Should we sign Andetson or Jack?

[Gugny]

1 hour ago, GunnerBill said:

I would bring Anderson in at the right price. I doubt they will though. He isn't exactly Mr process. 

The “process,” has jumped the shark. 

[Yantha]

1 hour ago, GreggTX said:

Miles Jack and Robbie Anderson could really help us if the conditions are right.

Robbie Anderson's speed must be respected and Miles Jack is a decent replacement for Edmunds.

I don't know their recent history. Are there off field issues or injury issues with either of them? Can we afford them? They'd certainly fill a couple big holes going into the draft allowing Beane to focus on the OL for a change.

Your thoughts?

Nah...  I think the WR room is already showing enough new faces and a draft might be enough to put us in great shape.  Don't want another ego in the room with certain expectations.

 

I'm not sure about Jack really, but if he's cheap, why not add a body to compete (might not make the team).

[billsfan89]

Wouldn't hate Jack to kick the tires on but Anderson is a headcase with low levels of production that's a hard pass.

[frostbitmic]

Robbie is now legally known as Chosen Anderson.

[Freddie's Dead]

Myles Jack (or Jyles Mack, as he was glossed in a draft thread) would be worth a vet min contract, if he can pass the physical.  Hard pass on Anderson, will never forgive him for the cheap shot on Hausch....wait....never mind, wrong Anderson....  Still a hard pass though.

[BillsShredder83]

4 hours ago, strive_for_five_guy said:

Anderson sucks

id sign him for the right price for one year only. hes a malcontent but very talented. his first year in CAR with Teddy B was very impressive, and he looked good on the Jets at times. I wouldnt hold too much against him for the CAR blowup, that staff was a mess last year, lockerroom had already been lost

3 hours ago, freddyjj said:

Yes degenerative osteoarthritis of the knee

dude held it together really well! at draft time they made it sound like a career ender in 5 years....... this was the Marcel Dareus draft. kudos to him

[cage]

5 hours ago, Doc said:

What about Golladay?

 

I have no idea what happened to Galloway w/ NYG, but that guy was a total stud on Lions

[TheBrownBear]

I can't believe that Jack is only 27.  It seems like eons ago that he was tearing it up as a two way star at UCLA.

[MasterStrategist]

13 hours ago, GreggTX said:

Miles Jack and Robbie Anderson could really help us if the conditions are right.

Robbie Anderson's speed must be respected and Miles Jack is a decent replacement for Edmunds.

I don't know their recent history. Are there off field issues or injury issues with either of them? Can we afford them? They'd certainly fill a couple big holes going into the draft allowing Beane to focus on the OL for a change.

Your thoughts?

Why on either? Please share your thoughts on why these guys are good fits.

 

1. Anderson: NO.  Too expensive/not a team player/we already signed 2 Fa Wrs/draft is still around the corner...want any more reasons?

 

2. Jack: go ask Steeler fans their thoughts.  Living in Pittsburgh, he didn't look good at all LY for them.  He's lost his athletic burst and is just a name at this point.  Again, the draft is a better option.

[L Ron Burgundy]

5 hours ago, MasterStrategist said:

Why on either? Please share your thoughts on why these guys are good fits.

 

1. Anderson: NO.  Too expensive/not a team player/we already signed 2 Fa Wrs/draft is still around the corner...want any more reasons?

 

2. Jack: go ask Steeler fans their thoughts.  Living in Pittsburgh, he didn't look good at all LY for them.  He's lost his athletic burst and is just a name at this point.  Again, the draft is a better option.

Yeah I remember something about Jack being pretty much done for because of this.  Lost a huge step already.   Shame really.

[Captain Hindsight]

On 4/3/2023 at 11:24 AM, Doc said:

What about Golladay?

That dude 100% quit when he got his money. Daboll was signing soon to be MVP candidates off the street to replace him