, OldTimer1960 said:

I like Downs very much and I think that he would provide a nice target in the short to intermediate area - sort of a bit faster Cole Beasley.

 

If that comparison is accurate, it would certainly help the offense, but can you not find reliable slot receivers in other ways and use the pick to help an area that isn’t as easy to address?

Not all receivers with the same traits are created equal. In this case, downs is a slot master who has excellent hands, elite speed, and runs precise routes. Why not get the whole package instead of waiting later?

1 minute ago, NewEra said:

Sure you can.  You can sign Jamison Crowder and Isiah Mckenzie. 😉 

This. 100% this. The fact that people say to wait and get a guy like that later is how you keep putting yourself in this situation every offseason. Time to bite the bullet and get an elite guy and have it fixed for 4-5 years. 

[HappyDays]

12 minutes ago, whorlnut said:

Anything but defense for me. Show Allen good faith by getting him someone in the first.

 

 

[NewEra]

13 minutes ago, HappyDays said:

 

 

Apples to Oranges.  One of the greatest play callers ever vs rookie OC that no one knows if he’s good.
 

We could afford to do that if we had Andy Reid. 

[whorlnut]

19 minutes ago, HappyDays said:

 

 

What is your point?

 

 

Reid can get by with anyone. He has Mahomes, the best oline, and the best TE in the game. What does Dorsey have?  McD has to have the very best every year. Reid trusts his abilities with less so the other side can get stocked up to give it the best chance. 

[HappyDays]

 

[FireChans]

7 hours ago, whorlnut said:

What is your point?

 

 

Reid can get by with anyone. He has Mahomes, the best oline, and the best TE in the game. What does Dorsey have?  McD has to have the very best every year. Reid trusts his abilities with less so the other side can get stocked up to give it the best chance. 

Reid doesn’t get by “with anyone.” We watched their patchwork OL get annihilated in the Super Bowl two years ago.

 

They get good players. We get less good players. They draft good OL players. We draft Spencer Brown and Cody Ford. They sign Juju, we sign Jamison Crowder. 

[ddaryl]

18 hours ago, whorlnut said:

Reid can get by with anyone. He has Mahomes, the best oline, and the best TE in the game. What does Dorsey have?  McD has to have the very best every year. Reid trusts his abilities with less so the other side can get stocked up to give it the best chance. 

 

 

Yeah I honeslty have lost some faith in our FO. We will clearly see if the light has come on for the FO at the end of this offseason, or its another summer/training camp of us manufacturing enough positives to get us to the start of the season with hope.

We have too many holes over drafted on the Dline, ignored OL accept for cheap FA acquisitiions and projects which IMO is the reason for Allen taking too many sacks and our running game never displaying dependable consistency
We clearly lack a bonafide #2 receiving threat and that needs to be addressed. That can be a TE or WR but we need another player who can come close to catching 80 passes ++ to go along with Diggs' 100 +

 

We should not have half of those issues at this point, there is always gonna be a need but we have too many. Now we have to play cap gymnastics and our draft record has been iffy which is why we have so many holes.

[BarleyNY]

12 hours ago, FireChans said:

Reid doesn’t get by “with anyone.” We watched their patchwork OL get annihilated in the Super Bowl two years ago.

 

They get good players. We get less good players. They draft good OL players. We draft Spencer Brown and Cody Ford. They sign Juju, we sign Jamison Crowder. 

 

Yup. I’ll add that it is worth noting what KC had on offense when Mahomes was drafted. The OL included Eric Fisher, Mitch Morse, Laurent Duvernay-Tardif and Mitchell Schwartz. Offensive skill position players included Tyreek Hill and Travis Kelce. Since Mahomes was drafted the Chefs have had 18 picks in the first three rounds. 12 defensive and 6 offensive players were taken. Some thoughts on this:

- The defense had some studs, but was more in need of upgrades at the time.

- QB, WR1, LT, C, RT and a stud TE were all under contract. Other than WR2/3 there were not a lot of glaring needs that would require high picks.

- Why neglect to u clyde what KC spent to get Mahomes, who obviously is an offensive player? Two firsts and a third. That would make it 12 D to 9 O. Still slanted toward D, but not by as much. 

[BillsShredder83]

On 4/11/2023 at 2:16 PM, section122 said:

Here is my draft thought that I have been thinking about recently and figure this thread is as good as any to put it.

 

How would people feel about DeAndre Hopkins and pick 34 for pick 27 with Arizona eating most of the salary.  This would be about the value of a 3rd round pick and get that 5th year option for Arizona.  It would then allow the Bills to solve the WR position and still be in a spot to fill the LB or OT need.

I'd feel like Arizona owner would have to piss test his GM for being high on crack at work lol

 

So Arz moves up 7 spots, loses Hopkins and eats most of his salary? How would you have to think about this at all as buffalo. You say yes and do whatever u can to get the deal signed off before the crack wears off

[GunnerBill]

The heavy rumour the last 48 hours is the Titans trying to trade up with the Cardinals to get to #3 for Richardson. 

[BillsFan2313]

12 minutes ago, GunnerBill said:

The heavy rumour the last 48 hours is the Titans trying to trade up with the Cardinals to get to #3 for Richardson. 

 

I think it would be a smart move by Arizona. You could probably still get Carter or the top o-lineman

 

Edit: for some reason I thought the Titans were picking 7th. Carter wont be there

Edited April 14, 2023 by BillsFan2313

[Solomon Grundy]

1 hour ago, GunnerBill said:

The heavy rumour the last 48 hours is the Titans trying to trade up with the Cardinals to get to #3 for Richardson. 

Giving up on Malik Willis already? Glad to see some teams are willing to admit to their mistakes 😎

[GunnerBill]

4 minutes ago, Solomon Grundy said:

Giving up on Malik Willis already? Glad to see some teams are willing to admit to their mistakes 😎

 

Or doubling down on it? I mean Richardson is basically Malik on speed. Bigger and stronger but with very similar questions. 

[TheBeaneBandit]

On 4/12/2023 at 2:19 PM, NewEra said:

Agree with most of this, but I’d draft Johnston if he’s there based on traits.  Usually not a good enough reason to do so, but this draft blows and trading down may be tough.  
 

I’d be happy with any of the top 4 WRs @ 27.   I might even be ok with Hyatt and Downs.  If drafting Downs @ 27 means we don’t draft a DT, LB or CB, then I’m good with it.  
 

The more I watch of Hyatt- the more I dislike him.  But the speed trait would help me come around to it.  

 

The more I watch Downs, the more I love him.  The only thing I don’t love is his size. If we got 8 years of a Cole Beasley 2020 play and trust (with Josh) I’d be happy with the pick.  Could happen. He’s tough to cover.
 

The more I watch Kincaid, the more I want him.  I think he’d be my first choice over every pass catcher

 

I'm thinking about the same. I've even warmed up to Mayer and possibly even Washington in the mix.

[BarleyNY]

41 minutes ago, Solomon Grundy said:

Giving up on Malik Willis already? Glad to see some teams are willing to admit to their mistakes 😎

New Oiltans GM this season - Ran Carthon. He might as well take a swing right out of the gate. If it doesn’t work, then he might still have time to take a second one.