We don’t Need a WR

[Buffalo_Stampede]

Just now, The Jokeman said:

Renfrow under contract until 2026 with two voidable years. He's a good player but with a $13 million cap hit the next two seasons he might be a tad too expensive. 

You can move it around. Extend him a couple years. But you’re basically telling Gabe Davis he’s not in the future plans.

[The Jokeman]

Just now, Buffalo_Stampede said:

You can move it around. Extend him a couple years. But you’re basically telling Gabe Davis he’s not in the future plans.

I'm all for adding a slot WR and even advocating for us to sign Greg Dortch if he's an UFA. I'm not done with Gabe but we do need to add some more weapons as to me our own viable ones for next year are Diggs, Davis (as a 2/3) and Shakir. 

[Bob Jones]

4 minutes ago, Jerry Jabber said:

If your team is bringing in retired WR’s during the season because the WR’s on the team aren’t getting the job done (outside of Diggs), then those WR’s are garbage. Davis a not a #2WR, he’s a #3/4. McKenzie is a gadget player and not a consistent slot WR. Too soon to tell on Shakir, but banking on a low round draft pick to be an instant contributor was a horrible and stupid gamble.

From what I saw, Shakir looked pretty good, but seems like they hardly ever went to him.

[John from Riverside]

We can always use more talent, wide receiver

[whorlnut]

6 minutes ago, Jerry Jabber said:

If your team is bringing in retired WR’s during the season because the WR’s on the team aren’t getting the job done (outside of Diggs), then those WR’s are garbage. Davis a not a #2WR, he’s a #3/4. McKenzie is a gadget player and not a consistent slot WR. Too soon to tell on Shakir, but banking on a low round draft pick to be an instant contributor was a horrible and stupid gamble.

Agree. To me, bringing in those guys late was admitting they failed at WR. They bet on Davis and he didn’t step up. It was silly to not push him with competition in camp. That’s what they have preached since day one and they didn’t do it at WR this season. I can forgive them for McKenzie. Crowder was his competition and he went down early. But they need to add to the room and not with mid to late round picks. 

[Ramza86]

I meannnn...If we could get like Dhop here. Id do it in a second.

[Drew21PA]

Sheesh no

 

no we dont

 

having a wr is going to do nothing.

 

what would a line that gives Josh 3-4 seconds after drop back look like ?

 

one that can open a hole for the running backs?

 

oh what would that look like?

2 minutes ago, whorlnut said:

Agree. To me, bringing in those guys late was admitting they failed at WR. They bet on Davis and he didn’t step up. It was silly to not push him with competition in camp. That’s what they have preached since day one and they didn’t do it at WR this season. I can forgive them for McKenzie. Crowder was his competition and he went down early. But they need to add to the room and not with mid to late round picks. 

Not forgiving for McKenzie - he was terrible and coke Beasley not playing all year then coming in and making more of an impact is a clear indication McKenzie should be gone 

[Ridgewaycynic2013]

22 minutes ago, Motorin' said:

 

No dark sarcasm in the draft room.

A slight modification. 😁

[Ridgewaycynic2013]

28 minutes ago, Ridgewaycynic2013 said:

A slight modification. 😁

Hey, speaking of 'dark sarcasm', think Doug Whaley would sign on as a 'special consultant' for the 2023 draft? 🤔

*
Hello?....

[ColoradoBills]

I'm sure this WR debate will be raging all the way through the draft.

 

I personally believe that even with a better OL and OC scheme the Bills still need 1 improvement in the WR corp.

Some will want a 1st round pick at WR but it seems to me it will have to be around the 3rd round pick.

 

Hoping that the draft falls with something like this order.  OL, S, WR, OL for the 1st 4 rounds.

[transient]

I think Beasley was the last person Allen trusted for the underneath stuff. How many times earlier this season when he tried to take the easy completion did Singletary or McKenzie or Cook or even Shakir screw it up. As several posters have mentioned upthread, Beane re-signing a broken down Brown and a broken down Beasley was an admission that they misjudged their roster in replacing the production of Beasley and Brown/Sanders. Some of that was Crowder getting injured, but his history would tell you that's inevitable.

 

Davis is not a possession receiver. He's consistently proven he can't catch a contested ball that hits him in the hands. They may have been low probability plays, but how many of those deep 50/50 balls to Davis SHOULD have been completed. With a true #2 receiver, no matter how bad they looked, they win the Jets game with the ball Allen uncorked after spraining his elbow. There were at least another 5-10 examples of balls just like that that Gabe dropped. Davis was fine last season as a number 3 when he had a less talented corner covering him, but he can't catch the ball in tight coverage. I wanted to punch Romo in the face when he was repeatedly going on about "Big Game Gabe" on Sunday. Watch some film from this season, asshat.

[Donuts and Doritos]

1 hour ago, Rebel101 said:

We need an OC who schemes plays where not all the QBs targets are 20 yards down field on 3rd n short. Our receivers are getting separation. The passes have been off, or it’s been a low % pass schemed at the worst time. This team all year hasn’t taken what the defense has gave them and continuously just tried for the big play. Dorsey and Allen=Erratic 

 

Gabe's career catch % is 55.3%. Here's his season breakdown:

 

2020:  56.5%

2021:   55.6%

2022:   51.6%

 

That's not good enough under Daboll or Dorsey. We need a WR2 or better yet a second WR1, like the Bengals have going.

 

https://www.statmuse.com/nfl/ask/what-is-gabriel-davis-catch-percentage-career#:~:text=Gabe Davis has caught 55.3 percent of targets in his career.

 

Edited January 26, 2023 by Donuts and Doritos

[Low Positive]

That's good because the FA WRs are pure dog poop and the ones in this draft aren't much better. 

[whorlnut]

7 minutes ago, ColoradoBills said:

I'm sure this WR debate will be raging all the way through the draft.

 

I personally believe that even with a better OL and OC scheme the Bills still need 1 improvement in the WR corp.

Some will want a 1st round pick at WR but it seems to me it will have to be around the 3rd round pick.

 

Hoping that the draft falls with something like this order.  OL, S, WR, OL for the 1st 4 rounds.

WR, OL, OL, S or OL, WR, OL, S. Either way, S needs to come last. Benford will step in and do well as poyer’s replacement and Hyde will be back. Too many years of high picks on d while the offense is put on hold are the reason we are in this mess to begin with. 

[1onemangang7]

Need a running game to find out. Truth is fans like to point but everything starts up front and with a running game.

[ColoradoBills]

1 minute ago, whorlnut said:

WR, OL, OL, S or OL, WR, OL, S. Either way, S needs to come last. Benford will step in and do well as poyer’s replacement and Hyde will be back. Too many years of high picks on d while the offense is put on hold are the reason we are in this mess to begin with. 

 

I could live with that.  Like I said, this debate will rage all spring.

[whorlnut]

Just now, ColoradoBills said:

 

I could live with that.  Like I said, this debate will rage all spring.

It will. Haha. I just think the o needs to be addressed first before we look at anything on the defense. I could live with d in the third round, but with how McD can coach DBs, I think it makes more sense to take one later. 
 

Last year, I wanted Tariq Woolen in round 2 and breece hall in round 1 for that reason. McD is great at coaching DBs and we could wait and still get a really good one. Now…Woolen is in the mix for defensive rookie of the year and hall was running away with OROY before he got hurt. My point is…just wait on safety and trust McD to do what he does better than anyone…coach up DBs. Remember…poyer was a corner before he came here and we converted him to safety. 

[1onemangang7]

8 minutes ago, whorlnut said:

WR, OL, OL, S or OL, WR, OL, S. Either way, S needs to come last. Benford will step in and do well as poyer’s replacement and Hyde will be back. Too many years of high picks on d while the offense is put on hold are the reason we are in this mess to begin with. 

So Josh is your guy on 4th and 2? He already made it a point he's taking too many hits. You don't list a guy that cam break arm tackles. 

[JakeFrommStateFarm]

Yes we do.

 

We need an upgrade to Gabe and McKenzie.

 

Brown and Beasley will not be coming back.  Crowder was only on a 1 year deal.

 

Love to get a 4.3 guy that can run down the field to switch out with Gabe or be an upgrade to McKenzie.

[RyanC883]

Question is will one be available in 1st round. What we don’t need is Bean reaching and picking average players i.n the 1st.